11 ms·
New US Army Tech Instantly Destroys Enemy Fire
- Aelinsaar 11y agoNot the most accurate headline, but it's about time that we started implementing this at the level of individual tanks and APC's, not just warships.
- bhouston 11y agoIt isn't US Army tech, it is mostly Israeli army tech that was developed to manage the Palestinian population in Gaza and the West Bank.
- tormeh 11y agoThere are two Israeli offers, one American and one German. That's just 50% subjugation of Palestinian territories. Get your facts straight.
- partiallypro 11y agoThe article actually mentions this (and an Israeli defense contractor is a one of the few that's lobbying for it.) I think the key difference, from my understanding, is that it has never been deployed onto a convoy. Also the "Iron Curtain" relies on the projectiles being lobbed instead of shot directly, since the people shooting those projectiles into Israel don't care who they hit military or civilian. It has been interesting watching defense move along, from the Patriot missile program, to the Iron Curtain, and now something that is mobile and can take on smaller projectiles.
- thinkcontext 11y agoI think you are confusing Iron Curtain with Iron Dome. Iron Dome is the area anti rocket / mortar (lobbed) system. Iron Curtain is a system that protects individual vehicles from "shot directly" projectiles like RPGs.
- Kristine1975 11y ago>to manage the Palestinian population in Gaza and the West Bank >manage the Palestinian population Not sure if that euphemism is beautiful or really horrifying...
- Thriptic 11y agoIron Dome
- venomsnake 11y agoBeing under constant threat helps to develop defensive technology. Israeli developers have very tight feedback loops. And they see first hand what happens when they fail.
- tyingq 11y agoThere's 3 vendors working on this. A (older) video of one of them in action, blocking an incoming RPG headed towards a Humvee: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_yz_ONZltA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_yz_ONZltA
- imaginenore 11y agoRussians have had it for a while. It's called Arena: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YpmcmKwWzYo&t=1m36s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YpmcmKwWzYo&t=1m36s
- pandemicsyn 11y agoYup, and Israel has had Rafael's Trophy system deployed since 09 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OtMgnRMIspQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OtMgnRMIspQ
- vonmoltke 11y agoIron Curtain and Quick Kill (not mentioned in the article) have been in development since 2006. The idea and the capability is nowhere near as new as the article implies. The slow adoption my the US and Israel is motivated more by the collateral damage concerns that caused the Russians to scrap the Drozd system in 1980. As far as I know, Arena has similar issues, just not nearly as badly as Drozd (which basically shot a 107mm fragmentation grenade at the incoming round).
- gonzo41 11y agoThis is just the extreme miniaturization of counter battery fire. CIWS for tanks. My mind immediately thinks of the poor dismounted infantry near this thing when its engaged. We'll quickly be approaching the debate similar to the self driving car. Does it crash and kill the driver to protect pedestrians. or vice versa. Protect the men or the tank? The military is better at resolving these sorts of issues. Tanks are a force multiplier, Keeping them in the fight is important (worth the collateral?). But cheap options work aswell. Plenty of men alive and LAVs still rolling along thanks to bar armour.
- 11thEarlOfMar 11y ago' “Dozens of threats were launched at these platforms, many of which would have been lethal to these vehicles. Trophy engaged those threats and defeated them in all cases with no collateral injury and no danger to the dismounts and no false engagement,” the DRS official said.' The RPG-7 travels at a maximum velocity of 295 m/s. Fired from 200 meters and assuming linear acceleration, that means you'd have roughly 1-2 seconds to identify it, calculate trajectory and fire the interceptor. Compare this to intercepting an ICBM, which travels at a maximum (re-entry) velocity of 7,000 m/s. Fired from several thousand miles, you'd have about 30 minutes to identify it, calculate trajectory and fire the interceptor.
- adewinter 11y agoThe two systems are definitely not in the same league (agreed!), if that's what you're pointing out. That said, the time required to calculate an intercept point is not the hard problem, so 1-2 seconds versus 30 minutes is not really super relevant. Arguably more relevant factors are detection, precision, accuracy and ultimate intercept effectiveness. In the case of ICBM you're essentially trying to hit one bullet with another bullet... hundreds of miles away. It doesn't matter that you have 30 minutes to think about it. It's still ridiculously hard to actually know there's an icbm, where it is, and then be able to hit it with another missile (and have that make a difference). RPGs around a armored vehicle are way more straightforward by comparison. The projectile is easier to detect, it's a much smaller volume of space (easier to scan continuously) and the projectiles are traveling slower! Still I imagine it's quite a trick detecting incoming then swiveling, aiming and firing (accurately) your defense auto-cannon all in 1-2 seconds. It would be very impressive to see that in action.
