4 ms·
You've set up a strawman. There is no requirement that for a union to behave the way you suggest anywhere that I'm aware of. A union will generally be expected
by vidarh 11y ago
You've set up a strawman. There is no requirement that for a union to behave the way you suggest anywhere that I'm aware of. A union will generally be expected to provide certain protections, but there's a vast gap from having nobody to help you to reasonable representation is provided to even your positions vs. your employer to making the worst employees near impossible to fire.
E.g. the UK has plenty of strong unions, yet firing UK employees if you have good reason is shockingly easy for the most part seen with Scandinavian eyes. Some unions here are harder to deal with than others, sure, but it's also clearly possible to have unions that provide effective protection without making it impossible to get rid of people who do a bad job.
Part of the problem is that "doing a bad job" is sometimes used to hide cases of getting rid of people management doesn't like. It takes very few abuses of trust like that before you have a hardline union on the other side of the table that will not give a shit what arguments you have because they don't know whether or not the employer is telling the truth.
Once a relationship like that has soured, fixing it will be incredibly hard.
Remember that lives literally used to get lost over workers rights in the US (and still are many places in the world) - many unions today have a long institutional memory of people who died trying to gain concessions for their members.
E.g. AFL, now a part of the AFL-CIO was the instigator behind May Day as the international day for workers demonstrations, in part to continue the demonstrations for the 8 hour working day, in part in tribute to those who lost their lives in the Chicago Haymarket Massacre.
US unions in particular used to be on the forefront of this, and bore some of the worst brunts of violence, and many of the older US unions early became very much hardline for good reason.
Compare to unions many places in Europe where electoral success for left wing parties meant many of their demands where implement by law, allowing many unions to take a much softer approach and taking a lot of contentious issues off the table for union<->employer interactions because the hard stuff was dealt with by government.
- brianwawok 11y ago> You've set up a strawman. There is no requirement that for a union to behave the way you suggest anywhere that I'm aware of. A union will generally be expected to provide certain protections, but there's a vast gap from having nobody to help you to reasonable representation is provided to even your positions vs. your employer to making the worst employees near impossible to fire. Why do most/all Unions in the US end up this way? I am not sure you can say something is a straw man when literally most unions in a country act the same way. A straw man would be if I simply chose 1 union at random, like the Chicago Teachers Union. But choose more, look at the UAW or your local town teachers union. Seems pretty common.
- vidarh 11y ago> Why do most/all Unions in the US end up this way? I don't know. Do they? Why do most unions elsewhere not end up this way? Clearly there is something extremely toxic about the US relationship with unions given the kind of opinions we get to hear about them. It would be very interesting to understand exactly how that has come about. Part of it probably does have its root in the fact that the battle lines between unions and employers in the US were drawn very early, and that the US government never got the level of union-friendly representation that large parts of Europe did that forced employers to the negotiating table and that in many countries established relatively civilized relationships between unions and employers and/or shifted many of the conflicts away from the the unions. At the same time a lot of protection that may be extremely important to many US unionized workers doesn't matter elsewhere. Being fired in Norway, for example, is difficult, but if/when it happens, the social welfare system also makes it financially far less of a burden - there's much less of a reason for a union to take hardline positions on this in those circumstances than in a situation where the welfare system is as basic as it is in the US.
- mattmcknight 11y agoForget employers, most people's experience is with government employee unions. 35.2% of public sector workers in the US are in unions, only 6.7% of private sector workers. They are particularly powerful in local politics, and there is a history of negotiating benefits with the politicians they elect that become unaffordable in the future.