3 ms·
Apologies for the caps. I'd edit that part if I could. The "yet another" is simply because the major points the authors themselves claim, are exactly the same
by stephenr 11y ago
Apologies for the caps. I'd edit that part if I could.
The "yet another" is simply because the major points the authors themselves claim, are exactly the same as previous things (also submitted to HN) and with exactly the same fundamental problem, which I specifically described, and even suggested an alternative approach to.
I understand that you want to encourage positive feedback, but I have to ask: are you saying my wording needs improvement (i.e. I should have said "this has the same problem as other similar projects, X, y, z") or are you saying negative feedback in general is discouraged?
- dang 11y agoI'm saying your wording needs improvement. Good criticism is important, but please present it constructively. Otherwise the culture risks becoming too acidic and we all lose. The most important place to be careful about this is in discussing new work. That of course doesn't mean that all new work is good, but the bias toward tearing things down is so strong (especially on the internet) that it's better to err on the other side.