8 ms·
Germany to Give €1B Electric Car Subsidy
- frik 11y agoIt's for cars produced in Germany produced by Volkswagen, Daimler or BMW, so the car selection is very limited (several of the cars in the photo aren't subsidized because they cost more than €60k). Germany will subsidies €2000, the remaining rest (up to €2000) come from one of the three companies - basically a price discount. Isn't there a similar subsidies/discount in California(?) where you get $5000 if you buy an electric car (manufacturer doesn't matter afaik)?
- rb2k_ 11y agoThere is a Federal + State one: http://driveclean.ca.gov/pev/Costs/Vehicles.php http://driveclean.ca.gov/pev/Costs/Vehicles.php For a Chevy Volt, that was $7500 Federal + $1500 State Worked nicely for a lease too.
- lispm 11y agoIt's open for all producers, not only German. It is expected that other companies will join.
- Rexxar 11y agoIt's true but it's suspicious to require to sign a contract with government to have the money. They should instead have just publish a specification of what a car should have to qualify. The fact that the 3 majors German car makers have already a head-start for this subvention whereas there are lots of electric car models from other car makers doesn't inspire trust in this process ...
- lispm 11y agoWhat head-start? The market for electric vehicles almost does not exist. Almost nobody is buying them yet and it's not only a cost problem. The money allocated will be available for 350000 cars. It will take some years to sell those. In 2014 the whole of Germany bought just 8522 electric cars plus 27435 hybrid cars... It's even worse, probably half of these cars were never used in Germany but exported...
- Inthenameofmine 11y agoOnly tangentially related but still interesting. This is IMO how most governments will unfortunately implement People QE once negative interests fail and the next crisis comes rolling in. U think in the last crisis the US already implemented one thing similar called "cash for clunkers".
- hga 11y agoI'm pretty sure Cash for Clunkers was far worse, for it was pure Broken Windows theory of the economy. It not just took those cars off the street, one of the requirements was to destroy the engine.
- Gibbon1 11y agoWould have made more sense for the government to collect the inventory of clunkers and then auction them off in batches once new car sales recovered. Also amusing, okay sort of horrifying, was panicked calls as the housing bubble popped by erstwhile free market types for the government to buy up and bulldoze 'excess housing inventory'
- hga 11y agoWere those "erstwhile free market types" in favor of Clinton using Carter's law to force banks to sell subprime mortgages in the first place? (Something that no friend of the free market George W. Bush thought was just dandy, but at least he didn't say anything as stupid as "I want to roll the dice a little bit more in this situation towards subsidized housing." but mistaking markers of the middle class for causes is very very stupid.) Not that that is sufficient an answer, seeing as how many other countries also had property bubbles at the same time. Taking a step or six back, I see it going to the US running a huge deficit and the inevitable consequences of putting that sort of money in motion. In between are things like the IMF's insane response to Indonesia's short term liquidity problem when hot money fled it, which resulted in it's government/strong man being deposed, which the PRC took note of and acted accordingly.
- aluhut 11y agoShould have invested into charging infrastructure, bike lanes or street infrastructure all together. Last time the government threw all that money at the car industry people ended up selling their good cars and getting cars who faked their emission measurements. So I'm pretty skeptical here...
- jfoutz 11y agoI can't quite tell if you phrased that poorly, or didn't read the article.
- aluhut 11y agoAre you talking about those 300m? They are a "waterdrop on a hot stone" as we say here.
- adrianN 11y agoExactly. This way it's an obvious subsidy to our most important industry with dubious benefits. That money could be spent a lot better if the goal is to reduce CO2 emissions by traffic.
- tirant 11y agoExactly. I was terribly disappointed at the poor bike infrastructure I saw in Germany two weeks ago when I visited Munchen and Nuremberg. Those cities would be perfect for bikes, but instead they are totally dominated by ICE vehicles. It is very sad.
- aluhut 11y agoYou are right Munich is terrible. I brought my bike there once when I was working in our Munich office because I've heard the traffic is horrible. I was never so stressed out driving a bike through a city before. Collegue commented on this with: "what did you expect in BMW-City?". Guess you really have to love your BMW really much to add an extra hour just to get to work. Frankfurt where I live is not as bad, they've done a lot in the last years compared to cities like Munich but it's also not representative from what I experienced and hear from the community.
- Matt3o12_ 11y agoWhat annoys me about this plan is that every hybrid car is eligible. There are some hybrids that can barely drive 10miles on electric and thus never get charged by the owners (because installing a charging spot can be really expensive) and yet the cars count toward a total maximum. Hybrid cars should either have their own maximum limit (after that limit the subsidy ends) or every manufacture should have their own limit (like it is in the US, the first 200k electric cars get the $7,500 off for every manucature). This would make sure that 90% of those cars are not hybrids that can barely drive 10miles on electric and people have a chance to get the subsidy when the bolt and tesla model 3 are available (I think the model 3 will not be available without reservation before the end of 2019). Currently, there are no purely electric cars that don't suck (the Nissan Leaf has a range of 100miles and looks kind of funny and is incredible expensive for what it has to offer; the model S/X are excluded from the subsidy because they are considered luxury cars).
