6 ms·
> I don't see much of a need for unions anymore I find this bizarre to hear, given that the US has pretty much the weakest protections for workers of any devel
by vidarh 11y ago
> I don't see much of a need for unions anymore
I find this bizarre to hear, given that the US has pretty much the weakest protections for workers of any developed country.
- pc86 11y agoFor the record, if this were any internet discussion board other than HN, most people would read your comment as some form of "That's weird, you're weird, the US blows how could you not know that?" Not saying that's what you meant but some people here probably take it that way. That being said, most people in the US aren't clamoring for a lot of the "protections" you'll find in western Europe.
- uola 11y agoYet, almost every week there's someone writing online "this happened to me what do I do?". I mainly use my union for unemployment insurance, salary statistics, contract negotiation and conflict resolution. It's more like having a human resources department on your side than anything else. It's not "protections" that makes the difference, at least not for highly skilled workers, it's the knowledge and the bargaining power. And I somewhat doubt that US people don't want those "protections" because they are highly sought after when they are instead called "perks".
- vidarh 11y ago> That being said, most people in the US aren't clamoring for a lot of the "protections" you'll find in western Europe. I don't think most people in the US has any concept of the kind of protections you get in most of western Europe being possible.
- serge2k 11y agoA large number have been conditioned to think of it as evil/unworkable socialism.
- dkopi 11y agoThe biggest protection a worker has is his ability to quit and find another employer. All other "protections" usually end up costing you someway or another. Mandatory vacation days are converted to lower salaries. Maternity leave makes it more difficult for young married women to find a job. Mandatory Insurances and Pensions are simply calculated in to the "cost of employment", reducing the actual salary. Not being able to fire a worker means much higher hiring standards, and make it a lot more difficult for inexperienced workers to find a job.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoAll true, every protection has a cost. However its also true that the most vulnerable workers suffer grievously. Some protections are needed.
- masklinn 11y ago> The biggest protection a worker has is his ability to quit and find another employer. That's only ever a protection as long as your skills are valued and in high demand. Which means it's only a temporary protection, and only for a minority of the population. > All other "protections" usually end up costing you someway or another. The "other" is misplaced here, if all you have is the ability to quit, you have no stability[0], you have limited bargaining power (and are pretty systematically in a position of weakness), and the cooperative incentives with coworkers are very different, and arguably lower. [0] and things get worse if you own property (now your "protection" is tied to property markets), a partner (now your "protection" may be tied to fucking them over) or dependents
- segmondy 11y ago> That's only ever a protection as long as your skills are valued and in high demand. Which means it's only a temporary protection, and only for a minority of the population. What's wrong with that? If your skills are not valued or in high demand, you don't deserve any protection. Retool and equip yourself with valuable and skills that are in demand. Should I be protected because I dug my head deep into MSDOS or APL and refused to catch up to the modern day ubiquitous Unix systems and C++?
- tn13 11y agoAnd that is a good thing for economy in general. That is reason why American companies are able to innovate at faster rate, offshore work to cheaper countries and give better services to consumers. Because of lack of unions companies can hire people as they need and fire when they dont need which helps more people get jobs.