- 11thEarlOfMar 11y agoYeah, for me, it's the intercepting projectile. One is a bullet fired from auto-aiming system, the other a rocket with a guidance system. Bullets vs. rockets definitely not the same thing. Still, the performance of Trohpy is impressive. And, it has actually been proven to work in combat, something we pray to never see with ICBMs.
- unwind 11y agoFrom an extremely cursory look, the Wikipedia page on the system in question ("Trophy") is way more informative: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trophy_%28countermeasure%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trophy_%28countermeasure%29.
- rfreytag 11y agoSomething inbound to a ship that doesn't support aircraft can be assumed hostile meriting a violent response with reasonable safety. The same assumption cannot be made of objects inbound to a tank passing through a village with playful children.
- jonnycowboy 11y agoThe technology does not destroy the attacker but the projectile. Also I assume objects travelling below a certain speed or heat threshold are not "processed" so most children or children-thrown objects would not be targeted.
- Kristine1975 11y ago>so most children or children-thrown objects would not be targeted. >most Great/s
- pc86 11y agoThis seems like a willful misinterpretation of the comment.
- mark_chosenberg 11y agoDo not mind the naysayers, they may be vocal now but Tsahal will also deal with them with equal retribution once the constant threat of palestinians is eradicated.
- vlehto 11y ago...so next step would be strapping anti-tank mine to heavy duty quadcopter? Another possibility would be adding stealthy nose-cones to RPGs. Then you have to increase radar power of the defending system. ...which would help enemy artillery to target the tanks. I'm not saying this system is nullified. Just that there will be ways to bypass it.
- 11y ago
- spatulan 11y agoThe US Army's version might be new, but the general idea isn't. The Russian Drozd is the earliest of this type of system I'm aware of, and that was fielded in the late 70s.
- mcguire 11y agoI assume the idea goes back to reactive armor: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactive_armour https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactive_armour
- mcguire 11y ago"The Defense Review report also says that Iron Curtain’s sensors can target destroy approaching RPG fire to within one-meter of accuracy." Can anyone translate that into English?
- vonmoltke 11y agoI think "destroy" was left in by mistake, and the sentence is supposed to say that the system's targeting has a maximum of 1m position error.
- dragonwriter 11y agoProbably a 1m CEP [0] or similar rather than maximum error. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_error_probable https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_error_probable
- knodi123 11y ago"The Defense Review report also says that Iron Curtain’s sensors can target destroy approaching RPG fire to within 3.28 feet of accuracy"
- coredog64 11y agoI feel like reality is finally catching up with David Drake. Now we are just waiting on 400kg fusion plants and hover tanks.
- breischl 11y agoI had the same thought. I seem to recall that they could also link the entire brigade together into one giant air defense network. I wonder if they'll do something like that for the anti-missile systems, maybe at a platoon level. Or maybe just have the next tank in line automatically kill the attacker.
- hga 11y agoIndeed, all the "tribarrels" (equivalent to the M2 Browning used in Vietnam (or, rather, back from 1933 to today, it's a keeper)) could be/were slaved to the anti-artillery and air network, and could be automatically taken away from their operators to stop an incoming barrage. They had proximity fuzed Claymore style anti-"buzz bomb" defenses, but arming those was problematical for a zillion reasons, the best defenses were as they are today, sharp eyes and trigger fingers. Later killing a buzz bomb team that killed a super expensive tank and its crew was not considered an acceptable exchange.
- hackuser 11y agoI read elsewhere that a principle challenge of this tech is not to kill your own people who are near the protected vehicle.
- Kristine1975 11y agoI don't see the problem. Self-LART's have a long and colorful history.
- Mizza 11y agoI'm very skeptical of this technology. The Russian equivalent is currently deployed on T90s in Syria, but has been shown useless against rebel ATGMs. Ex - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2rfyeR-YaJw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2rfyeR-YaJw [War footage, crew survives but maybe NSFW depending on your sensitivity level.] The tank was disabled but not fatally (it was later repaired and put back in service), but that's just because the T-90 is a great tank and the shot was unlucky. You can see the damaged reactive defense system on the right from after this hit: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Cd_gdCnWoAA5tyN.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Cd_gdCnWoAA5tyN.jpg They said it was because the hatch was open, but I think it's actually because this is pure snake oil. It's just too hard.
- reality_hacker 11y agoSuccess is a combination of idea and right implementation. Maybe T-90 suffers from problems with second.
- Mizza 11y agoYeah, but I think that's going to be the case for the foreseeable future for all vendors. They can all make compelling pitches and demo videos, but as far as I know there's no evidence of any of these systems actually working on the battlefield.
- benologist 11y agoIsrael's shot a bunch of projectiles out of the air after detecting and calculating their trajectory in flight. What makes smaller projectiles much harder?
