5 ms·
I don't understand why they couldn't simply release the app without the money transfer part, and it would just keep a tab of how much the parent owes the kid. T
by StavrosK 11y ago
I don't understand why they couldn't simply release the app without the money transfer part, and it would just keep a tab of how much the parent owes the kid. Then, when the parent gave cash or whatever, the debt would just be wiped.
Pretty much "freshbooks for chores".
- nostrademons 11y agoIt sounds like they did the user research and found that having an actual debit card was a big part of the draw of the app. I could believe that. When I was a college student, it was a big deal when my parents got me a credit card. Even if you are limited in what you can spend, it shows that you're integrated into the same financial system that adults are and can make your own choices with money. You don't get that with a virtual currency or parents dispensing out $20 bills.
- joshvm 11y agoCouldn't you just piggyback another service like PayPal to process the payments? The PayPal student debit Mastercard is/was available to anyone over the age of 13. Then when you specify the chore and amount, the app sends the amount to the kids' account and therefore the card. The card doesn't seem to exist any more, but it sounds almost exactly like what this app does (without the todo list functionality). It's linked to a parents' account so they can provide cash for fuel/going out and can keep track of the kids' expenses. http://www.cnet.com/uk/news/paypal-targets-students-parents-with-debit-cards/ http://www.cnet.com/uk/news/paypal-targets-students-parents-...
- getmetheswan 11y agoThe challenge is storing money, legally, on behalf of a customer. No normal startup can afford to get licensed. So you need to legitimately work around the 'stored value' problem, i.e. you need to find a 3rd party with a legal solution. That's either a real bank account or a prepaid card. And the 3rd party has to have an API that allows you to open accounts, execute transactions, etc. The card program requires a bank partner too. And card programs cost 10K+ a month to run, regardless of whether or not you have 1 card issued or 250,000. Lots of cash burn early. So that's the target state. Johnie outlined some nice interim steps below, but this is not simple. Oscar took on a challenging business problem.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Nullabillity 11y ago> When I was a college student, it was a big deal when my parents got me a credit card. That sounds incredibly odd to me. Aren't you 18+ when you get into college? Couldn't you just get your own debit card without parental involvement?
- nostrademons 11y agoIf you're generating suitable income, which many college students are not, and have a suitable credit history, which many college students do not. Credit card companies want to make sure they'll be repaid. It's pretty common for them to require parental co-signers (or just issue an additional card on the parent's account) for people who don't have a full-time job. For a debit card - yes, you can just open a bank account and get one. You need money in the bank account. If you arrange a way to automatically transfer money into a kids' bank account at the touch of the button, you end up with an app much like this postmortem.
- detaro 11y agoHere is the author answering a similar question: https://medium.com/@oscargodson/the-whole-concept-we-were-selling-that-investors-and-others-loved-just-not-bank-partner-progress-5d316d4860b?source=responses---------5- https://medium.com/@oscargodson/the-whole-concept-we-were-se... (in short: a mixture of "that's not what people liked about the concept" and "not big enough of a goal"?)
- ThePaco 11y agoI still don't understand what made them want to reinvent venmo to pay kids for chores
- artursapek 11y agoNeither do I, it doesn't sound like a very fun challenge.
- coldtea 11y agoWhere "reinvent" = something totally different. For one, it's not reciprocal, only the kid side gets money. Second, it involves chores, not splitting bills etc where money are shared. Third, it was supposed to use the currency to be able to buy apps etc, not get actual money. And lastly, there's the kids angle. Sure, it's about debt and value exchange, but that can be said for tons of apps, even a bitcoin exchange.
- galistoca 11y agoYou don't get to say what people like about something unless you let it out into the world. There are so many cases where people built and released something just to find out people love it for the reasons they never expected. This guy makes it sound like he knows why he failed but it's far from it. The biggest reason they failed was because they never released anything. The first thing you learn as soon as you release a product into real world is that people say one thing but do another--so many people say they love something but they never use it. Only way to get around is to release it in public and find the early adopters who WILL actually use it (instead of just saying they like it).
- wmeredith 11y agoI'd pay for that.
- foodstances 11y agoBecause then it's basically just another todo-list app that shares lists between parents and children. That's neat, but hardly the kind of thing that needs a whole company behind it with lots of funding.
- theseoafs 11y agoSo do it in your spare time over a few months, release it and charge 99 cents, and maybe make a little money
- btcprint 11y agoWould be a perfect way to introduce kids to cryptocurrency. No need to deal with regulatory agencies. The "points" (btc/ether) are actually worth something (whether more or less in the future). kid marks they've completed task, parent xfer bits to kids wallet. Kid can now buy games at newegg or gift cards from tons of stores through Gyft. the smart kids (like my oldest daughter) roll the dice and Alex p. Keaton it for long term savings that has decent potential to multiply in value. I do this with my kids already, but with no app..just verbal "do this and I'll pay you $0.25 in bitcoin" an app with actual chore list they can work through and automate fund transfers would be awesome. If you're a rich VC make sure you PM me to partner up. There's only one way to successfully monetize this, and I'm the only one who knows it. Small target market but growing every day...the power of "frictionless transfer of value outside the insanely regulated walled garden of fiat banking and high finance"
- firebones 11y agoYes, shift the fraud risk to the family situation; offer any actual financial transfer as an upgrade.
- pedalpete 11y agoVery close to what I was thinking. BTC or possibly a credit card for the kid to use. Doesn't need to go through a bank. Kid gets a card, parent accepts chore, piggybank charges parent, piggybank credits kid. The problem as I see it is the founders didn't think about what they were doing, and didn't have the right attitude to find another way.
- codecamper 11y agocan bitcoin be converted into money outside the US?
- Natanael_L 11y agoThere's plenty of exchanges outside USA. Safello is currently the big local one here in Sweden, and there's plenty of bigger ones in other European and Asian countries.
- ultimatejman 11y agoCompany in the uk www.roostermoney.com is this