5 ms·

Ask YC: what happened around September 2009?

16 points by andreyf 17y ago

garply 17y ago
I'm not sure if I'm more interested in the explanation for this data or in how you came across it.
- dfranke 17y ago
  Prompted by today's XKCD, most likely.
  - deleted 17y ago
    [deleted]
- andreyf 17y ago
  Today's XKCD, in part, but also because I'd been having a discussion about it with several friends, caused by a tweet to a blog post about it: http://jpcameron.com/blog/?p=47 http://jpcameron.com/blog/?p=47 I'd heard about the conjecture once as a Freshman in college and then thrice in the past month - hence, the Google trends search.
jwecker 17y ago
Hypothesis: That's when something triggered inside of Google and it started tracking the trend (based on a build-up of volume? news? sitting in the queue for a while), and the steep initial slope is not real but a relic of the graph going from 0 to whatever their first recorded data point is. shrug
cruise02 17y ago
It will get a spike from today's XKCD, which will sadly probably be higher than the spike it receives when the thing is finally solved.
bkow20 17y ago
Collatz is the last name of a high school athlete who made track and field headlines at around that time.
misterbwong 17y ago
Here's some info from wikipedia in case you're wondering what the XKCD strip is about: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collatz_conjecture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collatz_conjecture
SamAtt 17y ago
Given Lothar Collatz was German and he died in September of 1990 I'd assume something about his death (a remembrance of some kind) triggered it. Most of the searches are from Germany along with neighboring Switzerland and Denmark. Also note someone posted a picture of him on his Wikipedia page in Sept. '09 which is the first time the page had been touched by a non-bot in 15 months (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Lothar_Collatz&action=historysubmit&diff=312437360&oldid=285135406 http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Lothar_Collatz&#38...) (He's also mentioned in the Sept. 2009 issue of the European Mathematical Society Newsletter for what it's worth)

16 points by andreyf 17y ago

garply 17y ago

I'm not sure if I'm more interested in the explanation for this data or in how you came across it.

dfranke 17y ago
Prompted by today's XKCD, most likely.
- deleted 17y ago
  [deleted]
andreyf 17y ago
Today's XKCD, in part, but also because I'd been having a discussion about it with several friends, caused by a tweet to a blog post about it: http://jpcameron.com/blog/?p=47 http://jpcameron.com/blog/?p=47 I'd heard about the conjecture once as a Freshman in college and then thrice in the past month - hence, the Google trends search.

jwecker 17y ago

Hypothesis: That's when something triggered inside of Google and it started tracking the trend (based on a build-up of volume? news? sitting in the queue for a while), and the steep initial slope is not real but a relic of the graph going from 0 to whatever their first recorded data point is. shrug

cruise02 17y ago

It will get a spike from today's XKCD, which will sadly probably be higher than the spike it receives when the thing is finally solved.

bkow20 17y ago

Collatz is the last name of a high school athlete who made track and field headlines at around that time.

misterbwong 17y ago

Here's some info from wikipedia in case you're wondering what the XKCD strip is about: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collatz_conjecture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collatz_conjecture

SamAtt 17y ago

Given Lothar Collatz was German and he died in September of 1990 I'd assume something about his death (a remembrance of some kind) triggered it. Most of the searches are from Germany along with neighboring Switzerland and Denmark. Also note someone posted a picture of him on his Wikipedia page in Sept. '09 which is the first time the page had been touched by a non-bot in 15 months (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Lothar_Collatz&action=historysubmit&diff=312437360&oldid=285135406 http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Lothar_Collatz&#38...) (He's also mentioned in the Sept. 2009 issue of the European Mathematical Society Newsletter for what it's worth)