3 ms·
I'm a pretty lib guy, but let's be honest, could we have the iphone/macbook without apple? ibm? intel? Not everything can be done "fast", although I grant many
by noobermin 11y ago
I'm a pretty lib guy, but let's be honest, could we have the iphone/macbook without apple? ibm? intel? Not everything can be done "fast", although I grant many things can't be done slow, and as recent years have shown, more and more can be done by those "fast moving" companies also.
I think the question of whether big business should exist is at this point no longer really an open question. Instead, it is important for us to regulate them. Dissolving the concept of a big business is throwing out the baby with the bath water. I feel like even big businesses as institutions can provide some good in society that smaller organizations not always can.
- caoilte 11y agoThe usual argument is that Apple/IBM/Intel have innovated simply because they do not hold monopolies. If they were to achieve monopoly domination they would have a duty of care to their shareholders to spend the money that they currently spend on innovating on preventing competitors from entering the marketplace. Don't confuse monopolies with big business. Your electricity utility company, your cable internet/(?television?)/(?phone?) company are monopolies. Arguably, Google is a search monoopoly. Apple does not have a monopoly on smart phones.
- noobermin 11y agoThe article does not deal with monopolies but the existence of big business. Either that or I misread it.
- caoilte 11y agoYou appear to have misread the article. Not difficult. They use language very differently to the way we do today. A key line, 'They [representatives of big business] regarded with especial favor the establishment of the proposition that a combination must be in "unreasonable" restraint of commerce to be unlawful' They're basically saying, "phew just because the government went after Standard Oil, doesn't mean it will come after us next because we are also big." In those days they talked a lot about "trust busting". This is a monopoly when one company creates an artificial market or a cartel when several do.
- yuhong 11y agoThis reminds me of this RWT thread though: http://www.realworldtech.com/forum/?threadid=158487&curpostid=158487 http://www.realworldtech.com/forum/?threadid=158487&curposti...
- xenadu02 11y agoThe debate at the time was whether a business of a certain large size or that met certain criteria was a de-facto anti-trust violation or if it had to also engage in price-fixing and other monopoly behaviors. The court decided that it had to engage in direct monopoly behavior. Rightly or wrongly this is what allows a market with 2-3 players who own 90+% of all sales to function as an effective monopoly trust. It's a prisoners dilemma and all know there is nothing to be gained by actually competing - so they don't meaningfully do so (or put out a few fig leaves to pretend to compete). Because they never actually conclude an agreement to fix prices they aren't doing anything illegal. You could interpret the law such that a de-facto monopoly was illegal but that definitely has a lot of problems of its own. I'm not sure where I come down on this issue. Having everything dominated by huge corporations is bad for society overall, but it does provide a lot of opportunity for startups to disrupt things. Unfortunately money (thus power) is so concentrated we are increasingly seeing the legacy players turn to campaign contributions and political games to snuff out competition. Yet some amount of regulation is far preferable to the alternative. Definitely difficult to strike a good balance.
- maxxxxx 11y ago"could we have the iphone/macbook without apple? ibm? intel? " I am starting to wonder if we would have better tech if Apple (or Microsoft before that and IBM before that) weren't as dominant. It seems big companies do something new and push the envelope for a while but then they suppress other innovation.
- digi_owl 11y agoYou can see that with how MS kinda stagnated around the 2000s, and then surged forward from Vista onwards. Damn it, XP was their longest ever supported Windows release.
- dredmorbius 11y agoA large part of the reason we have Unix, and Linux, and MacOS, is because of AT&T. And the 1950s anti-trust consent decree. Which draws back to the first anti-trust actions against AT&T in 1917, for specifically refusing to interconnect local telco traffic across AT&T's network. Pretty much precisely the current network neutrality argument a century ago, as it happens. So, in 1956, yet another consent decree prohibited AT&T from selling "computer systems". Which, in 1969, Dennis Ritchy and Ken Thompson had created. Prohibited by law from selling this, they instead gave it away. The OS plus source code were rapidly adopted by many university campuses (who needed a cheap but useful computing platform), particularly M.I.T. and most especially, Berkely, who extended the system tremendously. The question of how and where and why innovations happen (and how useful they are) is a deep one. I'm leaning toward a mix of a fostering environment (sufficient resources for creativity), an unbiased selection process, and lowered barriers to useful contributions and applications. Whether "big business" specifically aids or retards that process depends hugely on many specific circumstances. In related areas, AT&T specifically opposed development of packet-switched networks as threats to its core business model. They didn't want to be just a data mule. Much the same as today's wireless telephony providers don't. I doubt that'll save them. http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2011/07/should-we-thank-for-feds-for-the-success-of-unix/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2011/07/should-we-thank-f...
- nandemo 11y ago> I think the question of whether big business should exist is at this point no longer really an open question. Uh, that wasn't never the question, not even in 1911. It was and is about anti-competitive business practices.
- digi_owl 11y agoI would say yes. For anyone tracking the mobile phone market, there was other companies coming up with devices that were damn close to the iPhone but didn't get the traction in the press that Apple products got.