3 ms·
"Surely everyone experienced at these competitions would quickly figure out that lisp et al are huge competitive advantages, and everyone would quickly switch."
by jerf 17y ago
"Surely everyone experienced at these competitions would quickly figure out that lisp et al are huge competitive advantages, and everyone would quickly switch."
You missed the part where I pointed out that current major competitions don't accept arbitrary languages. That's the key point of my post. All else is not even. If they did accept arbitrary languages I would accept your logic, given sufficient time for network effects to wear off.
Otherwise, if you're going to argue that it's the people and their experience that really matter, you reduce back down to my point, which is that all the experienced people have their experience in C++ as cost-of-entry to the major contest sites and thus tended to use C++ as the language they have by orders of magnitude the most experience in by virtue of it being the only sane choice of the ones actually offered, rather than any intrinsic advantage C++ has over the non-offered languages.
- dutchflyboy 17y ago"You missed the part where I pointed out that current major competitions don't accept arbitrary languages." In this competition, if you wanted to use another language, you just needed to make a starter package (a stupid bot) and some instructions to get the compiler working on their end. So in this competition, arbitrary languages where accepted.
- eru 17y agoOh, he talked about learning effects from other competitions. The fact that you could use other languages here doesn't interfere with the argument. (Though you are right, of course.)
- dutchflyboy 17y agoHmm, you're right, I misread his comment. Sorry for the confusion.
- jcl 17y agoAlso, there are programming contests that accept other languages, but because these contests tend to focus on finding an algorithm of a given efficiency, it becomes hard to tune the time limits for multiple languages. So they tune to the most efficient/popular languages, which puts everyone not using C++ at a disadvantage. See, for example, the comments on this page: http://www.spoj.pl/problems/ABCDEF/ http://www.spoj.pl/problems/ABCDEF/