3 ms·
People are commenting that this isn't really a hack because it exploited Android, rather than WhatsApp. That is exactly how exploits work in the wild, so the d
by AndrewKemendo 11y ago
People are commenting that this isn't really a hack because it exploited Android, rather than WhatsApp.
That is exactly how exploits work in the wild, so the distinction is false. If I can get the info I need through a side-channel, no matter what it is, it's still a vulnerability. Full stop.
If it really is just an Android problem and doesn't carry over to iOS, then if WhatsApp is truly dedicated to security over everything, then they should disable on Android until the vulnerability is fixed on the Android side.
Given that that course of action would kill the vast majority of WhatsApp's base I don't foresee that happening.
edit: Also if you read the article again you'll see that the focus is on Android/Google vulnerabilities - and they used WhatsApp to demonstrate it as it's the widest distributed and used "secure" system on Android.
- thevibesman 11y ago> Since WhatsApp added the Signal Protocol, it shows you which of your contacts who are unable to participate in end-to-end encryption because they are still on an old version of the app. Instead of disabling the app on Android, they could list all Android users this way.
- ams6110 11y agoWell they said SnapChat is vulnerable to the same attack. As a developer you generally have to assume that the end-user devices are trustworthy, since that is where you render the message into something the end user can see/read/use. You can assume the network is hostile, and that the sender may be hostile, but if your phone/PC is also hostile it's pretty much game over. Related -- never check your email or bank accounts on a public kiosk.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoAs a developer you generally have to assume that the end-user devices are trustworthy Absolutely not. If you are designing for security, literally nothing in the chain is assumed to be secure by default - including the BTS and carrier networks. As someone who has designed these systems I ALWAYS take the device security into consideration, for this exact reason. As I mentioned elsewhere, the defense in depth model covers this in detail. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defense_in_depth_%28computing%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defense_in_depth_%28computing%...