6 ms·
Rather than inventing sophisticated chat bots, couldn't he have just had a well organised web page? If the question were where is assignment two / when is ass
by collyw 11y ago
Rather than inventing sophisticated chat bots, couldn't he have just had a well organised web page? If the question were where is assignment two / when is assignment due. The examples given seem like a "high tech" (possibly unreliable) solution to a low tech problem.
- dimino 11y agoI could reasonably ride a horse to work every day, it's only 2 miles.
- adekok 11y agoAnd where would you get said horse? Where would you keep it? What would you feed it? Who would take care of it? Students should be capable of reading text. If they can't, they belong in kindergarten, not university.
- betenoire 11y agoI see it as a "high tech" interface to the same solution.
- lucb1e 11y agoExcept you have to publicly post your question before receiving search results. A search function is a lot faster and you can do a few attempts.
- adekok 11y agoHaving written documentation for end users, that will work for only a portion of them. Probably most, which is good. But there are a significant percentage of users who can't (or won't) read documentation. Even they do manage to read it, they don't understand it. For some reason, human interaction works better for those people. They ask a question, and someone copies the answer from the documentation, and pastes it into the chat conversation. The user then goes "Oh, wow! That's helpful!" But ask them to read a web page, and they get lost. I would love to know the psychology behind this phenomenon.
- drhayes9 11y agoIn this specific instance, I wonder if some people, when panicking about their courses or under a deadline, are comforted by the notion that a TA is out there and willing to help them.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoI often suffer from this - and it stems for me from apparent time pressure and or resentment. The time pressure is the source of all sorts of sub-optimal issues - "I don't have time to write tests, documentation, do the right thing here ... Whatever. Including reading around the subject" I do think modern corporate culture contributes to this - I remember being impressed by a PhD DSP guy who was in my scrum stand up who most days would report "I was reading yesterday and will be reading today". Every so often he would say "I finished reading and wrote ten lines that solved the problem" As a contractor I felt I could not take a similar response, but I should ... or at least should be "I will be refactoring our Dbase access code / Our API / whatever cos it sucks rocks" But I am weak. Oh and resentment - "I don't want to find out the details of the pointless process this pathological bureaucracy has created and I really don't want to read a badly written set of documentation that probably does not have the real answers in it because no one likes to write the honest answers" Hmm, glad it's Friday. I am worse than usual
- collyw 11y agoIs the documentation going the be available via a chat bot or a web page? My guess is the second. Screw the lazy users who won't look up documentation. If you can't read docs (he is a computer science professor), then do you really aren't in the right subject.
- grayclhn 11y agoI think you'd be surprised at how often students don't read webpages and fire off an email to the class TA or instructor. Replying with a link to the relevant part of the webpage is something I'd love to automate. (I teach a largish introductory university class)
- qb45 11y agoYou can automate replying with a link to the course webpage ToC. Also, make it absolutely clear that the reply is automatic. Hopefully they'll get the hint. Or heck, just make it a policy that if they haven't received an answer in a week, this means they need to look at the website. I don't know why some people strive to be so accommodating to laziness nowadays.
- lostlogin 11y agoBecause in many cases, the lazy are paying the bills.
- mulmen 11y agoLaziness is a virtue. What you're suggesting is not all that different than creating a webpage that says "read the book" instead of adding value. If a bot can be created to make discovering answers easier why shouldn't it be done?
- qb45 11y agoThere are two kinds of laziness: one which makes you visit course website, copy teacher's email and send him some stupid question whose answer is one CTRL+F away on the same website, and another which makes you want to automate responding to such emails. I'm not sure if the former is that virtuous. Those people look like they are growing completely helpless.
- grayclhn 11y agoThere are lots of things I could do that would be less work but would come across as "being an asshole" to many students. A smart chatbot would be less work, more helpful, and a better experience for the students. Most technology is fundamentally about accommodating laziness. There's nothing "nowadays" about it.
- heurist 11y agoOr the engineer's solution to a social problem :)
- Florin_Andrei 11y agoNo matter how well organized the page is, you still have to do some sifting through the material. The bot is a way to outsource that effort to silicon.
- perseusprime11 11y agoNah. We are engineers who think in terms of man pages and documentation. The world has moved on and we are now in the "live" phase. Everything is live and interactive for the new generation.
- kennydude 11y agoMy computer science lecturers can't even put together a webpage so yeah it is asking a lot. (They didn't close tags in their tables for some bizarre reason)