3 ms·
Curious, how often does this work for your company? Anytime I'm given non-trivial homework for a job interview, I decline because there are a dozen other compa
by mywittyname 11y ago
Curious, how often does this work for your company?
Anytime I'm given non-trivial homework for a job interview, I decline because there are a dozen other companies that can determine my competence in a few hours of interviews.
I understand that hiring is risky for startups, but this approach seems excessive for what it is supposed to determine. It seems like you could get nearly all the same principal information about a person's talent by giving them an even more simple assignment, like writing a method to determine if two dates overlap.
A lot of what you're looking for is to see if a developer follows industry best-practices. It's just as easy to ask them, "what are some security/design considerations that need to be accounted for when creating a login page." You get the same information but in much less time.
- imsofuture 11y agoI've had really great experience hiring technical roles with 'homework'. Both product engineering + technical support. Each time, I've made sure that anyone completing the assignment is compensated with a $50 or $100 Amazon gift card (depending on the task). I don't think I've had anyone choose to not participate. I'm also happy to compensate people that make a solid effort and realize they are in over their head and gracefully bow out (specifically that's only happened when hiring borderline technical roles, like support -- no project is nightmarishly difficult). I understand your time is valuable, and so is mine. I would like to see how you work, on your own time, in a low-pressure environment. The information I receive from that is easily worth $100. Plus, if we do proceed to further interviews, we have a fantastic non-theoretical project to discuss.
- geebee 11y agoI refused to do a take-home interview exam for the first time a couple of months ago. I don't think a $100 gift certificate would have made much of a difference. The opportunity was a decent one but I've just had very bad experiences with take-homes in the past (spent a lot of time, didn't hear back for a month, got a one-sentence rejection from a recruiter, never talked to a developer). I might consider doing it later in the process, when I have a stronger sense that the exam will be taken seriously and given proper consideration. I'm just not willing to put this kind of time into what may simply be "screening". I think Gayle Laakman McDowell's comments on this subject were good: http://www.gayle.com/blog/2013/09/18/companies-who-give-candidates-homework-assignments-knock-it-off http://www.gayle.com/blog/2013/09/18/companies-who-give-cand... The problem here is that take homes allow companies to externalize the inefficiencies of the interview process - they may demand many hours of a candidate's time while dismissing that candidate in five minutes. The $100 gift card may make this a bit better, but it's still a bargain for the company (I'm certainly not surprised you consider the information easily worth $100).