10 ms·
If that's true we are moving into a scary world pretty much like 1984 where everything you do is monitored all the time. Add voice, face recognition, surveillan
by maxxxxx 11y ago
If that's true we are moving into a scary world pretty much like 1984 where everything you do is monitored all the time. Add voice, face recognition, surveillance drones, cheap data storage and AI to the mix it seems pretty soon everything you do in a public place will be recorded and analyzed. And all this can be done fully automated.
I hope people will recognize that some laws need to change. Surveillance makes sense in some cases but it should be hard and expensive to do.
- CamperBob2 11y agoIf that's true we are moving into a scary world pretty much like 1984 where everything you do is monitored all the time. Well, not everything. Plant a GPS tracker on a police car or a bug in the restroom at FBI headquarters and you'll soon discover some troubling asymmetries in the modern post-privacy paradigm.
- jfoutz 11y agoI was thinking the same thing. If no warrant is required then anybody can record whatever they want, right? edit I can't figure out how this could possibly be legal. It seems to me the rule for recording conversations is 1 party consent. [1] There is no way the FBI is participating in those conversations it's recording. I have no problem with law enforcement having special powers, but, isn't that special power a warrant? [1] http://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/recording-phone-calls-and-conversations http://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/recording-phone-calls-and-co...
- rayiner 11y agoWhether a warrant is required is a federal Constitutional question. Requiring consent to record a conversation is a statutory creation (and state law at that). State law doesn't define what does or does not violate the Constitution.
- dragonwriter 11y agoState law can be a factor in determining whether there is a reasonable expectation of privacy, which is a key factor in whether a warrant is required.
- caf 11y agoPresumably State law still applies to the activities of FBI employees in that state, unless the Federal government has passed a law specifically exempting them.
- rdtsc 11y agoInteresting point. In regards to wiretaps https://www.privacyrights.org/content/wiretapping-and-eavesdropping-telephone-calls https://www.privacyrights.org/content/wiretapping-and-eavesd... seems to imply that no, Federal Agents when investigating are not bound by State law but by federal law: --- Courts have held that the California law does not apply to wiretaps by federal agents authorized by a valid federal warrant. For example, federal agents may go to federal court and obtain a warrant to place a wiretap in California, even though state officials may be barred by state law from obtaining a wiretap under similar circumstances. --- In general I suspect they cannot be prevented by local state laws from doing their jobs.
- caf 11y agoThat example is not precisely on point though, because it involves a federal warrant - there's no doubting that the US Government can pass laws overriding relevant State laws where it has jurisdiction, and Federal warrants are ultimately authorised by a Federal law.
- rdtsc 11y agoYeah this is not an exact case, the quote mentions the warrant part as well (that is why I pasted that part in), but thought it was similar because it is still Federal agents, in their line of duty, and court declared they get to disregard state laws. The other interesting aspect is this is looked what Federal agents can do, not "How can we protect the privacy of our citizens? Let's see what we can do for them. Maybe they are entitled to more privacy because they live in California". This mirrors the attitude of the "expert" in the story, they just see the Constitution as an inconveniance you need to bypass in order to get your job done.
- niccaluim 11y agoIn California it's two-party consent.
- Spooky23 11y agoYou don't even need to go that far. Try to find the salary scales or FOIA the salary data of police. In most places, they cook up some reason why it's protected information. In many states, every aspect of public employee compensation is publicly available. As it should be. Public safety folks are usually exempt.
- mschuster91 11y agoIn Germany, these are (relatively) public; on the shoulder flaps of any regular police officer (except the riot police <insert deserved swear word here>) you have the rank insignia which allows one to approximate the salary level.
- MacsHeadroom 11y agoPolice officer personal income varies wildly from $30k to $400k per year, quite unpredictably, in the US. Overtime pay, bonuses, double-dipping by being "on call" for Fire Services while actively writting traffic tickets, etc. There is much variability and many factors.
- jflatow 11y agoSecrecy is one of the government's greatest powers. Unchecked, they try to classify anything and everything.
- Aelinsaar 11y agoIf there aren't already intelligent criminals using the police's own tech and tactics against them, I would be very surprised.
- arca_vorago 11y agoWhich is why the corruption is even worse. When before, the dirty tricks bag was mostly limited to domestic threeletters, largely due to tech limitations, now that both technical and legal barriers are lowered, every public figure of power is now more vulnerable than ever before. Its closely related to the issue of gov mandated backdoors, in which the gov erroneously claims only they can do it, but in reality a backdoor is a backdoor for anyone. Now, as for me, where did I put my camera detector/focused emp burst gun?
- dragonwriter 11y agoThere are, even if there aren't any who don't also work for the police department. Working in law enforcement doesn't mean you aren't a criminal.
