36 ms·
> He ultimately could not bring himself to accept that a solution does not exist — this is not how his mathematical world operates. I don't understand this. Th
by StavrosK 11y ago
> He ultimately could not bring himself to accept that a solution does not exist — this is not how his mathematical world operates.
I don't understand this. There is a solution, that the problem is unsolvable. It's as much a solution as finding a valid permutation would have been. It just sounds like his nephew hadn't yet learned that proving unsolvability means solving the problem.
- brianwawok 11y agoNot sure they teach this very early in school. Or maybe touch on it a few times but not in depth.
- maxander 11y agoBut that's not how "math," as taught to and perceived by middle schoolers, works; as far as they've likely ever seen, a math problem is a question for which there exists an answer in the form of a sequence of arithmetical operations and a final number or equality. I doubt these students even recognized the concept of a "proof" in this situation- at best, they simply "saw" that it was impossible. But that "seeing" is simply a piece of everyday human reasoning, not the wholly different things that they associate with math classes and happy math teachers, so of course they feel like something is missing. It does sound like the teacher had a good idea- probably it was precisely to get students out of this notion that every math problem has the simple kind of answer they're used to. But it also sounds like the lesson wasn't taught with attention commensurate with its profundity- its easy to forget that these ideas which are so fundamental for us are still alien to most grade-schoolers (or for that matter, many high-school graduates.)
- StavrosK 11y agoI believe you are exactly correct.