3 ms·
You are right to say that I haven't given a good model of vagueness, but all I am saying is that the argument in the pumpkin essay is flawed, and doing that doe
by mannykannot 11y ago
You are right to say that I haven't given a good model of vagueness, but all I am saying is that the argument in the pumpkin essay is flawed, and doing that doesn't require an alternative, and nor does the absence of one make the pumpkin argument more correct. N0us has pointed out in several places that formal theories with vagueness have issues, and maybe there isn't one that would satisfy all philosophers.
- ikeboy 11y ago>but all I am saying is that the argument in the pumpkin essay is flawed I don't think you've successfully pointed out a flaw. >N0us has pointed out in several places that formal theories with vagueness have issues I asked for an issue with my proposal and haven't gotten one yet.