8 ms·
Physics Makes Aging Inevitable, Not Biology
- mhb 11y agoAnd yet my refrigerator keeps my food cold.
- themgt 11y agoSimple analogy: would it be possible to design a digital hardware/software robot (and set of tools), such that the robot could: 1) build/maintain the tools it needs 2) use tools/knowledge/skill to repair/rebuild/replace its parts, good-as-new 3) transfer it's software from the old parts to the new parts when necessary 4) achieve immortality If so, one needs to argue why this analogy could not hold for biological life, why any underlying hardware or software cannot in principle be replaced/repaired/migrated to maintain the immortal being. Obviously this avoids arguments over the self/persistence of identity (ship of theseus), but it's not directly relevant to the article.
- esahione 11y agoIt is true. The Von Neumann Universal Constructor is one.
- otto_ortega 11y agoEntropy is the driving force of the universe and the one that rules life and death, it's particularly interesting the relationship between the drop in the internal temperature and the stretched survival curve... I suspect that something similar is the cause for the "time dilatation" effect of living things moving at high speed, the rate at which entropy advances should reduce and hence the reduced decay rate. Still looking for a speed-entropy relationship though. Anyway, loved the reading. I have entretained similar thoughts about the relationship between entropy and death for some time.
- esahione 11y agoInevitability to me is the Sun becoming a Red Giant. Aging is definitely not inevitable - hydras are a counterexample (and thus refute his claim). He uses the same argument as Aubrey de Grey but reaches the opposite conclusion. If aging is caused by the accumulation of mutations and 'wear and tear' then we can control it. All we need are properly placed stem cells derived from your 'unmutated' cells and taking care of the damage caused by our metabolism. I mean: we have 37+ trillion cells in our body. To find a lot of them that haven't suffered any mutation shouldn't be hard. We could even take a billion cells and use the most common base for a given position - in the end it should lead to your original dna because each cell would have base mutations in random areas. Or we could freeze a sample of DNA when we are young to ensure we have a non-mutated cell-line available for therapy.
- sekasi 11y agoI hate to be the wikipedia poster here, but the entry on Biological Immortality does make for a good read in this context; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_immortality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_immortality
- bobwaycott 11y ago> Or we could freeze a sample of DNA when we are young to ensure we have a non-mutated cell-line available for therapy. So we just need some light, paradox-correcting time travel for those of us that have presumably passed the point of freezing young-enough DNA. :)
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI'd rather use software to error/spell check my genome, and slowly edit to improve over time with crispr. No need to focus on my genome at birth.
- bobwaycott 11y agoI really love the error/spellcheck analogy.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThanks! I wish I could take credit, but I recall reading it in a passage about future tech possibilities in the book "Superintelligence": https://www.amazon.com/Superintelligence-Dangers-Strategies-Nick-Bostrom-ebook/dp/B00LOOCGB2 https://www.amazon.com/Superintelligence-Dangers-Strategies-...
- bobwaycott 11y agoOh, nice. I hadn't heard of this book before. Thanks for the pointer. I'll have to check it out.
- esahione 11y ago
- wnoise 11y ago> If this interpretation of the data is correct, then aging is a natural process that can be reduced to nanoscale thermal physics—and not a disease. How does that follow? Compare with "Measles is a natural process that can be reduced to nanoscale viruses -- and not a disease."
- stcredzero 11y agoHow about, "DNA damage from radiation is a natural process that can be reduced to nanoscale particle physics." This article is surprisingly fluffy. It doesn't mention SENS at all, which addresses some of these points. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategies_for_Engineered_Negligible_Senescence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategies_for_Engineered_Negl...
- easong 11y agoIt's disappointing that this article doesn't address the various animals with a degree of biological immortality (eg jellyfish, lobsters). I'm not convinced that the laws of thermodynamics make (human-scale) aging inevitable and insurmountable if there are several unrelated critters who have managed it. More likely is that immortal monkeys don't make evolutionary sense given the energy requirements.
- msegal 11y agoAnother article in the same Nautilus chapter addresses some of the variety of aging styles in other plants and animals (and concludes that aging is not in fact inevitable): http://nautil.us/issue/36/aging/why-aging-isnt-inevitable http://nautil.us/issue/36/aging/why-aging-isnt-inevitable
- reasonattlm 11y agoLobsters are probably on the way out of the possibly immortal and into the negligibly senescent category. They were only in the former category because there was no way to measure the age of an arbitrary sample of lobsters retrieved from the wild. Researchers did find a way to measure lobster age reliably a few years back, so data will emerge on their life spans over the next few decades. It isn't a well populated or well funded area of study, so results tend to lag. http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2012/12/tree-rings-lobsters http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2012/12/tree-rings-lobsters
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoIf these arguments are followed to their logical conclusion, biological life could not exist. It's biology (and perhaps a bit of philosophy) that divides a parent from a child. The physics doesn't care that the cell is in contact with a separate brain. And for single-celled or asexually reproducing organisms, the division between parent and child is even less obvious, but those organisms still exist.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- fragsworth 11y agoThis article is complete and utter nonsense. Anything can be made to last arbitrarily long, given enough external resources/energy and the ability to replace its parts.
- bordercases 11y agoTaking the strong computationalist view here: You need to consider the complexity-class of the operation for a claim like that to be meaningful. Human beings might be outside of anything tractable beyond whatever class growing a human being is in.
- crimsonalucard 11y agoNot true. Entropy wins, eventually.
- xlm1717 11y ago>They found that the shape of the survival curve remained essentially the same, but it was stretched or contracted as the temperature was changed. Creatures raised at lower temperature enjoyed a stretched survival curve, while worms exposed to higher temperature lived shorter lives. So sci-fi stasis had it right all long.
- esahione 11y agoWe knew they were right way before that: chemical reactions happen more slowly when colder. If you freeze your body nothing moves within your body and thus you don't age. Biggest problem is that water expands when frozen and bursts the cell walls D:
- mrfusion 11y agoOne example of immortality in humans is the egg cells. http://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/egg-cetera-1-the-immortal-egg http://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/egg-cetera-1-the-immortal...
- awinter-py 11y agoArticle doesn't address the question of whether a short lifespan is adaptive (i.e. whether current 'limits' on lifespan have nothing to do with systematic barriers). One reason for this would be the need to pack in more generations under conditions where rapid change is necessary in order to compete. The research on extra copies of tumor-fighter TP53 in elephants suggests that when the conditions are right, senescence can be rolled back. The fact that mammoths are extinct and elephants are next could mean there are downsides to this evolutionary strategy.
- bitwize 11y agoMammoths are extinct and elephants are "next" because of human hunting.
- awinter-py 11y agoAnother way to say that is that hominids with shorter lifespans out-evolved them. Today elephants are threatened more by habitat competition with us than demand for ivory or meat. Farmers at the edge of the wildlife parks in india and africa don't want to kill the elephants, they're protecting their crops. Orangutans are in the same boat. Another perspective is that long cancer-free lives turned the pleistocene megafauna into meat repositories for any smart, mobile team predator, and that if primates didn't use the mammoths as a safe way into the arctic some other pack animal would have (wolves, for example). Causation is hard to model in coevolution. People who study e.g. bacteriophages use the term 'domestication' to describe how coevolution partners influence each other; if you're going to read one paper about this read the one about bracoviruses and butterflies, it's eerie.
- thescriptkiddie 11y agoThis is the same kind of fundamental misunderstanding of physics that leads to arguments like "evolution can't exist because of the second law of thermodynamics". Living things are not closed systems, the inevitable increase in the sum total entropy in the universe has no bearing on their ability to repair themselves.
- GrayTShirt 11y agoI came here, to basically say the same thing. It seems folks do not realize the assumptions they are making. Fundamentals people fundamentals.
- theophrastus 11y agoYes indeed, and during the drunken biochemists' ball the suggested definition of life: "an entropy catalyst" wasn't the worst one (by far)
- gertef 11y ago> drunken biochemists' ball what's this? > an entropy catalyst" should be "anti-entropy catalyst", yes?
- theophrastus 11y agoy'know how every university department has a yearly "retreat"? The parent poster made an incisive reference to: "living things are not closed systems, the inevitable increase in the sum total entropy in the universe.."; and so it is. A living process maintains its own internal order at the cost of the entropy and energy of its surroundings. Life increases the entropy of its surroundings at a higher rate than in its absence. (of course so does fire, and that's why this is only not the worst definition)
- arikrak 11y agoI think the author's point is since aging is related to physics, you're facing exponentially increasing problems[1]. This will make it much harder to make progress against than the battle infectious diseases. (There were some similar articles a while back that focused on cancer specifically.) [1] As opposed to there being some biological effect that you could try to 'turn off'.
- ck2 11y agoExcept there are already known (rare) people who seem to age much much more slowly from superior genetics.
- ori_b 11y agoThe point seems a bit fatuous, a bit like arguing that a modern desktop machine isn't turing complete because there is a finite amount of memory. No, we can't reverse entropy, or avoid damage to our bodies. But that says nothing about whether we can slow it down, or do enough self repair, to consider these problems practically solved.
- CorvusCrypto 11y ago"If this interpretation of the data is correct, then aging is a natural process that can be reduced to nanoscale thermal physics" - this was utter crap. No wonder this guy is at a liberal arts college. You can't equate atomic force breakage to senescence. Without any scientific linkage it's like linking the sinusoidal pattern of seasonal temperatures to the amplitude of an alternating current. Welp, must mean that the basis of temperature is electricity right? "But the sheer number of possibilities being put forward refutes the very possibility. They can’t all be the cause of aging." - Wrong, more likely it's a mix of all of them. You can cruise PLoS One and realize that most researches in this area realize that it's likely a combination of many underlying factors from other researchers' discoveries that contribute to aging. One more thing, how does an open system become limited to the second law of thermo like a closed one? Stay scientific Hoffman.
- eva1984 11y agoNo...If you can change all the atoms in your body. U can probably live longer...
- JadeNB 11y ago> No...If you can change all the atoms in your body. U can probably live longer... Indeed, and if we declare each apparently dead person to have transferred his or her identity to someone born just a few moments before, then no-one will ever die.
- guelo 11y agoThe quest for immortality is the ultimate selfish narcism. The species is already immortal and will do fine without you. An almost identical human will take your place when you're gone and that human will have almost identical thoughts and feelings as you. Why does the species need to keep an old atrophying individual around? What's the point?
- JadeNB 11y ago> The quest for immortality is the ultimate selfish narcism. The species is already immortal and will do fine without you. Doing science is the ultimate narcissism. The universe operates according to scientific laws, and will do so just fine whether or not you understand them.
- m0llusk 11y agoSystems Thinking and simulations show why aging is such a great idea. Death energizes reproduction and renewal so that no particular pattern can dominate and experimentation and adaptation are organic components of continuation.
- alok-g 11y agoIs there a known explanation of how a newborn gets its biological age reset, given that the newborn starts from the cells from its aged parents? If the answer is not understood, it may be easier to research this instead by studying say zygote formation.