5 ms·
America’s Never-Ending Oil Consumption
- jschwartzi 11y agoAmericans don't love cars and big homes. The way our cities are arranged and our land is zoned make it difficult to live without a car and a big home.
- tinbucket 11y agoI absolutely agree about cars, but in what way is it "difficult to live without" a big home for the average American? How does zoning make that the case?
- rplst8 11y agoIt's mainly about the fact that the job market is so fluid and what will sell. Tax policy benefits those who own houses. When you invest in a house and you don't know where (geographically) your career will take you, the ability to unload your real estate quickly is a really attractive. Big houses are en vogue and the economy and job market reinforce that.
- stale2002 11y agoThe biggest effect of zoning rules and regulations is to prevent developers from building highly dense and efficient neighborhoods. If zoning rules allowed developers to build larger, taller, and more numerous buildings, we would all have better, cheaper, and more transportationally efficient housing.
- ams6110 11y agoZoning rules are largely the result of the desires of the local residents.
- nine_k 11y agoExactly; local residents totally don't like housing in their area become cheaper, because their own houses would become cheaper. They use their privilege of being local residents to constrain other property owners' rights in their area, preventing them from building denser housing.
- dredmorbius 11y agoBuilding codes (which also dictate housing dimensions) are highly influenced by building and lending institutions. Zoning as well.
- dredmorbius 11y ago1. The small homes simply aren't being built. 2. They're not being built where the jobs are. Take the SF Bay Area and the SV jobs/housing crisis. Much the problem is that many of the jobs (still) are on the Penninsula and South Bay, while high-density housing (and only somewhat so at that) is in San Francisco. Santa Clara and San Mateo counties are largely suburban sprawl, with very few exceptions. Transit stinks (virtually no usable busses, little rail other than CalTrain and VTA), and even riding a bicycle is a dicey proposition with traffic densities and poor bike lanes. 3. Schools. In the US, housing choices, especially for families, are driven by school access. Good schools are typically suburban. E.g., sprawl. 4. Urban blight. Less an issue now than previously as there's a flight back to cities, but the dense early housing belts around older US cities build in the period 1900 - 1945, that is, before the automobile was widely used, tended to be less attractive due to crime, poor schools, and, well, the attraction of a cheaper, brighter, cleaner outer-suburban belt. The point remains that denser housing stock is also quite often older housing stock. 5. Building codes. Various factors, including safety, appliances, access (doors, steps, stairs, etc.), have tended to make homes larger. One of the reasons the "tiny homes" movement has a preference for building on trailer platforms is that trailer and mobile home requirements are far less stringent. 6. Lending availability. Again, for various reasons, financing is more available for newer, larger, and suburban homes (additional reasons including redlining and government policies from local to national levels have also existed historically). Older and smaller homes are harder to buy, and to sell. 7. Builder and architect familiarity. There's an existing workforce and skillset around the "conventional" product. Building experimental, high-density, high-efficiency, or exotic (often, ironically, highly local or available) material homes pushes you to odd skillsets. It's a bit like basing a tech startup on a little-used programming language or operating system. 8. Major builders and planning departments. The "easy" direction for major builders, and for city and county planning departments, is what they know and what they know will sell. Given that a major builder might easily account for a substantial amount of all home construction nationwide, that's not an inconsiderable concern. The upshot is a lot of structural obstacles to constructing a widely different housing stock, particularly doing so throughout an entire town (let alone a city), which is what would be required to bring up overall densities. One household building one small home won't make the difference. You'd have to change an entire community's mindset. That's ... challenging.
- yardie 11y agoI'm going to disagree. Americans by big cars by choice. When gas was $4/gal the Chevy Suburbans stayed at home. Now that it's down to $2/gal they are everywhere. There is no policy in any state stating 5m+ vehicle is a necessity. As to big homes. You can't find much under 2000sqft unless it was built in a different era. I've got a listing open right now in another tab 2bd/3.5ba. Seriously, WTF?!
- seanp2k2 11y agoMaybe you rest one end of a cot on the edge of the tub and the other on the toilet?
- jdietrich 11y agoThat low-density sprawl didn't come about through diktat. Americans chose it, mainly because of racism. Newly-constructed suburban municipalities used exclusionary covenants and redlining to contain black people in the inner cities. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoSome of that was (emphasis was) pretty explicit racism, but some of it was about cost per square foot of land and the desire for the new. I'd say that things are moving away from racism fairly rapidly.
- torpfactory 11y agoOil is great. From an engineering perspective it is energy dense and relatively stable and easy-to-use. I can put a small amount of it in my pickup truck and drive up the side of a mountain. A pilot can fly to the other side of the world in a few hours time with a plane powered by the stuff. A few hundred years ago that level of mobility and conevnience would have been seen as a magic power - the domain of witches and demons. I don't think Americans are addicted to oil. We are addicts of the capability, the freedom, if you will, that oil enables. In the short term limits on oil limit our ability to do the things we want, many of which require oil to enable. When an alternative technology comes along which gives us the same capability and is cleaner and (most importantly) cheaper, we will gladly move on from oil. I personally would even support a tax on oil (and thus marginally reduce my freedom) in order to invest in whatever is next and facilitate the change before we permanently impair the earth. Alas my fellow countrymen do not have it in their hearts to tax themselves for this purpose.