- yardie 11y agoThe primary point of hybrids is that the ICE charges the battery. So a charging station isn't even necessary and most hybrids don't have a port for this reason. When energy gets low the ICE fires up to recharge the battery. Most hybrids are decent city drivers. The engine is off for rush hour where stop and go is common. Once on the highway the ICE takes over where its most efficient between 30-90km/h. For the moment, it's a decent compromise.
- Bluestrike2 11y agoThe idea behind subsidizing electric cars is to compensate for their higher prices and subsequently increase consumer demand. Including hybrids would undermine that, especially given the relatively low number of options available (less so at under the 60.000€ cap) today. But the German government's goal is to replace inefficient ICE automobiles with more efficient alternatives and not just sell more electric cars. Hybrids, though less desirable than fully electric cars, are still a significant improvement. They're plentiful, available in a number of different models across multiple price points, and available today rather than a few years down the line. From that perspective, including hybrids makes perfect sense.
- lumberjack 11y ago4.000€ is not really going to make a difference for anyone looking at higher end cars. Even an i3 is 34.000€ and I believe the VW e-golf is in the same price range. What low end electric cars are available in Germany? Nissan Leaf 21.000€, Renault TWIZY 7.000€, Renalt Zoe 21.500, Mitsubishi MIEV 24.000€. Any others in this price range (<25.000€)?
- ju-st 11y agoPeugeot i-On and Citroen C-Zero (19.000€). However these will likely not become cheaper because of the 2000€ mandatory manufacturer rebate.
- kuschku 11y agoAlso look at the VW e-up!
- jseliger 11y ago4.000€ is not really going to make a difference for anyone looking at higher end cars. Even an i3 is 34.000€ and I believe the VW e-golf is in the same price range. I wonder what the leasing options look like. In the U.S. the i3 has an absurd $40K+ sticker price. But BMW is offering leases that cost $~330/mo: http://www.bmwusa.com/bmw/special-offers/lease/2015-BMW-i3-with-Range-Extender http://www.bmwusa.com/bmw/special-offers/lease/2015-BMW-i3-w..., which is much more attractive and reasonable.
- franzpeterfolz 11y agoJust take a look at normal cars. E.g. Ford Focus Sedan is starting at 17.000$, 2.0 Liter Engine, 160 horsepower. Now take a Ford Focus from Germany with a comparable Engine (1.5L EcoBoost with 150 horsepower) Starting price is at 26.500$. Audi A3 in Germany is starting at about 26.800 Euro. Cars in the United States are way cheaper than in Germany. So 4.000 Euro is quite some money to get EVs and normal cars into the same pricerange.
- Huppie 11y agoNot sub-25k but the Kia Soul EV looks to be around 29.000€ and is a way better car imho than the i3 and e-golf. The 4k subsidy brings it just under the 25k mark. Disclaimer: I've test-driven all three and now 'own' a 2016 Kia Soul EV.
- olex 11y agoOne thing the article is missing: the subsidy is explicitly limited to vehicles that cost less that 60.000€. One can say with pretty high confidence that this is done with the explicit goal of excluding Tesla's Model S and Model X. This would be somewhat understandable, given that the subsidy's purpose is to give an upper hand to our own automotive industry in the electric market... if they had anything to offer. The updated BMW i3 is arguably the only German electric vehicle worth mentioning. E-Golf utterly fails on range (pending a future update), and both Daimler offerings (electric Smart and the B-Class Electric Drive) are way overpriced for what they offer.
- lumberjack 11y agoDo you think somebody who is going to spend 80.000€ on a car will be persuaded either way by a 4.000€ price difference?
- olex 11y agoFrankly, yes. If anything, someone who has spare 80k€ to spend on a car is more careful with his/her money, and 4k€ is nothing to sneeze at, no matter what kind of income one has.
- themartorana 11y agoThis is ridiculous.
- stesch 11y agoYou should only buy a car if you can afford 2 of them.
- B1FF_PSUVM 11y agoYou're right, the rich are tight-fisted. But there are plenty of barely solvent people with delusions of affluence ...
- Matt3o12_ 11y agoNo! Just look at how many people bought $80k teslas who previously only had <30k cars because they did not care about cars at all until a nice electric car came along. They want to save the environment and are willing to pay $$$ for it. According to a study I've read (can't find it sorry) 80k is a significant amount of most of those buyers but they are willing to lease a car for $800 a month to help the environment. So they are not millionaires who have more money then they can ever spend. Why should those people be punished? Furthermore, most people who can afford those cars already pay more then 50% of their income in taxes so they should have every right to be rewarded for buying a "green Car".
