3 ms·
I didn't find a lot of substance in this article, the message was basically "Alibaba's accounting practice is opaque, so we don't know where the money is." the
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I didn't find a lot of substance in this article, the message was basically "Alibaba's accounting practice is opaque, so we don't know where the money is." the reminder that in Arabian nights Alibaba was a thief seems to tie up the narrative nicely. Not that I'm buying it.
That said, it is tremendously important to Yahoo! that they understand the real value of Alibaba. No doubt it would be tremendously useful to have transparency on where all the money is coming from and where it is going, presumably these people use a recognized accounting firm to provide audited results for people who want to know?
- peloton 11y agoThere isn't a lot of substance but the Enron comparison is awfully loaded. The article specifically calls out the use of off balance sheet entities to hide costs-- for people who follow this stuff, that immediately triggers memories of Enron's use of special purpose entities and Lehman's Repo 105 off balance sheet shenanigans.
- tiatia 11y agoChinese culture is not honest. The idea of "shareholder value" must sound disturbing for them. Now Alibaba. Amazon and Ebay on Steroids. Maybe. Or not so much? Parts of the company are removed/divested from the stock. This is very likely not a good thing. In case of Alipay (Think Paypal) it is not a good thing because investors lose a very valuable asset. In case of the delivery services, it is not a good thing because likely this is a money losing business, making look Alibaba much more profitable than it is. “My experience with Chinese companies is that what you don’t know is generally not good news.” I agree on that. I live in China and I don't own any Chinese stocks. You may take all this already into consideration when investing into Alibaba. Not to the linked previous article from Bronte capital (their blog is actually in my RSS feed and very good): http://fortune.com/2015/09/18/alibaba-faking-numbers-hedge-fund/ http://fortune.com/2015/09/18/alibaba-faking-numbers-hedge-f... He has a look on some reported numbers from Alibaba. And while mathematically possible, I would again take them into carefully consideration of your investment. I use Alibaba. Its good. Most of the stuff is fake but they have good and cheap things. But knowing the Chinese and seeing this red herrings, I would pass. Here is another Blog post about another Alibaba competitor (competitor to Alibabas TMart) JD that speaks very positively about the competitor: https://oraclefromomaha.wordpress.com/2016/05/05/jd-com-a-multi-decade-compounder/ https://oraclefromomaha.wordpress.com/2016/05/05/jd-com-a-mu... But in the end, both are Chinese companies.