9 ms·
> When you grew up in a country where unions are healthy and working both for the employees and for the business, it is hard to see why Americans hate them so m
by pc86 11y ago
> When you grew up in a country where unions are healthy and working both for the employees and for the business, it is hard to see why Americans hate them so much.
Probably because most Americans (myself included) have never encountered a union that works for both the employees and the business.
My working-class father, twice, was working for a union and was forced to stop working for strikes, unpaid. My parents nearly lost their house when I was in elementary school because of it. One of those times the company actually shut down.
> You cannot talk about unions online effectively, Americans come out of the woodwork with super strange anecdotes and pro-business rhetoric.
Obviously America is more pro-business than most of Europe. But it seems odd that you define talking about something "effectively" and not being challenged on your opinions. I would argue it's hard (not impossible) to talk about unions online effectively because Europeans come out of the woodwork with super strange anecdotes and statements like a poor person disliking unions is inherently against their own self interest.
- revscat 11y agoI worked for UPS before going to college. It was a strong union shop, and I have decidedly different memories of it. When I slipped on a set of stairs and hurt my head, my manager immediately rushed me to the doctor and gave me the day off. The pay was good for an 18 year old without a degree, and I had full health/401k.
- sokoloff 11y agoThere are many non-union shops that would have done the same thing after your fall. In fact, I'd wager to say almost all of them with more than a handful of employees. (Mom and Pop places may have you "walk it off", but beyond that, through a combination of genuine concern for employees and HR/Safety policies, you'd be attended to.)
- programminggeek 11y agoOh there are many many non union shops that would NOT do the same thing and many places wouldn't offer health insurance or 401k at all.
- jtbigwoo 11y agoAgreed. I know anecdotes aren’t data, but here are some of the workplace injuries I witnessed before I got a white collar job: Hardees - frier accident=third degree burn. Management told her to finish the dinner rush. Two days later when her leg wasn't healing she went to the doctor. The owners never paid for the doctor, fought her workers comp claim, and fired her a few weeks after she came back to work. Little Caesar's - cook slipped and got a deep cut on his arm. The manager tried to keep him at work until he ruined a couple pizzas by bleeding on them. He drove himself to the emergency room. He quit the next month when the owners refused to pay for the emergency room bill. UPS - When I worked at a bookstore, the UPS guy who delivered to our mall came in with a terrible limp. A stack of boxes had fallen on him as they were loading the truck. His manager told him to complete his shift since they didn’t have any other drivers. He ended up needing knee surgery and having to fight the company for months for workers comp. To UPS’s credit, they didn’t fire him and he was still working for UPS when I quit the bookstore job. (I lived in a right-to-work state, so I don’t think the UPS drivers were unionized.)
- serge2k 11y ago> right-to-work I hate that phrase so much. Crushing unions described as protecting worker rights.
- arcticfox 11y agoThat just sounds like a nice person. Union/non union would never cross my mind if someone had a head injury. What would cross my mind, even if I was a bad person, is that it sounds totally illegal to make someone keep working with a head injury (regardless of unions). I don't know if it actually is, but I'm guessing mid-level UPS managers don't either.
- Chris2048 11y ago> statements like a poor person disliking unions is inherently against their own self interest Original was: > poorer Americans hate them, which is an affront to their own self interests The tone seems different to me.
- pc86 11y agoI didn't want to be accused of cherry-picking phrases to misrepresent someone's intentions, so I intentionally softened it a bit. But you're right.
- themartorana 11y agoBoth parents and wife are teachers, all are at odds with their unions, but are still forced to pay dues to an organization they'd prefer not speak on their behalf. I don't see much of a need for unions anymore (note: anymore - they obviously hold a very important place in US history) as long as the government is actively involved and enforcing things like OSHA. I am also strongly for universal healthcare and maternity leave, to name a couple issues which would solve a lot of what unions are in place for.
- vidarh 11y ago> I don't see much of a need for unions anymore I find this bizarre to hear, given that the US has pretty much the weakest protections for workers of any developed country.
- pc86 11y agoFor the record, if this were any internet discussion board other than HN, most people would read your comment as some form of "That's weird, you're weird, the US blows how could you not know that?" Not saying that's what you meant but some people here probably take it that way. That being said, most people in the US aren't clamoring for a lot of the "protections" you'll find in western Europe.
- uola 11y agoYet, almost every week there's someone writing online "this happened to me what do I do?". I mainly use my union for unemployment insurance, salary statistics, contract negotiation and conflict resolution. It's more like having a human resources department on your side than anything else. It's not "protections" that makes the difference, at least not for highly skilled workers, it's the knowledge and the bargaining power. And I somewhat doubt that US people don't want those "protections" because they are highly sought after when they are instead called "perks".
