4 ms·
> The medical community's current approach to testing (positive result, treat ALL THE THINGS!) No, that's what the patients want. "You do have cancer. We're
by DanBC 11y ago
> The medical community's current approach to testing (positive result, treat ALL THE THINGS!)
No, that's what the patients want.
"You do have cancer. We're going to watch and wait." is something that's only recently been accepted by some patients, even though the side effects of treatment are so drastic. And those positive results only happen because people push inappropriate testing.
> Less data is never the answer.
More dirty data isn't particuarly helpful.
- gumby 11y ago> > The medical community's current approach to testing (positive result, treat ALL THE THINGS!) > No, that's what the patients want. And the insurance companies, because they don't want to be sued for a false negative with unfortunate consequences. And there's an additional terrible incentive in that if you treat "just in case" and it has a negative consequence in terms of lifestyle, it's OK because "it's better than the alternative". Consider prostate cancers that develop slowly and could probably have been left alone (referred to as "watchful waiting") -- but if you operate, the patient will survive; the side effects like incontinence aren't the doctor's or insurance company's problem.
- MereInterest 11y ago> More dirty data isn't particularly helpful. Depends on how it is dirty. If it is systematic error, then of course it doesn't help. If it is statistical error, then repeating the test over and over is exactly what you need to do.
- JamesBarney 11y agoMost medicals tests are systematic and not statistical error. False positives will continue to be positive if you re-administer the test because they are due to variation in the individual and not the test.
- Houshalter 11y agoThe data isn't "dirty", it's perfectly accurate. You are just using it wrong. The test can give you an objective answer like "you have a 20% probability of having cancer". But the system doesn't weigh the cost and Quality Adjusted Life Years of treatment vs not treatment, it just defaults to treatment. This is the problem that needs to be fixed, not eliminating collecting data. And if the patients really are the problem, then don't show them the raw numbers. But having them is potentially useful. But maybe they should see the numbers, and maybe if they decide on treatment anyway that is their right to do so, and taking it away is wrong. Either way the problem is the system, not tests themselves.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> But the system doesn't weigh the cost and Quality Adjusted Life Years of treatment vs not treatment, it just defaults to treatment. This is the problem that needs to be fixed, not eliminating collecting data. Doesn't it? I mean, depends on the place probably, but I remember having a class with an MD once and we were discussing the overall goal of healthcare, and how to balance physical and mental well-being. The problems that arise there are exactly like this: you know, with your "perfectly accurate" data, that patient has X and, say, 3 years to live with serious symptoms showing up only close to the (for lack of better word) deadline; telling them about it will most likely mean 3 years of stress, painful treatment and heavy strain on patient's family&friends for, at best, a small extension of the lifespan. Not telling them means they live 2.5 years happy and then for the last 0.5 year they get sick. Should you tell them? Most people scream "yes", and that's exactly your approach of "defaulting to treatment". Doctors would sometimes like to answer "no", but that means lying to the patient, and not showing them the data. > And if the patients really are the problem, then don't show them the raw numbers. But having them is potentially useful. But maybe they should see the numbers, and maybe if they decide on treatment anyway that is their right to do so, and taking it away is wrong. It seems like a free will issue, except that if 99% of people do the same wrong, stupid thing when experiencing a particular situation, it doesn't seem right to let them suffer from it. It's one of those human rationality errors. Sometimes people do need to be protected from themselves. Now the problem is that the current trend of separating the doctor's office from the lab - whether via third-party private labs or all those half-assed smartphone-based tests - means that it's hard to hide raw data from the patient. And yeah, I'm a bit conflicted about it - I want to look at my own raw data, I want to play with it, graph it, whatever, but I'm also aware I might freak out if something really weird shows up in them.
- DanBC 11y agoYou're assuming people know what the test results mean. Every time we ask people what the tests mean we find they don't know. Gerd Gigerenzer (Reckoning with risk) shows that doctors, nurses, and patients don't understand the results of screening tests. Here's another example: https://www.sciencenews.org/blog/context/doctors-flunk-quiz-screening-test-math https://www.sciencenews.org/blog/context/doctors-flunk-quiz-...