4 ms·
> Either come up with an objective standard for merit that unions and management can agree on or go for the closest objective approximation - seniority and acce
by brianwawok 11y ago
> Either come up with an objective standard for merit that unions and management can agree on or go for the closest objective approximation - seniority and accept that some incompetent people are going to take a paycheck (the horror!).
But better people deserve more pay, not just older people. If that is the only argument, I would argue to just get rid of unions.
- crdoconnor 11y agoThe norm in most corporate and non-corporate environments that don't have unions is that the better person doesn't get better pay: the kiss ass does. Getting rid of unions does nothing to further merit based pay.
- brianwawok 11y agoWith unions - It literally does not matter what you do, you can't get fired, you get paid a set rate. Without unions - You negotiate a fair market value for your wage. You see no reason how without union could lead to better pay? How much could DHH get a job consulting Ruby for, vs someone who can hardly code?
- vidarh 11y agoDo you have any evidence that "better people" (according to what measurement?) generally are the ones who get better pay? The places I've worked it has generally seemed pretty arbitrary and largely down to who are best at negotiating. I've yet to work anywhere that have taken an anything remotely objective stance to measuring productivity and rewarding staff accordingly. The closest I've gotten was working for Yahoo, which at least tried to gather feedback, but the system was still inherently flawed by being based on managers ranking staff members without any kind of formalized system to ensure the rankings were objective. One year I was told that the group my team was in had too many "above expectations", and since two out of four on my team were ranked above expectations they had to arbitrarily drop one down to "meets expectations". (Not at any time while I was there did I see any kind of attempt at creating a uniform definition of what "meets expectations" or "exceeds expectations" meant; had a manager with high expectations? sucked to be you) Since that directly affected the raises I was allowed to allocate, and since the ranges were in percent of salary, that decision cost that person several thousand pounds a year on an ongoing basis that I was unable to adjust for the following years, because some HR drone was making the reports from line managers fit his idealised curve without making any attempt at verifying whether or not the reports matched reality. (as an aside: the origin of socialism, from Saint Simon, was the idea of a meritocracy)
- brianwawok 11y agoFor developers, better people tend to get better pay through job hopping. If an individual company only promotes brown nosers, there are other companies that are looking for talent. Source: Looking back at my college class. 10 years later - most of the people of MEH skill are at one level of job, and most of the people of high skill are at another job level. It's not a perfect correlation, and I am sure things like negotiation have a nontrivial impact.. but it is WAYYYYY better than looking at the staff of a local teacher union and pay rates.