3 ms·
Most european languages are bound to disapear if Europe wants to achieve anything in common. You just can't if people don't understand each others, and if peopl
by cm2187 11y ago
Most european languages are bound to disapear if Europe wants to achieve anything in common. You just can't if people don't understand each others, and if people all have to speak a common language, within a couple of generations, French, Spanish or German will be that old dialect that some old people insist on speaking but that new generations don't understand anymore. Everything has a begining, a peak and an end. Languages too.
- zanny 11y agoLanguages are incredibly complex and information-intense things to learn, store, and maintain in ones brain. It almost feels aggressive for high-tower liberals to talk about how important it is that minorities preserve their languages, when there can be real costs to their economic prosperity associated with having to divide their childhoods between a "native" tongue that is for practical use worthless, and English. Even worse when English proficiency is harmed in favor of a less useful tongue. And that is not to say English is in any way a good language. It is dreadful. But language is not valuable for how well it pleases a gramaticist, but for its ability to facilitate communication, and right now English is so far and away #1 globally in that regard doing anything but trying to press every civilization to teach their citizens it is almost condemning them to poverty for some upper crust and downright selfish ideals of cultural diversity.
- realusername 11y agoLanguages are not only strictly for communication and not everything has to be linked to increasing economic value either surprisingly.
- Typhon 11y agoEurope wants to achieve anything in common It's unclear if "Europe" wants anything of the sort at this point, and you seem to assume that English would be the common language, which is not unreasonable since it's the one currently being used, but it's not politically acceptable, and it'll be worse if the UK finally decides to leave. Note also that Europe is probably the part of the world where minority languages are in better shape. E.g Catalan is spoken by 4 million native speakers, which is more than all of the native american language speakers combined.
- WildUtah 11y agoMayan and Nahuatl (Aztec) are each spoken by more than that before we even address the much more diverse South American languages. Europe is far from the most prosperous place for minority languages. SE Asia and Central America are far better.
- Typhon 11y agoI thought I'd written 'North America', but apparently I didn't, so yeah, point taken. Even if there are more minority languages in SE Asia and South America, I'm not sure they're treated better there than in Europe.
- seeing 11y agoCould there be other possibilities? Europe may want to achieve some things in common but not at the expense of not achieving other things not in common. Per the article: step outside the European worldview to see how cultural viewpoints elsewhere understand and express the value of multilingualism
- realusername 11y agoA unique european language is the last thing I wish to Europe. It's what's making Europe so rich in terms of culture. And a language is also representing a whole culture, there's is just concepts you can't express in other languages, it's not only communication. By the way, I know it's HN and people here are more internationalized and pro-globalisation than the average but the actual reality on the ground is that the far right and nationalism is growing in most EU countries and the current trend is to limit the EU, not expand it even further.