5 ms·
You aren't giving false positives any credit. False positives can be DEVASTATING. If a test has 50, 75, 90% false positive rates, as many do - you are causing m
by brianwawok 11y ago
You aren't giving false positives any credit. False positives can be DEVASTATING. If a test has 50, 75, 90% false positive rates, as many do - you are causing much panic for nothing.
If tests were 100% reliable and a simple pinprick.. absolutely, everyone should take one when they wake up and drink their morning coffee. But with the accuracy of tests today? Not so sure.
basically take any 100% healthy person. Run 500 tests on them. They will have 5-6 major problems via a false positive result. Run more detailed invasive tests on those. Maybe you rule them out, maybe you get another false positive. You could end up going through Chemo or some other "cure" for a disease you never had, and the "cure" could end up giving you real cancer.
- sigmar 11y ago>If a test has 50, 75, 90% false positive rates, as many do What tests are you referring to? I can't find a reference but I highly doubt the FDA would approve of many tests with that high of false-positive rates.
- mikeyouse 11y agoYour doubt is misplaced.. At least at the high end. Pap smears have a false negative rate of ~20% and a false positive rate of ~10%. Many doctors are now recommending less frequent tests; http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB125875596169058039 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB125875596169058039
- sigmar 11y ago10% false positive rate is significantly lower than the quoted "50, 75, 90%"
- LionessLover 11y agoHow about you read the article the entire discussion is about? You will learn what is meant right there.
- Falell 11y agoI think these statistics are claiming '50-90% of observed positives are false', not '50-90% of all tests return false positives'. Suppose 0.1% of the population has a condition and the test for the condition has a 0.5% false positive rate. If administered blindly, most positive tests will be false positives.
- fisherjeff 11y agoI think this is the crux of the article's argument - more people testing more frequently and "blindly" means a whole lot more positive results, most of which will be false.
- sigmar 11y ago>'50-90% of observed positives are false' if ^ is what he means, he should write that. The term "false-positive" has a very clear definition in medical statistics.
- brianwawok 11y agoFair enough. But the more rare a condition, the more observed positives will be false.
- Houshalter 11y agoSuch a test would still be very useful, when combined with other independent weak tests. If 5 weak tests in a row confirm you have cancer, then you should worry. And anyway just report the numbers to the doctor and the patient. "This test has a 5:1 likelihood ratio, so if the odds of you having the disease were 1 to 100, it's now 5 : 100 or 1 to 20." Everyone needs to get a better grasp on probability.
- dragonwriter 11y agoWhich doesn't mean it's not a good test to rule out the tested condition if there are symptoms that might indicate the condition. Sometimes it's clinically valuable to rule out a condition, particularly if the appropriate treatment for another possible condition would be drifter if the tested-for condition might be present. There are people whose training makes them, in principle, the appropriate experts to decide when these tests are needed and worthwhile, they're called physicians.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pak 11y agoThere's a difference between false positive rate and positive predictive value: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_positive_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_positive_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positive_and_negative_predictive_values https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positive_and_negative_predicti... The latter depends on the prevalence of the test condition in the population, which is one of the major points of the OP. A test can have a low false positive rate but still have a low positive predictive value if the test condition is sufficiently rare (as it is for most diseases). brianwawok was probably referring to tests with a low positive predictive value.
- sigmar 11y agoAll very true. Perhaps he mistyped, not sure. I'm just pointing out what was written and factually inaccurate.
- tokenadult 11y agoIf you read the fine article, you will see a very clear example of how a highly accurate test can still be misleading for clinical practice if the clinician is deciding whether or not to treat for a low-base-rate condition. Examples like this have been in books about statistical reasoning for medical decision-making over and over and over again since the turn of the century.