5 ms·
Wasn't one of the primary motivations for privatising the space industry to cut costs? So player A wound up having significantly higher costs than later player
by ianai 11y ago
Wasn't one of the primary motivations for privatising the space industry to cut costs? So player A wound up having significantly higher costs than later player B. Oh, but mind you, player B (spacex) has had some very serious accidents along the way. I don't remember hearing about such with ULA. I don't necessarily read this as a story of corruption and waste, full stop. Unless I missed something...
- gaius 11y agoULA's track record is 100%
- thomasahle 11y agoAlso if you look at the individual companies since their foundation?
- gaius 11y agoThat's besides the point. What the govt is paying for with ULA is risk reduction. If you absolutely have to get that satellite up in response to a geopolitical situation, for example. Musk has done great work and SpaceX is definitely cost-competitive but can it deliver that level of certainty? No-one knows.
- thomasahle 11y agoMy point is that a 100% track record is easy to achieve, if you are allowed to reset the counter just by renaming your company or forming an alliance.
- gaius 11y agoThey haven't done that. 106 launches.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- gunshigh 11y agoYou're missing the point. Lockheed and Boeing had initial failures when each company was started. It's not like Boeing put up rockets on day one without a problem. Then, when each company approaches stability with their launches, they form a new alliance. That new alliance has "zero failures", but that's only because you ignore each company's original problem s.
- clintonb 11y agoI see your point, but it's not exactly relevant. As a purchaser in need of putting a multi-million dollar satellite in space, I could not care less that your company had failures in its infancy. I want to see your most-recent results as evidence of your ability to put my satellite in space. Comparing SpaceX, and whatever its success rate is, to ULA, and it's 100% in 106 launches, is easy. The string of 106 successful launches is what I'm looking at. Just because you're new to the market doesn't necessarily mean you get a pass on quality/success. This is especially true when we're talking about putting expensive objects, that took years to build, in space.
- soared 11y ago> I could not care less that your company had failures in its infancy > Just because you're new to the market doesn't necessarily mean you get a pass on quality/success Contradiction?
- dogma1138 11y agoNo it's not. When SpaceX gets to 100 launches with no failures you could effectively reset their counter if you want. ULA has currently 100% in orbit mission success rate which cannot be overlooked. Now for some it might not be an issue considering SpaceX is considerably cheaper, but if you are putting a new spy satellite into orbit your risk metrics might be different.
- ericd 11y agoIs the cost difference between the launches usually less than the cost of building a backup satellite?
- ncallaway 11y agoYes. Many times yes. The cost of launches is on the order of a few hundred million. Military satellites often cost a few billion. Losing a satellite is, by far, the biggest risk during a launch. The launch cost itself is non-trivial, but a small fraction of the overall mission cost.
- pravda 11y ago> Military satellites often cost a few billion. Wouldn't it be more accurate to say the plans for a military satellite cost a few billion? I would assume stamping out a new copy when you have the plans costs just a few tens of millions. I mean, if you wanted one Airbus A380, it would cost you 15 billion dollars. But once you have the plans, you can stamp out additional copies for 100 million or so.
- gaius 11y agoEach one is unique, because they are always being improved.
- forgotpwtomain 11y ago> Military satellites often cost a few billion This needs a reference.
- mnl 11y agoNot really, but here you go: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KH-11_Kennan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KH-11_Kennan And no, you can't make cheap primary mirrors (in a garage).
- Spooky23 11y agoThat's a real goalpost moving exercise. How is a 1960s failure relevant today?