5 ms·
The thing is, if you also block ads and aren't going to pay them money (or give them something else of value, as discussed here), Forbes are probably happy that
by Silhouette 11y ago
The thing is, if you also block ads and aren't going to pay them money (or give them something else of value, as discussed here), Forbes are probably happy that you don't go to their site. A visitor that generates no revenue is just a drain on resources.
- nihonde 11y agoMaybe...just maybe...ads aren't a good business model for journalism any more.
- a_imho 11y agoSeeing an accurate valuation of your product is a bitter pill to swallow if you are accustomed to an inflated market. I don't think it is a business model problem and changing your monetization strategy won't help you much unless you can convince your customers about the (perceived) quality of your content. I don't think adblock shaming is very effective here. There are many many sites without adverts doing just fine, even receiving donations and volunteer work.
- mtkd 11y agoThe combination of populist/sensationalist/clickbait articles with subtle marketing seems to have some merit - see the Daily Mail with their "buy a dress like this for less" panels on the celeb articles - but that forces the content into a certain direction and is not sustainable without massive traffic volumes
- nihonde 11y agoOne thing I have learned in this life: the more you cater to the lowest common denominator in society, the more everyone plays by their rules. I understand the "Buzzfeed" concept of using populist, knuckle-dragging content to sell ads in order to fund content for people who prefer to use their brains, but I think it's an epic example of the snake eating its own tail, and a wildly pessimistic, fatalistic vision of the future.
- antisthenes 11y agoI would be happy if 90% of the "journalism" died out, and the rest remained as quality investigative content behind paywalls (which I would gladly pay for and already do for 2 sites) and government subsidized strictly informational reporting (sort of like we already have from NOAA, Orange alerts, emergencies, closures, etc.)
- javajosh 11y agoI'm sure that most everyone would be fine if 90% of X died out - but it's usually a wildly different 90%. This is a corollary to Sturgeons Law (90% of everything is crap). Interestingly, we sort of know what this conflict is: it's yellow journalists vs muckrackers. * There are, in the body politic, economic and social, many and grave evils, and there is urgent necessity for the sternest war upon them. There should be relentless exposure of and attack upon every evil man whether politician or business man, every evil practice, whether in politics, in business, or in social life. I hail as a benefactor every writer or speaker, every man who, on the platform, or in book, magazine, or newspaper, with merciless severity makes such attack, provided always that he in his turn remembers that the attack is of use only if it is absolutely truthful.* — Theodore Roosevelt
- bogomipz 11y agoWere they ever though? I don't that its recently hit some kind of tipping point.
- danneu 11y agoOf course ads are a good business model for journalism. The dying business model is easily-detectable, obvious ads that can get defeated by NoScript or a regular expression.
- abhi3 11y agoBut that visitor could share the content with other people who share it on further..... To people who don't have ad blockers.
- Silhouette 11y agoThat's conceivable, but this kind of pyramid scheme rarely seem to be very successful. It's the same argument some pirates use for sharing their latest movie rips with other pirates, but it only works if it's not pirates all the way down.
- soared 11y agoAre you trolling? Social shares are a pyramid scheme and a nonviable way to drive traffic?
- Silhouette 11y agoDriving traffic isn't the goal. Generating revenue is. My original point was that driving traffic that doesn't generate revenue one way or another is actively bad for a commercial site.
- soared 11y agoFor most sites I would say that distinction doesn't exist (eCommerce), but I guess for adblockers its true. I think if Forbes lost 100% of their adblocker traffic they would be worse off though. I don't know how I would justify it directly through revenue generated though. If they were smart they'd realize that long term their monetization method is going to change, and the value of someone as a lifetime reader is worth more than the lost revenue of a couple years of adblocking. There is something to be said about adblockers still seeing native ads, but thats unfortunately the route we are heading down.
- soared 11y agoThat is not the least bit true. No website wants to generate revenue from 100% of their visitors, that is horribly un-optimized. The resources it takes to provide a couple pageviews for one person is less than a penny, and those pageviews have value outside of ad clicks. There are a million benefits from high traffic, even if that traffic doesn't click ads. I'm not going to list them, they are dead obvious.
- effie 11y agoCould you mention just a few such benefits? I think you're right - the readers always pay with their attention if not with their money - but genuinely curious about others.
- soared 11y agoMy bad, should've just listed some. Potential revenue is the main one. With existing traffic you just have to convert it to revenue by selling it (ads) or selling to it (ecommerce). But brand awareness and engagement are valuable in themselves because users get to know the brand and recognize them as an authroity in the niche. I'm thinking of an REI blog as an example. Blog readers aren't directly making REI money, but REI spends tons of money on blogs/pics/etc. They are building the brand, generating views, and establishing themselves so traffic comes back and reads more. Its then easier to convert existing semi-related (blog) traffic into purchasers then it would be to get all new traffic.
- Silhouette 11y agoI'm not going to list them, they are dead obvious. It's going to be difficult to have any interesting discussion, then, because it's not at all obvious to me what benefits high traffic has for a typical commercial site if that traffic isn't generating revenue or providing something else of value. Obviously if the purpose of your site isn't to make money then things are different, but given that we're explicitly talking about models for revenue generation here, I think it's reasonable to assume commercial websites that are intended to be profit-making.
- 11y ago