3 ms·
I'm not against unions, I'm against public sector unions. Private sector unions can do whatever they want. Let them strike, collective bargain, walk out, sit i
by koolba 11y ago
I'm not against unions, I'm against public sector unions.
Private sector unions can do whatever they want. Let them strike, collective bargain, walk out, sit in. The damage is isolated, the dollars involved are relegated to business owners and workers, and there's competition on both sides of the equation.
Public sector unions are were the trouble is at. Government work stoppages[1] are bullshit as are unfunded future concessions that will have to be paid by our children's children.
[1]: Yes we can all make jokes about how they're not doing anything to start but you know what I'm saying...
- afarrell 11y agoOne problem with getting rid of public sector unions is if you try to get rid of them all at once on a federal level, that lets them pick their symbolic battleground. They will probably choose Memphis, where Dr. King died supporting the right of public sanitation workers to form a union.
- riffraff 11y agobut then, how should public sector employees ask for better conditions? I am not a fan of public service, but public sector unions seem to be abstractly as reasonable as private ones.
- koolba 11y ago> but then, how should public sector employees ask for better conditions? The government already has to compete against the private sector. If wages rise there, whether through union action or labor shortages, then government will have to act accordingly. This works in the opposite direction as well (lowering wages/costs). The main issue is that the current government does not have an interest in long term planning. The current mayor/governor/steward is more than willing to push the true costs of things down the road because they won't be around to account for them. That's how you end up with massive unfunded pension obligations. Public sector unions are just one part of this problem albeit a big part.
- riffraff 11y ago> The government already has to compete against the private sector private companies compete against other private companies, by this reasoning unions are not necessary in the private sector either. Also, in some areas the government does not compete against the private sector, I think. Don't police forces or firefighters have unions in the US?
- gozur88 11y agoPublic sector unions have always seemed iffy to me. They put a lot of money into the political process, and unlike issues with competing interests there's really nobody on the other side, so they usually get their way. It's a case concentrated benefits and diffuse costs. In California politicians don't cross the public sector unions, because the unions provide money for poltical campaigns. Schwartzenegger tried to reign them in and was pretty much mortally wounded in political terms.