4 ms·
Not that that survey is completely worthless, but it's also very far from a peer reviewed scientific study. And even among those, 1/3 turn out to be wrong. Sev
by BurningFrog 11y ago
Not that that survey is completely worthless, but it's also very far from a peer reviewed scientific study. And even among those, 1/3 turn out to be wrong.
Several things are obviously questionable:
* Relying of people self reporting their motives and history is problematic even for sober and sane people.
* Who made the study? What's the methodology? What are their incentives?
* Etc...
- raldi 11y agoA peer-reviewed scientific survey would reign supreme, but in the absence of one, we're left with a pretty-good survey that says one thing, and someone's gut feeling the says another.
- mseebach 11y agoHow do you know it's pretty good? It doesn't even appear to be sourced (looking at the Google Cache, I suppose a footnote could have been lost in formatting)? A non-peer-reviewed survey is just a gut-feeling with a budget, doubly so when we're reading about in a newspaper with an explicitly stated agenda on the subject.
- pessimizer 11y agoBut to put it in perspective, it was posted in response to a random person saying a random thing on the internet, citing nothing but what they thought that they might do if they were homeless.