7 ms·
Maybe it is me, but as the discussions here[0] about the relevance of Lisp etc which I blame largely on PR/Marketing unfold, I cringe when any announcements are
by tluyben2 11y ago
Maybe it is me, but as the discussions here[0] about the relevance of Lisp etc which I blame largely on PR/Marketing unfold, I cringe when any announcements are on Google groups. It feels like projects who do their communications (even between devs) in Google Groups are not too much into current affairs and therefor ignored by people who do not know about the project beforehand.
Again, maybe that's way off, but I find the interface horrible and dated and only ancient projects seem to use it...
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11698414 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11698414
- TeMPOraL 11y agoGoogle groups are the best solution if you want to have a working mailing list without having to deal with setting up and maintaining a mail list server yourself (which is a non-trivial task and a serious responsibility). E-mail still stands unconquered as a practical tool for people who want to get things done with minimum bullshit. What else would you propose they use instead?
- tluyben2 11y agoGithub seems to work well. Including the use of email. And it allows for much better organization with not minimum but almost minimum bullshit.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoGithub how? I've yet to see Github being used well for any kind of discussion other than issues. Three major drawbacks compared to mailing lists: it's on-line, it's proprietary, it sucks for searching and filtering (seriously, the few tools it gives you are a fraction of what you get in any e-mail client).
- tluyben2 11y agoYou have good points; I was commenting on the use as issue tracker which projects seem to do and the use of the actual Google Groups interface. If you use it with an email client that's quite different and yes, you are right there although I don't find it optimal the non proprietary and online nature annoy me too. Maybe I shouldn't use the client and just sign up for the list and respond via email.
- eatonphil 11y ago> only ancient projects seem to use it... Do you mean like Golang? (https://golang.org/help/ https://golang.org/help/)
- davexunit 11y agoThe big problem with Google groups is that it requires proprietary JavaScript in order to read the archive. I wish the Scheme standards community would care more about free software, but in my experience they just don't understand.
- coldtea 11y agoWho said Scheme is all about free software? Or I missed the /s mark?
- johncowan 11y agoIn practice, proprietary Schemes have not survived unless they have become free software.
- johncowan 11y agoWe understand fine. The standard is freely available and reusable, the implementations are free software (now that Chez has become so), the process is as open as can be. If you'd rather maintain your own archive of posts, please do, and let us know where it is. As things stand, the posts that weren't on Google Groups lists have been lost because the person who volunteered to maintain them (I had no influence over that decision) didn't keep backups.
- panic 11y agoWhat mailing list service would you rather see used? I spent a while looking for one a few months ago. There didn't seem to be anything that was both easy-to-use and designed for multi-way communication (rather than designed to send one-way marketing email).
- gkya 11y agoI haven't used it, but give a look: http://librelist.com/ http://librelist.com/
- newjersey 11y agoDoesn't replace a mailing list but also consider a discourse community forum site (like phpBB) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discourse_(software) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discourse_(software)
- icebraining 11y agoDiscourse is a big FU for people who want to read it on the go but don't have mobile Internet. Whereas with HN and phpBB I can easily save the pages offline, Discourse's "infinite scrolling" makes sure you can never save more than a few posts. The 5MB of JS that a single page like [1] forces one to download is just icing on the cake. [1] https://meta.discourse.org/t/cheap-docker-hosting/44262 https://meta.discourse.org/t/cheap-docker-hosting/44262
- eggy 11y agoI know what you mean, but what is interesting is that serious, new vs. old work, does not always correlate with a nice front end, or how it looks. Although, I have been following PicoLisp for years, and the site was just redone to look more modern. Didn't matter, since PicoLisp stands on its own for people who are interested in such a thing. The mailing list is direct and archived on at least two mail archival sites [1]. I also like J [2], and the Google Group gets less traffic than the individual direct email lists. As long as I can communicate, and stay current, I really don't care if the site looks good, as long as it is easy to navigate with old styling. [1] http://picolisp.com/wiki/?home http://picolisp.com/wiki/?home [2] jsoftware.com
- tluyben2 11y agoI follow picolisp and J as well and I would consider them niches which have their fans and get referred by fans to newcomers. Both are great projects by the way.
- eggy 11y agoNot sure what the relationship between niches and website appearance is here. I only care about quality, not quantity or popularity when selecting my tools for a task. There are people doing real work with both J and PicoLisp. Look at KDB+/Q. It is a highly effective time series database/language that is used by some of the largest companies, but could be called niche, yet the kx.com site is modern, but look at kxparc.com which is Arthur Whitney's site. He created A+, K and Q, and inspired J, yet the site is basically plain text and minimal, the beginnings of a desktop and server OS in K, KOS. BTW, J has Jd, a time series dbase with J as the built-in language of you're interested in that sort of stuff. I am more a "function over form" kind of guy, although I understand the importance of appearance and human interface designs.