- Mizza 11y agoOcclusion. I watch a lot of ATGM videos, and most of the shots are when tanks are parked next to buildings, driving through an urban environment, or perched on a hill, rather than in open terrain. There is very little time to react no close range sensors.
- cptskippy 11y agoOff topic but I found it disturbing the way they kept saying "Allahu Akbar". It reminded me of Frisky Dingo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LmnaeU0k80I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LmnaeU0k80I.
- gamegoblin 11y agoIt is very commonly used to express astonishment or surprise, the same way we say "Oh my god!" in English.
- dang 11y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11685052 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11685052 and marked it off-topic.
- elif 11y agoThings like this, along with the new suite of drone modules capable of jamming/destroying radars, seem to be creating an atmosphere where our military can operate with relative impunity. That is not, in itself, an ethical problem. If we can kill 1,000 people with 0 deaths, however, the ethical bar for how we apply that force should be held to a stricter standard, as the slope to fascism is being made steeper. Unfortunately, the recent trend of extrajudicial, extralegal executive action 'war' declaration post-9/11 appears to be lowering that bar. Even if you think there is a moral imperative to every one of our military deployments: having no skin in the game also makes it easier to demonize us, to the benefit of anti-US propaganda.
- ultraforce 11y agoI think with a situation such as this it may make the prioritizing of only damaging enemy combatants, of course this is suggesting the term enemy combatants being based around people engaging directly at firing weapons towards those that the us military or those who are employed by the military are in charge of protecting or themselves.
- InclinedPlane 11y ago> If we can kill 1,000 people with 0 deaths, however, the ethical bar for how we apply that force should be held to a stricter standard... What do you mean "if"? We've already killed thousands of people with drone strikes. And sadly the ethical bar on that is not held to a stricter standard, indeed it's held to a lower standard. Some people are targeted based on social networking algorithms that are hugely flawed. The ratio of "collateral damage" deaths to "good kills" is perhaps as low as 50/50, maybe even worse, since there's very little investigative followup.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoMostly this seems to advocate the US adopting the Trophy system from Rafael although it does mention there are other vendors in the picture. The fundamental point, which is also made in Dunnigan's "How to Make War" is that the cost of fortification goes up faster than the cost of attack capability, so you can only match scale if you use two attack systems. Or to put it in terms of this article, if you added 50 tons of armor to a tank it might be impervious to RPG fire but also unable to move effectively. The cost of building a guided munition has gone down with the miniaturization of sensors and compute power, and a number of field deployed systems (like Iron Dome and Trophy) have demonstrated that calculating intercept solutions has given the designers of such systems the ability to defeat or at least mitigate very near threats. But given that I wonder just how many "army on army" sorts of wars will be waged. Looking at the tactics of modern day insurgencies they hit civilians rather than military forces. Back in the day there was a front line of multiple opposing armies engaged in control over a battlefield while their aircraft went behind the lines and bombed the cities to degrade infrastructure. Today there is no "front line" just bombs going off in cities degrading infrastructure. And no visible army (well its fine when its attacking but between attacks it blends in). As a result, the militaries of the world are developing strategies for moving around killing people without themselves being at risk. This tank strategy is already deployed in Israel. The ultimate answer to that seems to be remotely operated robotics. No threat to the operator, and equipped with a variety of offensive weapons to dealing with threats to others. I am not looking forward to the day where you have a self driving tank which is impossible to kill. But when I look at the road we're on, I see that we are headed to that place.
- zipwitch 11y agoScience fiction author Keith Laumer had a few ideas along these lines as far back as the 1960s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bolo_%28tank%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bolo_%28tank%29
- partycoder 11y agoThere is a saying: "you don't put a $100 lock on a $50 bike". I think the same applies here. If to block a $300 RPG (hypothetical cost, i don't know what the cost is), costs $10000, then they still win.
- schwap 11y agoNot if blocking a $300 RPG for $10000 prevents $100000 of damage to the intended target of said RPG.
- partycoder 11y agoYes, from the perspective of the defender it's better. I am only saying, that for the attacker, it only means winning less, as opposed to not winning.
- white-flame 11y agoIn cases where the attacker is strapped for cash, and the defender is not, $300 could be far more relative value to the attacker than $10k is to the defender.
- informatimago 11y agoThe more so when the "defender" is printing its USD at will.
- partycoder 11y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6vi528gseA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6vi528gseA
- dogma1138 11y agoAn experienced tank crew is worth more than a tank. One of the main reasons that Israel has developed so many defensive technologies is that it understood that keeping your experience and trains personnel alive is the only way to win a war of attrition no matter how much man power you can muster to replace casualties.