- Aelinsaar 11y agoA good, depressing angle I didn't intend or really consider when I made my comment, but of course you're right to think of that first.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- avs733 11y agoTheres no need to plant a GPS tracker, the radio protocol almost all police/fire/EMS use is called P-25[0]. Even when both parties remember to enable encryption, the protocol still has a long list of security of security vulnerabilities including the ability to jam it (both broad range and single user jamming) with the radio embedded in a childrens' toy because of poor implementation [1,2]. The protocol is so bad in fact that it could easily be used as active location tracking silently. Here is a talk about the complete list of fail [3] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_25 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_25 [1] https://hackaday.com/2010/10/09/pulling-data-from-the-im-me-spectrum-analyzer/ https://hackaday.com/2010/10/09/pulling-data-from-the-im-me-... [2] http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/p25sec08102011.pdf http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/p25sec08102... [3]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7or-_gT8TWU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7or-_gT8TWU
- bigiain 11y agoSubversive art project idea: A RaspberryPi(or similar) with a $12 TV tuner software defined radio, and a small database of the various frequencies and bands particular flavours of your local LEO and/or federal TLA use. I know our local highway patrol, for example, use at least: P25, police issued cell phones, iPads with cellular data, HF radio (at least on rural/country cars), and whatever they use for the data connection for their in-car computers. Most/all of that would be encrypted, but hey - metadata's a free-for-all according to them, right? I bet if you knew what to look for, you could quite reasonable detect the presence of a highway patrol car when you saw some digital P25, a cellular connection on the bands used by the contracted cellular provider, and I'd bet good money that patterns of encrypted data that things like ALPR systems send would be quite distinctive... That's all staying pretty solidly at the whitehat end of the wide grey space of "what's allowed". If you were much closer to the blackhat end of that spectrum, I'd also bet pretty good money that sophisticated criminals are already exploiting GSM and 3/4G weaknesses to individually identify cellular radios by cracking the encryption to see the IMSI data. And that'd all be passive and undetectable, if you were firmly in the blackhat camp, active attacks against their P25 radios can (as pointed out) be done for effectively zero dollars.
- 11y ago
- awqrre 11y agoWe are moving in a scary world... technology is nice but it makes monitoring too easy. As I see it, updated laws is the only thing that can save us... One of so many examples would be to get rid of car license plates.
- post_break 11y agoThat will make insurance rates skyrocket.
- awqrre 11y agowhy?
- dragonwriter 11y agoBecause it will make hit and runs easier to get away with. It won't make liability insurance worse, but it will make coverage that pays for damages in those cases much more expensive.
- awqrre 11y agoand let me guess, it will make terrorists harder to catch. most newer cars already broadcast their locations to the car manufacturer (http://www.businessinsider.com/ford-exec-gps-2014-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/ford-exec-gps-2014-1)
- srtjstjsj 11y agoThe article does not corroborate your claims at all. > Rather, Ford cars have several on-board services such as "Sync Services Directions" (a navigation device that works with drivers' phones) and 911 Assist, which users have to switch on and opt into. And employers can use a service called "Crew Chief" to monitor their corporate car fleet.
- ams6110 11y ago
- imaginenore 11y agoYou can't have an expectation of privacy in public places. Facial recognition can be beat by a hat + sunglasses (which is the hugest plot hole in Person of Interest, the characters never even attempt to disguise themselves).
- maxxxxx 11y agoI don't want to live in a world where I have to wear a hat + sunglasses.
- imaginenore 11y agoYou don't have to. But throwing a tantrum isn't going to change reality. We have the laws allowing anybody to film anything visible from public places, with a few security exceptions. That's more important than you getting upset that you are not invisible.
- alayne 11y agoWe're talking about limiting the actions of government here. It's hardly a "tantrum".
- marincounty 11y agoI think it's a good idea to get used to wearing sunglasses. This next paragraph is a bit offtopic, but I think we will look back with regret at how free we were with our picture being taken. Right now--I don't think it's acceptable behavior to be clicking away. It used to be cute, now it's just teenage behavior. To the Shutterbug who can't go anywhere without taking your pictures--at at least don't automatically post? Or, maybe put the camera/phone in your pocket? Enjoy the moment? Or, at least let the people around you enjoy the moment? If anyone cares the microphone in the courthouse light was for these realeste investors whom were rigging foreclosures in Alameda, San Mateo, etc. They were paying other buyers to not bid on foreclosures. I always felt not enough people show up at these auctions. Just don't violate The Sherman Anti-trust Act. https://www.fbi.gov/sanfrancisco/press-releases/2015/two-northern-california-real-estate-investors-plead-guilty-to-bid-rigging-and-fraud-at-public-foreclosure-auctions https://www.fbi.gov/sanfrancisco/press-releases/2015/two-nor...