- denzil_correa 11y ago> The government has budgeted over all €600 million for electric car purchasing subsidies until 2019 and another €300 million for building electric car-charging stations in cities and highways. It would be interesting to see how the 300€ M would be spent on electric car-charging stations. Would it cater to certain brands of cars? Would it lead to issues with "standards" for charging? That would give out the true intentions of this subsidy.
- Huppie 11y agoThere are already a few common standards (at least here in Europe.) For public charging station almost every manufacturer uses the TYPE2 (MENNEKES) plug, the actual charger is built into the car. For fast-charging there's the CHADEMO standard (japanese) which a lot of electric cars use and the newer 'European' Combo-plug (an extension to the TYPE2 plug) that is currently in-use by the BMW i3. In The Netherlands (where I live) a company called FastNed is building a fast-charging network on the highways, they offer TYPE2 (for cars not having fast-charging support,) COMBO, and CHADEMO and usually also have a conversion plug for Tesla cars so you can also charge them there. I hope part of this subsidy allows companies like them to get stations along the German highways as well.
- rdl 11y agoHow does electric charging work in Germany? The cost of electricity in Germany seems to be 6x what it is in parts of the US, so I'm not sure if the economics work out for electric cars there anyway.
- franzpeterfolz 11y agoSo the German Prices 1 KwH is about .28$ 1 gallon is 3.78 liter 1 liter gas about 1.52$ 1 gallon is now at 5.70$ What are the prices in the USA right now. The electricity prices include about .20 Euro taxes and subsidies for windharvesting and solar etc.
- rdl 11y agoElectricity is $0.08-0.15 per KWH; gas is about $2-3/gallon. (There are obviously exceptions -- Hawaii electricity is almost German prices, and it is progressive, so if you use a lot you pay a high marginal rate. There are also specific areas with really expensive gas, maybe 2x the cheapest gas.) Electric seems like an easy choice in the UK -- high fuel costs and not high electricity prices -- and a less obviously good choice in places in the US with cheap fuel (Midwest, south) but expensive power (I think some small utilities have high rates due to legacy costs) It doesn't seem like a clear winner in Germany yet, or at least is relatively less good than in California (high fuel costs, high subsidies for electric cars, high traffic, and relatively low electric costs). If I lived in Germany (goal!) I'd still consider getting an electric as a city car if everything else worked out, just for environmental reasons, but I'd probably still be tempted to get a 550d or something instead if I were doing long trips. Whereas in California and Washington State I definitely want a Model 3 next, or if I had to buy today, maybe an i3.
- ido 11y agoIf you lived (in a decent sized city) in Germany, you could do without a car altogether thus helping the environment even further :)
- tiatia 11y agoPff. Nothing. Germany to Give €100B refugee subsidy http://www.reuters.com/article/us-europe-migrants-germany-costs-idUSKCN0Y50DY http://www.reuters.com/article/us-europe-migrants-germany-co...
- xgbi 11y agoLet's just hope that it doesn't end up like all other subsidies: the car maker increasing price to include this rebate and munching all the benefits from the government's help.. I still remember how photovoltaic subsidies in France ended up in the hands of the hands of the installers, who raised prices to match the government's help and fucked up consumers who thought they were getting a bargain when they were actually paying much more that real market prices.
- denzil_correa 11y ago> So they probably just picked a round number that sounded nice. Except that in this case it specifically excludes all car models from Tesla.
- Tomte 11y agoYou just love to spread this misinformation, do you? Strangely it also excludes the BMW i8 and the Porsche Cayenne in their hybrid variants. Obviously the German government is doing all it can to thwart those evil German carmakers. Oh, and Tesla, right.
- denzil_correa 11y agoFalse Dilemma Fallacy. I said Tesla's models are excluded. I never said BMW and Porsche hybrid (that's almost clutching straws - pun intended) aren't excluded.
- Tomte 11y agoYou claimed protectionism, i.e. excluding foreign cars in order to boost sales of domestic cars. Turns out German cars are excluded as well. Not Germany's fault that Tesla's affordable car is so late. But you still play the language-lawyering thing to try and hide your ulterior motives and intentions.
- denzil_correa 11y agoReading Comprehension? > You claimed protectionism, i.e. excluding foreign cars in order to boost sales of domestic cars. I said IF the number is arbitrary, it could be deliberate. > Turns out German cars are excluded as well I never said they weren't. In fact, what percentage of German cars are excluded? If they're just a few it could still be a protectionist move. > But you still play the language-lawyering thing to try and hide your ulterior motives and intentions. Your issue of interpretation of English isn't me having ulterior motives and intentions.