3 ms·
You misunderstand what I'm saying. This is a description of fact: the United States Supreme Court has a well-established body of law which holds that the Const
by patio11 17y ago
You misunderstand what I'm saying. This is a description of fact: the United States Supreme Court has a well-established body of law which holds that the Constitutional protections afforded to speech of a commercial nature are less extensive than the Constitutional protections afforded to speech of a non-commercial nature. Therefore, there is at least theoretically a risk of the government being allowed to do something analogous to this in spite of the First Amendment against speech restrictions, on the theory that the prohibited speech was commercial in nature.
However, it is unlikely that that action would be in the mainstream of constitutional interpretation in the US, and it is vanishingly unlikely it would be upheld if the commercial speech was also political, such as if the speech self-referentially criticized the government.
This is a statement of opinion: non-withstanding the well-established body of case law, I believe that the Supreme Court is wrong and that commercial speech has and deserves full protection under the First Amendment.
- anamax 17y ago> You misunderstand what I'm saying. I did misstate your position, but I still don't see how that position was in what you wrote.