7 ms·
Wow, that's just terrible thing to say. Really terrible.
by bogomipz 11y ago
Wow, that's just terrible thing to say. Really terrible.
- Crito 11y agoHe may be factually incorrect, but what is "horrible" about it? If he were right, wouldn't it be wrong for cities to offload their homeless problem on SF? If that were going on, what would be so "horrible" about sending them back, and asking all cities to take their fair share of the burden?
- azinman2 11y agoWhat's incorrect? And why assume I'm a he?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Crito 11y ago> may be I see others claiming you are incorrect, but haven't been arsed to actually read their sources to see who is actually right. Regardless, I see nothing "horrible" with what you've said.
- castis 11y ago> And why assume I'm a he? I'm curious. Why do you make this a talking point when you are, in fact, a he?
- azinman2 11y agoDo you know my gender identity? I don't believe we've ever met in real life. There's a big gender bias in tech already, and even within anonymous HN I see this in comments all the time where everyone is assumed male and few ever point it out directly. If we want balance in tech these kinds of assumptions need to get chipped away to make others feel welcome. It's the same thing with race, sexuality, etc.
- castis 11y agoedit: ugh, nevermind. your ridiculousness has nothing to do with gender bias.
- azinman2 11y agoThe form of a man? My point is there's no sex field next to my handle... It was just assumed. I'm guessing that you googled me to even start this discussion, and even then you have no idea what my gender identity is. These biases are the types that keep tech a men's club and make it hard for women to want to be around 99% guys.
- twoodfin 11y agoSan Francisco is not a sovereign state: It can't "send" US residents anywhere, they're free to go where they will. Similarly, SF can offer whatever "fair share" it likes, but can't force other cities to do the same.
- tomjen3 11y agoCouldn't SF enact a law to make it illegal to sleep on the streets? To not give an address to the police (could be a hotel room, etc), when asked? Then make a deal with some other place that has lots of cheap land that they handle the people who gets arrested for this (for a fee), which is still cheaper than rent in SF.
- twoodfin 11y agoPart a) is probably fine (though I am ignorant of the latest jurisprudence on what you can and cannot be required to tell police officers). I am certain that part b) is illegal. SF is free to arrest people locally for local crimes, but they can't 'extradite' those arrested to other states: If you're charged with a crime, it's your constitutional right to be tried "by an impartial jury of the state and district wherein the crime shall have been committed"[1]. [1] http://constitution.findlaw.com/amendment6.html http://constitution.findlaw.com/amendment6.html
- dragonwriter 11y agoAfter conviction, they could ship them off to somewhere else for whatever punishment they were sentenced to; alternatively, they could just agree to drop the charges after arrest in return for them accepting one-way bus tickets. Actually, something like the latter (with or without formal arrest) has happened a lot with the homeless and/or mentally ill (and, especially, the mentally ill homeless.) Though, IIRC, SF has more frequently been cited as a destination than a source of those types of maneuvers.
- azinman2 11y agoWhy? It's not like the SF homeless population all grew up here.... although in the 80s it did significantly increase once the institutions were shut down by Regan and they forced those without families into the streets. To me THAT is the terrible thing.
- DanBC 11y agoMany homeless people have a mental illnessed caused by being homeless, not the other way round.
- brandonmenc 11y ago> the institutions were shut down by Regan ugh, this old distortion. You're probably referring to the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act which, while signed into law by Reagan, was actually co-authored by two Democratic state senators and a Republican assemblyman, following the advice given at the time by the medical establishment - and under pressure from the public - that protections were needed to prevent the inappropriate over-commitment of people into asylums. The result was an "overreaction," and more patients were released than should have been - again, under the advice of medical professionals. [1] However, before this, people were sent to asylums - indefinitely - for reasons that today would seem barbaric. Alcoholics, the mentally retarded, people with anxiety disorders, or simply troublemakers whose families didn't want to deal with them anymore - locked up in asylums and the key thrown away before this legislation was passed. We might be suffering for a lack of mental health services, but over-committing people into asylums seems like the greater evil. The narrative that Reagan got into office and one day decided to boot everyone out onto the street for no good reason is just wrong. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/1984/10/30/science/how-release-of-mental-patients-began.html http://www.nytimes.com/1984/10/30/science/how-release-of-men...
- bduerst 11y agoWhy does it matter who wrote it? And yes, it does make it much more difficult to put people in a mental institution against their will - but it also is the unforeseen cause for what the OP described.