2 ms·
I'm a little troubled by the argument that an increase in the probability of death signifies or is equivalent to an increase in the rate of aging. I feel like t
by dahart 11y ago
I'm a little troubled by the argument that an increase in the probability of death signifies or is equivalent to an increase in the rate of aging. I feel like that conclusion doesn't follow and is misleading, but I'm not sure. Am I off base?
If we suppose humans live to around 85 years on average, and rarely if ever die before 65, then there's a big bell curve normal distribution on 85, and what looks like a non-linear exponentially increasing probability of death up to about 80. But that doesn't mean everyone started aging faster at 65, it just means people started dying around 65.
Imagine that you go bowling and throw 20 mph balls on average. The distribution would look similar. Bell curve on a pin dropping at around (say) 5 seconds, but the curve starts at around 4 seconds and ends at 6ish. Does this mean the ball suddenly accelerated at the end? No, in fact the opposite happened, it was slowing down. But the rate of probability that a pin goes down is exponentially increasing from 0-5 seconds.
Not a perfect analogy to aging by any stretch, but am I right that an increase in the probability of death is unrelated to aging - the speed at which we approach death?
- Jtsummers 11y agoI don't think this is a reasonable conclusion: If we suppose humans live to around 85 years on average, and rarely if ever die before 65, then there's a big bell curve normal distribution on 85, and what looks like a non-linear exponentially increasing probability of death up to about 80. You're suggesting that the probability of dying after 85 decreases. That's not the case, it continues to rise. If it decreased that would suggest an improvement in health (un-aging) at 85, which doesn't occur. Having an average at some point doesn't mean there's a bell curve around it. The average of a uniform distribution [0-100] may be 50, but there's no bell curve around 50. It's just a uniform distribution all the way through.
- dahart 11y agoYou misunderstood me and confused the probability of dying by 85 with the probability of dying at 85. You're talking about the cumulative distribution and I was talking about the probability distribution. The chance of death at a given age is a bell curve. The chance that I'll die at 150 years old is zero, it is less than the chance that I'll die at age 70. The chance that I'll die by the time I'm 150 is 100%.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Jtsummers 11y agoThe chance of death at a given age oughtn't be a bell curve. The chance of me (33) dying at 60 are much higher than the chance of my coworker (65) dying at 60. There's a shear drop off at the age in question. After that point you have 0 chance of dying at the particular age, it's not a bell curve. So I feel like I still don't understand what you're getting at in your example.
- dahart 11y agoDo you want to understand? I'll try to help, but it seems like I'm using math terminology and concepts you're not familiar with, and I don't want to presume you're interested in learning math. Sadly, we're not even talking about the meat of my point, you got stuck on the uncontroversial preface to my real point. My point was that Nautilus is wrong and maybe being sneaky by saying that aging accelerates near the end of life because the probability of dying is going up. That's not true, and the bowling analogy shows why. Over time, the probability of pins being knocked over goes up. But you can't conclude that the bowling ball is accelerating. The author made an incorrect conclusion from the data to make his point. It might be intentionally misleading, or it might be a mistake, but it's nonetheless incorrect to suggest that an increase in the probability of death must have been caused by an increase in the rate of aging. Now, if you want to learn the difference between CDF and PDF, look at the first two pictures in this article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normal_distribution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normal_distribution I'm not saying that the PDF of death by age should be a bell curve, I'm stating a fact. It already is a bell curve. Go look at the data. You're trying to argue against reality with logic. You're right, it doesn't have to be a bell curve. But it IS a bell curve. https://www.longevitas.co.uk/site/images/ELT15.png https://www.longevitas.co.uk/site/images/ELT15.png http://www.aihw.gov.au/uploadedImages/Subjects/Deaths/age-death-figure1.png?n=2358 http://www.aihw.gov.au/uploadedImages/Subjects/Deaths/age-de... http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200304/ldselect/ldeucom/165/4051902.gif http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200304/ldselect/l... Very few people die of old age at 55. Many people die of old age at 80. Very few people die of old age at 100, because there are very few people left. That's a bell curve. Does that make more sense?