3 ms·
If influencing climate change is the main goal, aren't saving lives and making new people two of the worst things to do? If people are the cause of climate cha
by paulcole 11y ago
If influencing climate change is the main goal, aren't saving lives and making new people two of the worst things to do?
If people are the cause of climate change, then fewer people seems like the best solution, no?
- NhanH 11y agoAnd if fewer people is the best solution, then letting climate change to run its course seems like a decent choice too. I don't mean to make a mockery of your comment by any mean, I agree with it. Just wanted to point out that the whole situation is very nuisance. (As in, you can't just point to everyone and claim "don't do this, don't do that, save the planet" -- the science itself is clear)
- J-dawg 11y agoThis is the problem with any suggestion that we voluntarily limit our carbon-emitting activities. If we take the argument to its logical conclusion, we should all stop reproducing altogether. It's the 'dead great-grandfather principle' [0]: "He’s much greener than you, you cannot compete with that. If you move into a smaller apartment, your grandfather is in a very, very small apartment. It’s underground, there’s no lighting, there’s no heating, he doesn’t have any broadband." I don't disagree with you or the parent comment at all, I absolutely believe that we should be limiting our carbon emissions. But at its core this is a philosophical problem as much as a scientific one. To what extent do we have the 'right' to change the climate? Should we have a per-person carbon allowance? A global one child policy? [0] http://www.wired.com/2011/02/transcript-of-reboot-11-speech-by-bruce-sterling-25-6-2009/ http://www.wired.com/2011/02/transcript-of-reboot-11-speech-...
- hackuser 11y ago> To what extent do we have the 'right' to change the climate? It may not be a very novel question. What right do we have to pollute our environment? I can't emit lead from my car, or toxic vapors from my home or workplace. Greenhouse gasses are just more gassous pollutants among many others.