3 ms·
> the absence of a set schedule removes the biggest drawback of public transportation I’d argue that having no schedule is even worse. With a set schedule, I
by kuschku 11y ago
> the absence of a set schedule removes the biggest drawback of public transportation
I’d argue that having no schedule is even worse.
With a set schedule, I can just go to the stop, wait a minute, and a bus will come – most lines are running every 5 or 10 minutes anyway (or 15 to 20min in the suburbs).
With this, the situation would get a lot worse, I’d have higher waiting times, less of a guarantee that one would come (what if there’s not enough demand?), etc.
- erik 11y agoBus coverage in my city is nowhere near this good. High frequency routes are every 15min. Most are 30min, and some routes only run every hour. On demand with some delay would be a huge improvement.
- jfoutz 11y agoWith an uber like indicator of wait time, it seems like it would be tolerable. If a bus is guaranteed to show up in 20 minutes, i can make use of those 20 minutes. Fundamentally though, it's a density/diffusion problem. Having enough rides available in the right spots is tough. Especially when, say 10% of riders go way off in the sticks, with no need for pickups out there. You want a nice random distribution of rider routes, but really, people go east in the morning, and west in the evening (for example), so a lot of capacity is unused just getting back to where demand is. tricky tricky problem. schedules and defined routes are part of the solution, for sure.
- kuschku 11y agoIndeed. A uber-like waiting indicator is actually already existing in about all cities – either per app or website (like http://kvg-kiel.de/fahrplan/echtzeit/#?stop=52 http://kvg-kiel.de/fahrplan/echtzeit/#?stop=52 ) or as an actual display at the bus stop (like http://www.kvg-kiel.de/yaml/gfx/submenu/fahrplan.jpg http://www.kvg-kiel.de/yaml/gfx/submenu/fahrplan.jpg ). And many cities already have on-demand busses (mine calls them ALiTa or "Anruflinientaxi", pretty much meaning "taxi that operate as bus line on demand via calling a phone number". But an especially important part, as you mentioned, is knowing for sure when the next bus will come – even without looking at the display – so you can plan for that, and use that time.
- snuxoll 11y agoThis is one area I've been rather happy with using HERE Maps for, I put in my destination and my desired arrival time and the vast majority of the time I get a workable route on public transit that has only failed me a handful of times (I've always allotted myself extra time to avoid human error, so the few times it's been wrong I've still gotten to my destination with time to spare). Even Muni (which most locals seem to complain about) didn't give me many troubles, but my local municipality is junk for public transit so maybe I'm way more lenient than most.
- pampa 11y agoIn Moscow all buses are equipped with GPS/GLONASS trackers and there is an app, Yandex.Transport, that shows you where all the buses are. It is hard to keep a precise schedule in traffic, but with the app you always know how far away the next bus is.
- kuschku 11y agoThat’s what they do here as well, but the app just calculates how far the busses are off schedule based on the GLONASS and GPS data. If you look at the raw data for each stop, you see this: http://www.kvg-kiel.de/internetservice/services/passageInfo/stopPassages/stop?stop=52&mode=departure http://www.kvg-kiel.de/internetservice/services/passageInfo/... "plannedTime": "11:00", vs. "actualTime": "11:02", This is a pretty awesome solution that ensures the numbers actually are useful, and that everyone can easily understand them (without having to look at a map and find where the route is).
- DKnoll 11y ago>> the absence of a set schedule removes the biggest drawback of public transportation >With a set schedule, I can just go to the stop, wait a minute, and a bus will come – most lines are running every 5 or 10 minutes anyway (or 15 to 20min in the suburbs). Your European is showing... ;) In Canada and the US, except some core routes in the urban centre of major cities, you will never see 5 to 10 minute frequency. I feel like this lack of schedule would have far more benefit for North American commuters.
- kuschku 11y agoIndeed. And it’s a good thing that for those people we now have the technology to improve things. But considering what Uber tried to do, I’m pretty sure it will happen again that people try to force US concepts on European cities, and people here get angry because they lose products and services they like, and get worse alternatives. Which is also a case whenever Google buys a startup and turns a "globally available" service into an "available everywhere – in the US" service.
- icebraining 11y agoBut considering what Uber tried to do How do? Did they force people to use them?
- kuschku 11y agoNo, but they tried to eliminate their competition with unfair business practices (predatory pricing, for example, driving without insurance, etc). The result was that, without them being banned from doing that, they'd have been able to provide a cheaper product, which, for the average customer would not have been better, but long-term, would have reduced the quality of service.
- icebraining 11y agoSo if the product isn't better for the average customer, they can just ignore it, no? Why be angry?