3 ms·
From the article: "I’m picking on Google today because I ran into an article written by a recent Google applicant who walks the reader through an interview proc
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
From the article: "I’m picking on Google today because I ran into an article written by a recent Google applicant who walks the reader through an interview process that appears to be designed to exclude the most qualified applicants for a marketing job."
He concludes google excluded their "most qualified applicants" because they declined to hire someone who can't apply that complicated mathematical practice of division:
“Say an advertiser makes $0.10 every time someone clicks on their ad. Only 20% of people who visit the site click on their ad. How many people need to visit the site for the advertiser to make $20?” I froze. The problem sounded easy but I didn’t want to cause an awkward silence trying to solve it.
“Um…well, ok. So, 20 out of 100 people click on the ad. Every ten clicks make one dollar…and you need 20 of them…” That’s as far as I got before I resorted to guessing answers, none of which were right. I was panicking and I couldn’t do a thing about it. My nerves were taking over. Anna could sense this and began to give me hints. None of them helped my frazzled brain.
After five painful minutes the annoyed interviewer gave me the answer. “100 people make two dollars, and two times ten is twenty. The answer is 100 people times 10 which is 1,000 people.” She made it sound so easy; I felt like a moron. As if she enjoyed my misery, she immediately fired off another math problem.
FAIL.
- owinebarger 17y agoYou might be surprised how widespread the non-understanding of division is among the normal population. That includes the accounting profession, who have mastered addition and subtraction, and possibly multiplication as well. It's not clear whether an understanding of division is really required for Google's marketing or not.
- sethg 17y agoIIUC one of the key acronyms in the advertising world is “CPM”, the cost of an ad per thousand people in its audience. That word “per” is division.
- owinebarger 17y agoActually, it's a decimal point shift, which is a little easier than general division.
- mootothemax 17y agoI couldn't agree more with you. The applicant did the right thing in reading up on the company, but just didn't have the skills. For example, she knew how many ad placements GMail had, but it took her a lot of tries before she answered the question about how much Google makes from Gmail ads, and surely for the position she was applying for, the ability to make an educated guess (backed up with figures) at these things would be vital?
- sethg 17y agoHer assumption that one out of four GMail ads gets clicked on seems wildly off-base; I thought that these days, a click-through rate of one percent is considered a smashing success. But of course if you know that every GMail page has four ads, and you assume that one quarter of the ads gets clicked on, the math for the rest of the problem gets a lot easier.
- coolnewtoy 17y agoscenarios like this make me want to be a fifth-grade math teacher. maybe I could do a better job than this person's did.
- idleworx 17y agoIf you can't solve a basic algebra equation you should be ashamed of yourself applying for any financial/math/cs jobs. I learned that in 5th grade (alas in another country though where school actually teaches you something). All he had to do was write the problem down and solve for P: 0.10 * (P*0.2) = 20 ->>> result 1000 P eople.
- msg 17y agoLesson learned for that interviewer. Lead with the math problem, then go over resume, boost Google, and end the call.
- tptacek 17y agoIt's worse than that. This is a candidate for a marketing position at a leading technology company who, when she flunks an interview for clearly never having even attempted to do a calculation marketing people do constantly, writes a blog post making it clear that she thinks the interviewer was at fault. Math illiteracy may not be a dealbreaker for a technology marketing role (hey, I've managed OK), but marketing illiteracy clearly is.
- mattm 17y agoThis person probably needs more experience at interviewing. There's absolutely nothing wrong with bringing a pad of paper and a pen to the interview. He should have solved the answer on paper rather than trying to think it through out loud.