3 ms·
The problem is: Why should I write a review? I have nothing to gain. Maybe I have had a bad experience and want to warn others: That would explain mostly bad r
by okket 11y ago
The problem is: Why should I write a review? I have nothing to gain.
Maybe I have had a bad experience and want to warn others: That would explain mostly bad reviews for almost every product. (Given enough users, some will have bad experiences, if only it is by them misusing it)
I can understand that mostly bad reviews creates an incentive to counter these with good reviews, but from the wrong side (seller, not consumer). This would explain the many fakes.
I guess reasonable trustworthy 3rd party sites like consumer reports are still necessary.
- jbob2000 11y agoI write reviews all the time, and to be honest, Amazon makes it pretty easy. Basically if it shipped on time or earlier and was exactly what I expected, I will write a review and say exactly that.
- HemanHeartYou 11y agowhat youre doing is, seemingly, review the product based on amazon delivering it to you in a speedy and secure manner. unfortunately many reviews include this when it shouldnt even be considered.
- _JamesA_ 11y agoI have never ordered a product from Amazon that didn't ship on time or wasn't what I expected. I'm not trying to be negative but I don't see what value the type of review you say you are writing adds.
- jbob2000 11y agoI bought a smartphone case that looked robust in the picture, but was kinda cheap and didn't perfectly fit the phone, so I noted that in my review. It's just a dinky review, you're not supposed to do a full product breakdown. If everyone thought of amazon reviews this way and just gave 30 seconds for a review for every item, then there would be no automated review problem.
- taejo 11y agoThat's fine. It's the other type that people are asking you not to do: didn't ship on time, packaging damaged, delivery person left it in the wrong place, the wrong item was sent, etc.
- beberlei 11y agoWhat has shipping to do with the products quality? There are two things you buy at amazon: 1. a physical product 2. the amazon service and shipment. The second one should IMHO not be relevant for the peoduct review, yet many rate them and skew the results.
- jbob2000 11y agoYeah, fair, but if it's not a common product that amazon keeps on their shelves, then it's an important note, I think. I usually only buy stuff on amazon if I can't find it in the store, so it's usually a somewhat rare or very specific thing.
- derekp7 11y agoWhat is the incentive to post commentary on discussion sites such as HN? For many, writing a review for an exceptional product triggers a type of internal emotional response that ties them to a community.
- dingaling 11y ago> Why should I write a review? I have nothing to gain. Unfortunately I'm now of that mind-set as well. A few years ago I was in the top-500 of reviewers on Amazon UK, based on 'helpful votes'. I only reviewed things that I had bought for myself and focused on items that had no or very few existing reviews. Then two things occurred quite quickly: 1. I learned that many top reviewers were receiving free samples as part of Amazon Vine. I asked myself: why am I spending my time doing this without recompense? They were churning-out multiple reviews per week and I was doing perhaps three or four a month, but it still felt unfair. 2. People starting aggressively scoring reviews negatively for subjective reasons. I remember an airline stewardness marking as 'unhelpful' my review of a book because she said I had insulted her airline. Amazon weren't interested in reverting down-votes like that. I drifted away from Amazon reviewing after that and in time I have also drifted away from Amazon. They never fostered their community of honest-amateur-reviewers ( with, say, a Gift Card at the end of the year ) and they're paying the price now.