5 ms·
There is another explanation of OkCupid's conclusions which is not discussed in that blog. The author of the blog even censored a comment pointing this fact out
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
There is another explanation of OkCupid's conclusions which is not discussed in that blog. The author of the blog even censored a comment pointing this fact out.
39% of black women are obese, compared to 23% of white women. Men prefer to date non-obese women.
http://minorityhealth.hhs.gov/templates/content.aspx?ID=6456 http://minorityhealth.hhs.gov/templates/content.aspx?ID=6456
- natrius 17y agoIf you take economic status into account, I'd bet that the difference is much smaller. I'd also bet that the distribution of economic status on OkCupid is more uniform among races than it is in society as a whole.
- jorgeortiz85 17y agoThe OkCupid blog post claims they were careful to control for attractiveness: We were careful to preselect our data pool so that physical attractiveness (as measured by our site picture-rating utility) was roughly even across all the race/gender slices. http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/2009/10/05/your-race-affects-whether-people-write-you-back/ http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/2009/10/05/your-race-affec... So even though guys were rating these black women to be as "attractive" as the non-black women in the sample, the black women were getting fewer responses from guys.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI stand corrected. Apparently OkCupid does a good job with their numbers.
- _pius 17y agoHard to believe that you're serious.
- natrius 17y agoI don't see what's unserious about it. It's an incorrect explanation of the effect at work, but it was still a valuable comment.
- _pius 17y agoThe comment essentially said: "black women are fatter than white women, which is why they don't do as well on OKCupid." That doesn't strike me as particularly serious or valuable, especially when a quick look at the OKCupid methodology would have ruled it out immediately.
- natrius 17y agoExpecting people to both read the linked article as well as go back and re-read the original post is a lot to ask. I definitely didn't, and I also forgot that OkCupid had already ruled out that factor. The comment was a hypothesis backed with data, which I consider serious and valuable.
- ErrantX 17y agoThe great thing about hacker news is that people aren't worried about voicing ideas backed up with data - even if in wider society you'd probably get denounced for it. In this case the rationale was voiced, considered and then rejected - all correctly. If OKCupid had NOT filtered for that data would you consider the comment equally valueless? This is a triumph of the scientific process IMO :)
- _pius 17y agoHeh, surprised that pointing out a dumb comment is gathering such a firestorm. Nothing against yummyfajitas but yes, this was a dumb comment: linking to some data doesn't change that one way or another. The great thing about hacker news is that people aren't worried about voicing ideas backed up with data - even if in wider society you'd probably get denounced for it. True. The problem is that if you're going to make an inflammatory argument, people are going to expect it to be well thought out. This particular one wasn't. Backing up one of your premises with data doesn't make the conclusions any more valid. To me, the comment was so obviously flawed and inflammatory at the same time that it looked like nothing more than a troll, implying that OKCupid is censoring the real reason for the apparent bias against black women on the site: they're just fat. Think about the argument for a second: it claimed that a pairwise comparison between black women and white women could explain black women's poor response rate as compared to all races. That doesn't make any sense. If OKCupid had NOT filtered for that data would you consider the comment equally valueless? Clearly not equally valueless, but still pretty dumb, given the reason above, and equally inflammatory. This is a triumph of the scientific process IMO :) I agree.
- mistermann 17y agoWhich explains why it is so hard to get an Asian woman to reply to you, they must be inundated with messages, presuming of course that men don't prefer obese women.