- darpa_escapee 11y agoTotal surveillance is sold under guise of preventing terrorism, but the main effect is simple: it allows the status quo to become entrenched and permanent. You are rendered economically exploitable and politically neutered. There is a reason the state and intelligencies, from the Pinkertons to the FBI, have had a historical obsession with extensive spying on political movements and economic assembly. Both have real potential to change society. Would the civil or labor rights movements be possible under these conditions? Both threatened the bottom lines of powerful people. The FBI tried to persuade MLK to commit suicide by digging up dirt from his love life. He was considered a national security threat[0]. [0] http://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/11/16/magazine/what-an-uncensored-letter-to-mlk-reveals.html http://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/11/16/magazine/what-an-uncens...
- jflatow 11y agoYes. We are told these measures are taken to protect our national security, but in reality they are meant to protect the government. Take the ongoing incident with Hillary Clinton's email server, for example. Clinton was quick to support scrapping 4th amendment rights (Patriot Act) in the name of security, but when it came to state secrets, she played it fast and loose (at best). It took 15 years and a scandal before the Secretary of State's emails were finally secured. We started a mass surveillance program practically the day after 9/11. We are starting to forget we are supposed to have things like civil liberties, and that the exceptions made for wartime only work if war is not permanent. The war on terror has no end. Before terror, it was drugs and communism. The government will never stop coming up with reasons it needs more power.
- yuhong 11y agoThe war where government agencies compete for more resources probably don't help either.
- pjlegato 11y ago"Entrenched and permanent" is a bit exaggerated, as the governments of pervasive-surveillance East Germany and the Soviet Union discovered.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoSurveillance gets easier and cheaper over time, that is progress, to know more than you did before. Every person will have a (or multiple) device that can capture and broadcast multiple audio, video, and other sensor data streams to the entire world.
- optforfon 11y agoGoogle has vastly more information on everyone in America. Orders of magnitude. (and by extension maybe foreign intelligence agencies) The government is just playing catch-up! I rather our slightly dysfunctional government have more information about me than an ad company that's the play toy of tech-utopian billionaires
- partiallypro 11y agoI don't use Google, and prefer they not keep tabs on me all the time...but I think governments have a much...much worse track record on suppressing people than corporations. Google can be wiped from the earth by merely a new invention or a shift in the market to a better product...or financial fraud. Pretty hard to up root an entire legal structure and apparatus that grows every single year and has the ability to jail you or kill you. What I find terrifying is corporations like Google that have all of this data working hand in hand with the government. This creates two problems, a) the government now has tons more data they shouldn't have giving them more authoritarian abilities and b) that company now has immense lobbying power and can stifle competition for its mere deep relationship with the government. Basically, fascism.
- optforfon 11y agoI don't use google either! But I've gotta say, every year it gets more and more frustrating as people ask me to use their google spreadsheets and chat with them on google hangouts etc. etc. Google might not have an account of mine, but I'm 100% sure they know who I am, what I'm interested in and what I'd be interested in in the future! Thanks to cookies, their ads and snippets of JavaScript on every webpage, my friends uploading contacts lists with my name in them etc. etc. they must have a profile built for me. With the current state of things it actually doesn't really bother me (other than it's monopolistic market distorting effects, but whatever), but you brought up the possibility of them falling part! A very interesting scenario. Google is playing nice and placating people while they make boatloads of cash. When Firefox and IE natively implement adblock or some technounicorn clobbers them they'll get a lot less nice! And we checked enough End User Agreements to let them With the government we have some recourse
- 11y ago
- djsumdog 11y agoIn this article, they seemed to be targeting one person. They fucked up because they didn't get a warrant. They shouldn't need one. It is a public place. I don't want to get into the situation where regular citizens are not allowed to take pictures of people in public places. Still, I can see their lawyer's argument for expectation of privacy. What about the homeless? Do they have no expectation of privacy? Unless they are in their tent? (If they even have a tent).
- woodman 11y ago> In this article, they seemed to be targeting one person. That is an interesting interpretation, because the same article left me with the impression that they recorded everybody within earshot of the bugs for 10 months.
- benevol 11y ago> If that's true we are moving into a scary world pretty much like 1984 This became obvious since the proof delivered by Snowden. And we don't need more proof. What we need now is a way to roll the surveillance state back.
- BurningFrog 11y agoWe are moving into a world where everything you do is monitored all the time. This is driven by technology, and legislation can't do much to change it. It's possible other technology can, but until then, assume you are monitored.
- rms_returns 11y agoYeah, with that kind of advancement in technology, the "Captain America vs Iron Man" debate is going to be sprung soon. In other words, the debate between Individual Freedom vs Individual Safety.
- mattnewton 11y agoTo quote Franklin - "Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."