3 ms·
"I'll give it a shot :)" I admire your initiative. :) "logic cells: easy, by universality of NAND." Got me dead to rights there. Seems to be able to do anyth
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
"I'll give it a shot :)"
I admire your initiative. :)
"logic cells: easy, by universality of NAND."
Got me dead to rights there. Seems to be able to do anything boolean.
"a massive (or not so much) array of flip flops"
http://www.learningaboutelectronics.com/Articles/D-flip-flop-circuit-with-NAND-gates.php http://www.learningaboutelectronics.com/Articles/D-flip-flop...
Close but still need the resistors.
"May I suggest a"
That's not a NAND gate but it's pretty neat. Thanks for that link. Especially as when you posted it I was, in search of esoteric constructions, just discovering and looking at these diode-based works:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diode_logic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diode_logic
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D-17B https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D-17B
Note: D-17B is pretty wild in design, appearance, tech, and reliability all at once. Makes me want to try it on 0.35 micron in voter part of lockstep or TMR circuits. :)
"having Vcc and ground available is an implicit requirement of having a functional NAND gate, and IO could just be some wires mirroring a memory location."
Now you're stretching. NAND doing signal conditioning, power regulation, or 2-3 component differential equations is hard to believe. I'm thinking it fails here. I admit I cheated by including an analog requirement but it exists in ever real-world computer (esp SoC) so it seemed fair-ish.
Overall, a high-scoring counterpoint that taught me some useful stuff about NAND gates and old-school ROM. I'm researching both reductionism and old-school techniques in anti-subversion hardware. So, quite relevant. Thanks!
- andars 11y agoThose resistors are not part of the flop, they're just there to limit current through the LEDs to make the state visible. See here for a D flip flop: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flip-flop_(electronics)#/media/File:Edge_triggered_D_flip_flop.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flip-flop_(electronics)#/media.... My point was about Vcc and ground was just meant as a response to the "power-related analog components". If you don't already have a regulated power rail even a single NAND gate won't be able to do it's thing, so its definitely a requirement but if you say you are allowed a functional NAND gate you must be allowed power rails as part of that.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI'll be darned. So, NAND gets some extra points on the flip flop. Far as analog, even if I ignored power rail we still have ADC's, DAC's, etc. This time I hesitate as I say I doubt they'll be implemented just with NAND gates.