5 ms·
GCHQ's Boiling Frogs paper on software development
- nxzero 11y agoReminds me of the "Find Out if the NSA and GCHQ Spied on You" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11705650 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11705650
- nbevans 11y agoThis is very well written.
- cm3 11y agoIt might be dangerous to click on it, is there a tl;dr or text extract of it?
- dan1234 11y agoYou could probably use an online pdf-to-text converter[1] or view the PDF from within a virtual machine. [1]http://pdftotext.com http://pdftotext.com (no affiliation, first search result)
- cantagi 11y agoIt's OK - Github converts it to HTML. However, GCHQ could politely ask the NSA to force Github to give them the usernames and IP addresses that viewed the repo. Maybe use Tor?
- coroxout 11y agoIt didn't convert it for me. Oops. Well, they know who I am anyway. Hi again! (Edit: If you click on it from the repo file list at the top it converts it; don't do what I did and click on the link to download at the bottom of the readme)
- mseebach 11y agoI don't understand why everybody assumes GCHQ and NSA are completely inept amateurs. Getting a list of usernames and IP addresses from GitHub would have an insane signal to noise ratio - after all, there are plenty of perfectly legitimate reasons to want to read this document. It's much easier to go to HN and grab the usernames and IPs of people you can see taking a rebellious position in discussions about these organisations. Also, why would you assume that showing any interest whatsoever in Tor isn't going to land you on many more watchlists than reading a public PDF in GitHub?
- chinathrow 11y ago> Getting a list of usernames and IP addresses from GitHub would have an insane signal to noise ratio Or you could assume that they have that information already. Which I deem highly likely - private repos are a must-target for any intelligence service out there.
- nxzero 11y ago>> ..."GCHQ and NSA are completely inept amateurs." Assuming anyone is inept is inept, since even the inept get lucky.
- Spearchucker 11y agoActually I wasn't that impressed. I found it hard to focus on the text - there's a lot of government speak (like "ways of working") in there. Also, the author has a fixation on Conway's Law ("Conway" appears 40 times in the document), and everything else is really a spin on Wardley's evolution curve. Both are useful, to be sure, but there's nothing inherently profound or new here. This is (should, maybe?) be targeted at CxOs of big corps, and I think has some value there - if only it were more pithy (which is not the English way). There is also some irony in that they're saying "do away with big planning upfront" in the same document as "be big-data-driven". Big data needs big planning up front if it's going to be meaningful.
- cyberpunk 11y agoHah a PDF! Nice try, folks...
- matthewmacleod 11y agoYou know that PDFs aren't unsafe, right?
- tomelders 11y agoThis is a PDF from GCHQ we're talking about.
- matthewmacleod 11y agoThat makes literally no sense.
- conjectures 11y agoIt literally makes sense. Do you mean to say it is paranoid?
- matthewmacleod 11y agoNo. The origin of a PDF has no relation to the security or otherwise of the format.
- eterm 11y agoBut the viewer does matter. If I view using pdf.js, then not only does the "format" need to be unsecure (whatever that means), but it would require a browser vulnerability that's exploitable through javascript. At which point why go through the charade of a PDF at all?
- tomelders 11y agounless there's an exploit that we don't know about yet.
- cm3 11y agoWait, the GCHQ has a GitHub profile where they share a Graph Database engine. Interesting.
- bshimmin 11y ago"Gaffer's Accumulo Store is optimised for: Ingesting large amounts of data efficiently." For some reason that made me feel slightly nervous.
- sievebrain 11y agoWell it's not a secret anymore why GCHQ/NSA need large graph databases.
- jjp 11y agoThink it was announced a few months ago - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10732609 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10732609
- th0br0 11y agoThe sad thing is that they seem to be developing Gaffer on Windows. At least most files in the repo have the +x bit set...
- dotemacs 11y agoI like how all the members of that GitHub organisation have secret usernames: https://github.com/orgs/GovernmentCommunicationsHeadquarters/people https://github.com/orgs/GovernmentCommunicationsHeadquarters...
- tragomaskhalos 11y agoUnfortunately, Q saying "Now pay attention a09631" doesn't quite have the same ring to it. (pedants: yes I know it's not the same organisation).
- vidarh 11y agoEven so, I wonder how much information they accidentally leak this way. And how much effort they go through to keep such information leakage at acceptable levels.
- kinai 11y agowhen I just opened the pdf my xorg died (OOM) - I kid you not, first time that ever happend. funny coincidence..or is it? I figure now I got a reason to setup that new distro I was playing with burn all them compromised stuff
- rwmj 11y agoIf they're any good then they've modified your BIOS or Intel SMM.
- qazwsxedcyco 11y agoViewing the PDF using either the github viewer in Iceweasel 38 or downloading it and viewing it in Atril resulted in 2.1GB memory usage in a spare Jessie / MATE VM I had lying around. Close Atril and Iceweasel, ps -ef to check they're gone, look at top - and Xorg still holds on to 1.14GB. Kosher it ain't. Proceed at your own risk.
- qazwsxedcyc0 11y agoYou'd be well advised to, too. Couple of hours ago I created a throwaway account and commented here how Xorg held onto 1.1GB of memory after viewing the PDF with the github viewer and/or Atril. Tested and reproduced within a disposable Jessie / MATE VM. I offered an opinion that this wasn't entirely usual behaviour. The comment vanished. Not modded away, not "paled", just vanished. Nothing to see here, move along now.