- gedy 11y ago> Alas my fellow countrymen do not have it in their hearts to tax themselves for this purpose. It's not about heart, it's that most people aren't doing well enough to care for more taxes. Reduce asset prices for housing, NIMBY politics, etc and maybe they would.
- kinnth 11y agoNot everything should revolve around cost. There are other factors to consider. Also these freedoms that you talk about come at a cost to others, so consider this the next time you want to drive over that hill.
- orangecat 11y agoNot everything should revolve around cost. Whether it should or not, it does. If you altruistically reduce your gas consumption, you're decreasing total demand and thus lowering the price. That makes it profitable for the evil corporation down the street to use even more of it.
- rlanday 11y agoGetting people to use less oil is easy. Tax it to make it more expensive. I don’t mean to say that that would necessarily be good policy, but it would be a hell of a lot more effective than just giving a speech.
- dredmorbius 11y agoThat's one of the lessons of economics that seems to be largely lost: To discourage use of something, make it more expensive (or less efficient). To encourage use of something, make it less expensive (or more efficient). Increasing efficiency increases overall consumption: the Jevons paradox (1865). Jevons was also an early peak-fossil-fuels theorist, though his area was coal (oil had just been discovered, the 4-cycle internal combustion engine was 20 years off).
- ryanwaggoner 11y agoWhere do those taxes go without creating a situation where the beneficiaries of the tax no longer want oil consumption to drop? And most alarming, how do you avoid politicians (who are best suited to solve the collective action problem here) not wanting to give up big sources of income that the taxes provide?
- jakozaur 11y agoPolitician speaches has usually little to no impact on dayily life habbits. What can help is the policies. E.g. Higher gas tax, denser cities with better public transport, higher taxes on cars...
- castratikron 11y agoIf you're an American and you're interested in supporting a carbon tax, check out the Citizen's Climate Lobby: http://citizensclimatelobby.org/ http://citizensclimatelobby.org/ What they're trying to implement is a revenue-neutral fee on carbon emissions: a fee is collected on fossil fuels at the source (the well, the mine, whatever), and the money from the fee is placed in a fund. At the end of the year, the money is then redistributed to every citizen. About 2/3 of citizens would net positive on this fee.
- ryanwaggoner 11y agoSo 2/3rds of citizens are incentivized with hard currency every year to want MORE carbon emissions?
- castratikron 11y agoThe fee is aimed at and energy producers and investors. The fee would increase steadily every year, which would signal them to divest from fossil fuels. The dividend part of the plan is put in mainly to make Republicans happy, since no Republican is ever going to support a new tax (Al Gore couldn't even increase the gas tax by 5 cents).
- dredmorbius 11y agoThat's an interesting exploration of the past 50 years or so of US domestic oil consumption politics. For a rather more detailed history of oil, I recommend Daniel Yergin's The Prize. It's rather the epic book (there's also a PBS/BBC miniseries), and it wraps up in 1992 with the first Iraq War, but really hammers home the impact of oil. As to consumption, conservation, price, encouragement, and discouragement, the problem's complicated. As torpfactory notes here, oil is close to a perfect fuel. It's high in energy density (by weight or volume), exceptionally stable (proven multi-million year stability), liquid (so it flows, unlike solids, but stays in what you put it in, unlike gas), safe (little or no protective equipment is needed near it, and while I wouldn't advise bathing in it, you can touch it with little harm), and works in thermal and motive systems ranging from thimble-sized to the size of a large house. The immediate exhaust products are mostly harmless (CO2 and water -- though yes, over time the CO2 becomes quite problematic). There's little else that's so immensely attractive as a fuel. It was also abundant and cheap, for a time. But it's ultimately finite, supplies we've used took tens, possibly hundreds of millions of years to form, and we're consuming them at the rate of ~5 million years of formation per year of consumption. Jeffrey S. Dukes' paper, "Burning Buried Sunshine", describes this calculus in detail, and I highly recommend it. If you want people to use more of something, lower prices and increase efficiency. If you want them to use less, increase prices and decrease efficiency. The fact that increased efficiency increases overall production has long been noted, William Stanley Jevons is credited with describing his eponymous paradox in The Coal Question, 1865. Oil's price is another problem. Carbon taxes address externalities on the consumption side, but in extraction, I'm coming to the conclusion that typical market forces tend to ignore, to their error, the embodied creation costs of oil. It's as if you were living off a trust fund but considered only the cab fare to cross town to the bank to make a withdrawal, and not a depletion allowance based on actual costs of replacement for the funds removed. Properly accounted, oil would cost hundreds, thousands, possibly millions of times what we account for it. There's also the problem that a democratic populace is an ultimate "shoot the messenger" manager. The public wants to hear what it wants to hear, and the lessons of US presidents Carter and Reagan should be closely studied. Carter told the inconvenient truth, Reagan the attractive lie.