30 ms·
Advanced Ping: httping, dnsping, smtpping
- kyberias 11y agoWhy the inconsistent naming? Why is it httping and smtpping? Why not httpping?
- imdsm 11y agoThis got me as well.
- dkopi 11y agoDifferent people creating different tools
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- merb 11y agoactually the naming is bad anyway. the initial implementation only was used to check if a host is reachable (routing etc) inside a network. then later other stuff came in like RTT. however a ping on a higher layer is mostly not a "real" ping. since it tests way more than just reachability. i.e. a http also checks connectivity and when it comes to domains it even includes a dns check.
- Programmatic 11y agoPing has confounding factors as well (firewall blocks, DNS, etc). If it works then you know that it's IP reachable, reachable on that TCP port, and that there's a responsive daemon on the other end. If it doesn't, you know that you need to troubleshoot. A device could not ICMP echo request ping, but respond to httping. Neither is perfect.
- dkopi 11y agoTLDR: A lot of companies block ICMP for security reasons. OP thinks you shouldn't and provides links explaining why. That said, if ICMP is still blocked, you might be able to use httping, dnsping and smtpping as tools that provide similar information based on a server's responses to higher layered protocols.
- INTPenis 11y agoI'm not a network architect but I like it when ICMP is blocked because I know it can be used to tunnel traffic in penetration situations.
- dkopi 11y agoAny type of traffic can be used to tunnel other types of traffic. You can tunnel over DNS as well: https://zeltser.com/c2-dns-tunneling/ https://zeltser.com/c2-dns-tunneling/
- INTPenis 11y agoOf course but security is multi layered and blocking ICMP is one layer, while using internal DNS is another. It's mitigation that costs nothing.
- dkopi 11y agoICMP is a valuable diagnostics and control tool. Blocking it doesn't come without a cost.
- scurvy 11y agoWhat does blocking ICMP get you? (other than a broken network) Blocking ICMP fragments is fine if you are worried about DDoS attacks, but don't blanket block everything ICMP (especially ICMPv6). Just curious as to what problem you are solving by blocking ICMP.
- dkopi 11y ago
- INTPenis 11y agoI have an sshping in my ~/bin because I often found myself waiting to log back into a rebooting server and ping starts responding much earlier than ssh. #!/bin/bash while sleep 0.5; do nc -vv -w 1 -z ${1:-localhost} ${2:-22} done
- ape4 11y agoIt bugs me a bit that "ping" has got into general use. eg "Ping me with an email later".
- bramblerose 11y ago'Ping' (the word) is older (as in: 1835 old) than the 'ICMP Ping'.
- 13of40 11y agoI always thought it came from old fashioned submarine sonar. What would it have meant in 1835?
- Programmatic 11y agoIt referred to a "high-pitched, short and somewhat sharp sound" (the bullet pinged off his helmet). SONAR uses noises that sound similar, so SONAR emanations became pings and then it became associated with echo/response at that point.
- accounthere 11y agoI thought it came from ping pong. As in you send a "ping" and it responds with a "pong".
- awqrre 11y agoreminds me of mIRC's "Ping? Pong!" events...
- gumby 11y agoMight not bother you if you could convince yourself that it isn't a metaphorical reference to ping(8) but instead was a reference to a sonar ping, or tossing a pebble at a tank to see how full it is -- to former being where the program got its own name in the first place!
- chip_rosenthal 11y agoWhy not just use nmap? $ nmap -Pn -p domain e.gtld-servers.net Starting Nmap 7.01 ( https://nmap.org ) at 2016-05-15 13:32 CDT Nmap scan report for e.gtld-servers.net (192.12.94.30) Host is up (0.072s latency). PORT STATE SERVICE 53/tcp open domain Nmap done: 1 IP address (1 host up) scanned in 0.22 seconds The repeated ping function -- which is intended to display packet loss or delay -- isn't useful for TCP services.
- sbierwagen 11y agoI usually just curl -I a host to see if it's accessible.
- reader_1000 11y agoThere is also paping [1] that lets you "ping" to arbitrary port, although it only works for TCP. [1] https://code.google.com/archive/p/paping/ https://code.google.com/archive/p/paping/