- vidarh 11y ago> That being said, most people in the US aren't clamoring for a lot of the "protections" you'll find in western Europe. I don't think most people in the US has any concept of the kind of protections you get in most of western Europe being possible.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>My working-class father, twice, was working for a union and was forced to stop working for strikes, unpaid. And how appreciative were you of the higher earnings yielded from him having a union that was actually prepared to strike? >Obviously America is more pro-business than most of Europe. Hence why average American wages are in decline while the 1% have gotten wealthier and wealthier and wealthier.
- pc86 11y agoI don't think the extra $0.75 an hour or so compared to the non-union companies was doing us any favors. Not to mention the large percentage of that difference that went to union dues.
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoWhen I worked as a union employee in a grocery store (cleaning toilets, mopping up spills) my union fees were $12 a month. I got paid $1.75/hour more than minimum wage, which is what people doing my job elsewhere would have gotten. Back then in Alberta minimum wage was $5 an hour, and I got $6.75 So even at the 15-20 hours a week I worked back then, that seems like a pretty good deal as I made back the union dues in a week. Not to mention the additional protections I got. And that was a pretty shitty union and a pretty shitty job.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoInequality is falling, not rising, due mainly to increasing incomes at the bottom. http://www.maxroser.com/economic-world-history-in-one-chart/ http://www.maxroser.com/economic-world-history-in-one-chart/ Wages within the US are in decline because of a shift to non-wage benefits. Worker compensation has done nothing but increase, there are just a bunch of laws (e.g. Obamacare) making it optimal for companies not to increase wages. https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/COMPRNFB https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/COMPRNFB The same trend towards within-country inequality can be seen in Europe, so any US-specific explanation is simply incorrect.
- 11y ago
- calibraxis 11y agoMore of my fellow Americans should read up on the IWW. Which was far more serious about workplace democracy than those relatively right wing, corporate-friendly unions that the US promoted. > But it seems odd that you define talking about something "effectively" and not being challenged on your opinions. The US is pretty fundamentalist: over 40% believe God created humanity 10,000 years ago [1] and many have disturbing beliefs about the "invisible hand" (of divine providence, of course), which they try to impose on others. So when people try to talk about these things, highly motivated fundamentalists clog the discussion with dogma, when they numerically dominate. These two forms of fundamentalism are strongly linked. ("Debt: the First 5000 Years" discusses this.) [1] http://www.gallup.com/poll/170822/believe-creationist-view-human-origins.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/170822/believe-creationist-view-h...
- brudgers 11y agoProfessional sports industries are examples of successful unionization that ordinary people are exposed more or less continuously. The US collegiate athletics industry offers a point of comparison for non-unionized work in the same occupations.
- themartorana 11y agoThese examples are so severe they're not analogous to the discussion. Pro athletes can still negotiate their own salaries and compensation packages beyond the union (the union negotiates the league minimum salary), and college athletes are basically slave labor.
- arcticfox 11y agoThe vast majority of college athletic departments lose money due to the vast majority of athletes being revenue losers. It's more like a salary cap system with the salary cap set at a scholarship. The "league" basically breaks even after making enormous profits on a few athletes, and losing on all of the rest. Disingenuous to call it slave labor, especially considering any athlete can quit at any time for any reason.
- themartorana 11y agoThe "league" has billion dollar revenue, multi million dollar coaching salaries, enormous capital expenditures, and more. They are not "break even." If in fact you believe that student athletes are not exploited to an unconscionable degree, here is just a little educational material to get you started. http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2011/10/the-shame-of-college-sports/308643/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2011/10/the-sham... https://www.amazon.com/dp/1591846323/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_TTMoxbWF9FGEF https://www.amazon.com/dp/1591846323/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_TTMo... https://youtu.be/pX8BXH3SJn0 https://youtu.be/pX8BXH3SJn0 http://time.com/3586037/exploitation-is-everywhere-in-mens-college-basketball/ http://time.com/3586037/exploitation-is-everywhere-in-mens-c... https://sports.vice.com/en_us/article/four-years-a-student-athlete-the-racial-injustice-of-big-time-college-sports https://sports.vice.com/en_us/article/four-years-a-student-a... http://www.thenation.com/article/ncaa-poster-boy-corruption-and-exploitation/ http://www.thenation.com/article/ncaa-poster-boy-corruption-... https://www.bostonglobe.com/arts/books/2016/02/21/does-ncaa-exploit-student-athletes/OnIF5KDFbt6oYACJlBBsSP/story.html https://www.bostonglobe.com/arts/books/2016/02/21/does-ncaa-... And I'm not alone calling it slave labor. I'm just one in a massive chorus. https://www.google.com/search?q=ncaa+slavery&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&hl=en-us&client=safari https://www.google.com/search?q=ncaa+slavery&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF...