4 ms·
This title seems editorialized: the title here on HN is ambiguous about whether the "reason" is "because of" or "to prevent", while the title of the actual arti
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
This title seems editorialized: the title here on HN is ambiguous about whether the "reason" is "because of" or "to prevent", while the title of the actual article makes that clearer.
If drivers aren't getting paid enough to want to drive for a particular company, they should build the "tip" into the price, to make sure everyone gets paid enough. But the right response to good/bad service is a rating, not a tip. A field for a tip implies that the "real" price is higher than advertised, because only a monster wouldn't tip, and that bad service just means a lower tip. A rating system makes sure that all drivers must provide good service, and the company should be making sure they get paid accordingly.
Transportation isn't a service where it's acceptable to have good drivers who get paid more and bad drivers who get paid less, no matter what mechanism implements that pay differential. There should only be "good" drivers.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoThere are good reasons to tip a good driver beyond the stated cost of the service. Maybe they know the area well enough to get you through during rush hour. If you have a car seat you need to install and they can help quickly (as well as drive smoothly to keep the child from acting up) that is also a boon. If any service is exceptional, I am always happy to tip, even if I am already paying the full price (and living wage).
- jasode 11y ago>Transportation isn't a service where it's acceptable to have good drivers who get paid more and bad drivers who get paid less, no matter what mechanism implements that pay differential. There should only be "good" drivers. Of course, there's no universal authority on what "tipping" actually means but I think many people (both the riders & drivers) understand that tipping is for the "service" portion that's not related to the driving. E.g. carrying the suitcases, pointing out the landmarks like a tourist guide, etc. The "driving" component of getting from point A to point B in a safe manner, without making incompetent U-turns, etc is the baseline. The tipping isn't for that. E.g. I usually don't tip the Hertz/Avis car rental bus driver but if I'm trying to carry 3 bags and he helps me with them, I will tip him. All that said, it's possible that some Uber drivers want extra tip money just for the sake of extra money. Like others, I also prefer transactions where there is no tipping expected. It would be annoying to scramble for some loose dollar bills to tip the flight attendants as I try to rush off the airplane to make a connection.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> The "driving" component of getting from point A to point B in a safe manner, without making incompetent U-turns, etc is the baseline. The tipping isn't for that. That's how it should work, yes, but once tips become an option, tipping culture takes over in awful ways. Consider that the expectation in US restaurants is a 10-15% tip at minimum, for baseline competent service, and anything less suggests that your food came with extra saliva. That's not a healthy process.
- st3v3r 11y agoShould. Should. But that's not the way reality is right now.