4 ms·
A nefarious, diabolically clever government wants to compromise this device and then telegraphs that intent to the world by forcing the software to go closed so
by pvg 11y ago
A nefarious, diabolically clever government wants to compromise this device and then telegraphs that intent to the world by forcing the software to go closed source - that is absolutely an irrational and silly conspiracy theory. To believe that you have to believe that the government is both nefarious, diabolically clever and cartoonishly inept.
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoAbsolutely most certainly yes all three of those things. Nefarious: government is, I contend, only that group of criminals we have collectively decided we would be better to regulate and pay off. I'm not saying this is a bad thing, we certainly need some regulation and law enforcement, etc. Diabolically clever: the word means 'characteristic of the devil' - government is responsible for torturing people, killing people in pointless wars, etc. Cartoonishly inept: for sure! you only have to go outside, pick up a news paper, browse a news website, to see how incompetent government can be. But, we tend to speak of 'government' as some cohesive whole, which it most certainly is not. Is any one branch or agency of government all three of those things at all time? I don't think so. Some parts of government do a fine job of administering their responsibilities, some of the time. Probably. Maybe.
- dfc 11y ago> Cartoonishly inept Can you name one medium to large (resources and headcount) organization that has existed for 20 years that could not be called cartoonishly inept by its detractors?
- patrickmclaren 11y agoAmazon comes to mind.
- pvg 11y agoSo you wanted to let me know you deliberately misunderstood my point but then, wait, how clever, you did not. I don't follow.
- mindslight 11y agoAnd this is exactly the type of strawman that usually accompanies the "conspiracy theory" bashing. You've chosen the strongest-claiming narrative, which is easily knocked down. The simplest scenario isn't that YubiKey 4 went closed source to support a government backdoor. It's that it's entirely for business reasons as they've said. And then after a few years, a few more layers of middle management, a few interesting users, and a little more TLA focus, Yubikey 6 quietly gets subverted. Tangentially - I was pretty close to buying a Yubikey Neo for its form factor, but it didn't seem like I could modify/reload the OpenPGP applet, and documentation was scant as to how configurable it was. I really want the thing to operate as semi trusted hardware - passphrase, etc. Smartcard tech is nifty, but it seems like a non-hardened chip would be more worthwhile for the ability to iterate features/UI.