- tomelders 11y agoThe only thing coming out of GCHQ that I want to read is all the stuff GCHQ won't let anyone read.
- branchless 11y agoRead your own email. They won't let you have that. Or write a transcript of a telephone conversation to the UK.
- chinathrow 11y agoWhat an ironic title (no, I won't read the PDF) - since we're here, sitting in a boiling hot tub, getting warm and cosy with GCHQ sitting next to us in the next tub, aka GitHub repo.
- B1FF_PSUVM 11y ago> we offer this internal research paper publicly, not to present policy or guidelines, but to stimulate debate. Is there anything these guys cannot do? "The name is Hacker, James Hacker, id 007BA54781, and I have a licence to stimulate." Personally, I suspect that organizational studies are like the famous 'killing joke': anyone who engages in it is at risk ... (edit: penny drops) ... uh, oh.
- chris_wot 11y agoCool, ITIL for spooks. Can't wait till I see the multi-edition version that emphasises continuous simmering. Then I can get certified!
- wyzellak 11y agohttp://imgur.com/a/pbazB http://imgur.com/a/pbazB Contents of this PDF, page by page, in JPGs.
- rplnt 11y agoMy question is, why?
- ianpurton 11y agoIt's a PDF from GCHQ. It's almost certainly loaded with a surveillance payload. Probably even some sort of of brainwave scanner.
- based2 11y agohttps://helpx.adobe.com/security/products/acrobat/apsb16-14.html https://helpx.adobe.com/security/products/acrobat/apsb16-14.... https://www.cvedetails.com/product/497/Adobe-Acrobat-Reader.html?vendor_id=53 https://www.cvedetails.com/product/497/Adobe-Acrobat-Reader....
- distances 11y agoPNG would be more fitting for content like this.
- linuxlizard 11y ago(In case folks don't know, PNG better for text because JPG's compression introduces "ringing" artifacts around sharp edges, such as the black/white transition of text.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ringing_artifacts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ringing_artifacts
- xrorre 11y agoJPGs are also a lot safer as PDFs can ping remote resources using carefully hidden beacon images. Although that said, I sometimes use this to see who opened my files. I once left hundreds of these on a very popular cloud hosting provider (not naming names), and somebody working there was stupid to open the PDF on a machine connected to the internet, thereby proving abuse by employees and proving any random stranger can access 'your' files in the so called 'cloud'. Look up 'honeydocs'. Some interesting articles about this technique
- cm3 11y agoI tried cloning the repo and it hangs at 67%, so I kinda got suspicious and killed git. Hmm, maybe it's just a large repo, but being from GCHQ one cannot help but feel suspicious.
- cm3 11y agoHas anyone been able to clone it?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- justinclift 11y agoMaybe a [dupe] tag, as this was submitted a few days ago too? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11674394 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11674394
- nicky0 11y agoDoes HN have tags now?
- justinclift 11y agoNot sure what you mean. Other duplicate posts have "[dupe]" added to their title, so why the hassle this time?
- nicky0 11y agoNot hassle, I've just never personally seen a [dupe] tag so I didn't know what you meant.
- wjd2030 11y agoAlso known as "How GCHQ infected the internet with a PDF trojan" lol
- branchless 11y agoGCHQ have a puff piece planted in the FT today about their new twitter feed. Anyone else going to roll over and forgive them for being the key component in Western citizen surveillance? Even if they have got someone to draw some cute pictures of frogs whilst trawling all my email? Not me.
- dTal 11y agoI really doubt this PDF is infected with anything like people are suggesting, but why is it on here at all? It seems incredibly empty and buzzword-y to me, interspersed with such charming insights as "It can make good sense to use external suppliers." Lots of talk about "disruption". It reads... well, it reads exactly like what it is, a vacuous corporate "whitepaper".
- branchless 11y agoBecause GCHQ are having a PR drive and they have enough accounts here to up-vote it to the front page?
- saganus 11y agoWould it really be a good investment for GCHQ to keep enough sockpuppet accounts on HN to upvote something like this to the front page? What would they gain? And if they really have an eye on HN, that would probably mean that NSA as well. If that is true, would it inhibit a community like HN to self-censor?
- branchless 11y agoThere have been leaks from GCHQ on influencing internet forums. https://theintercept.com/2014/02/24/jtrig-manipulation/ https://theintercept.com/2014/02/24/jtrig-manipulation/ What would they gain? Look at the slides, these are not normal people all working in a large circular building. What would Kennedy have gained from the Bay of Pigs crisis had it gone the other way? Group think is it's own force. Those slides are pretty disturbing IMHO as is pretty-much everything I've ever seen out of that org.
- saganus 11y agoDamn. I was not aware of this. I mean I was aware that spooks were aware of forums and watching them and such, but I never thought that a forum like HN would be a target for them. But I guess that after thinking for a bit HN could definitely be a valuable target. It's just hard for me to accept that a community I visit regularly could be under the influence of these organizations. Scary thoughts.
- lr 11y agovirustotal scan of document: https://virustotal.com/en/url/1ecad5426be630531d4e5c9d4091a04dc0012af72e710e6d3a88c6d64dea79c9/analysis/ https://virustotal.com/en/url/1ecad5426be630531d4e5c9d4091a0...
- awinter-py 11y ago> For example, an organisation building public service websites would not build a software configuration management system for itself, this is a commodity capability that is best served by well-established tools such as the open source Git. Hmm TARDIS metaphor is very cool though