6 ms·
There's an iOS device attached to my Google account and I own no Apple products
- puzzle 11y agoThe most likely explanation is that one of his devices visited YouTube over HTTP (not HTTPS) and his ISP "helpfully" installed some kind of caching proxy that returned the wrong cookies to the wrong user. ISP have been known to cause mixups like that when cranking up caching aggressiveness to 11.
- justizin 11y agoThat doesn't really explain an iOS device being attached to the account.
- puzzle 11y agoThe ISP might have return his cookie to someone else running iOS. The fact that it only happened for a few hours might be explained by cache expiration.
- ben_jones 11y agoIf ISP's are returning cookies from the wrong users, wouldn't it also be possible for login credentials (stored within cookies) to be returned as well?
- puzzle 11y agoLogin cookies are usually sent over HTTPS. Check your browser's cookie store, you'll see that Google services use so many of them, also because of the many hostnames and domains they are on. I suspect YouTube cookies because you can't use google.com ones directly on its domain. And the console mentions devices that have been used with the account, not that have been logged in or have attempted to do so (an important distinction), which points again to cookies. If he used Chrome or another browser supporting ChannelID, such a mixup would have no consequence, because Google's GFE would detect the situation and mint new cookies or redirect the user to a login page.
- cortesoft 11y agoYoutube redirects all http requests to https
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Buge 11y agoAt no point should the ISP know his or any other user's cookies. If youtube is at all set up correctly, login cookies would be marked secure and only sent over https.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pbarnes_1 11y agoNo 2FA? That's... an interesting security choice.
- gcb0 11y agofor YouTube viewing? really? why would I go over the hassle to see cat videos? the worst that can happen is someone steal my like or generate fake ad revenue. not everyone have their life attached to a google account.
- chrisbolt 11y ago> why would I go over the hassle to see cat videos? the worst that can happen is someone steal my like or generate fake ad revenue. ...or log in with an iOS device and freak you out, leading you to write a blog post about it. This is a blog post about possibly unauthorized access to a Google account, pointing out the lack of 2FA is perfectly valid given the context.
- stormbrew 11y agoThis would be a valid point if not for the fact that Google forces you into using the same login across its sites in the same browser session. It's not really practical (without going to greater lengths than just using 2FA to begin with) to use a different/no login on youtube than the rest of the Googleverse.
- pbarnes_1 11y agoThe blog post is just a wall of text about an unexpected login to a Google account. 2FA would have stopped that from happening. It doesn't matter what you use your Google account for. 2FA is a must. The end.
- caf 11y ago...manufactures are known to leave unpatched versions of glibc, openssl and the built-in web browser... Android doesn't use glibc.
- markcerqueira 11y ago"I use a secure password algorthym." Maybe my notion of secure is wrong, but I didn't find it particularly secure ("Ensure your system always gives you a password between 8 and 9 characters long") or even convenient (absolutely no mention of password managers, system is based on memorization). And then moments later: "I currently don’t have two factor authentication." Just seems like there's two people behind this post: one who is concerned about security and one who doesn't fully leverage tools to enhance their security. Not ragging on the author. This just stuck out at me. I'm genuinely curious and would love a follow-up if author can discover what happened.
- ap22213 11y agoQuantitatively, how much more secure would using two factor authentication be over what the author is doing? Edit: Assuming that someone only crafts 9-plus-character passwords that don't show up in dictionary attacks and aren't reused across sites, is 2FA going to secure that person much more? I'm not challenging 2FA. Actually, I'm just trying to motivate myself to use it.
- shaftway 11y agoIf done properly, immensely. Sites can log invalid password attempts, and unscrupulous sites could include attempted usernames and passwords. That basically gives them a dictionary of accounts to try, because let's face it, most people use the same password for multiple services. Sometimes people's muscle memory kicks in and they accidentally type their password into the wrong site, or the wrong field. With Google's 2FA, you need access to either a pre-printed list of emergency codes, or the ability to see the person's incoming texts. That's where the "if done properly" caveat comes in. Google Voice is generally a bad idea. If someone accidentally gets into your email because you left it open, they also have access to your incoming texts.
- newjersey 11y agoI'd like to respectfully disagree. When done correctly, Google Voice can be as good as if not better than a traditional cell phone. I treat my email with more care than I treat my bank accounts. However, Google Voice is probably not as good as the app on your phone though.
- cmdrfred 11y agoMaybe the iViewedThis api endpoint on the YouTube ios app is not/was not checking tokens correctly?
- jamescostian 11y agoOne possibility is the author logged into an iOS device to check it out - e.g. one of the devices Apple stores have lying around for people to test out - and then forgot to logout, so when other people used YouTube on the same device, their views were logged under the author's account
- tantalor 11y agoThis is super easy to do accidentally if you log into Google while simulating a mobile device in Chrome devtools, because your user agent string tells Google what device you are using. First verify you don't have an iPhone (or whatever) in your recently used devices: https://security.google.com/settings/security/activity https://security.google.com/settings/security/activity 1. Open Chrome incognito window 2. Open devtools 3. Toggle device mode to iPhone (or whatever) 4. http://google.com 5. Log in Now go back to recently used devices and you should see the new device. Occam's razor implies PEBKAC.
- ikeboy 11y agoBut it should still have sent an email.
- dantiberian 11y agoDoes it always send an email, or just when the connection is coming from an unexpected place? e.g. new IP address, unusual time, different cookies, e.t.c. A changed user agent on a browser is pretty small, it wouldn't surprise me if Google didn't email for things like that.
- muddi900 11y agoEvery time a new device or browser logs in I get an email
- jdavis703 11y agoRight, but the UA also includes the browser's version in it. If you change from Chrome to Safari you're indeed using a different browser. If Chrome's UA gets updated from say "Chrome 45.1.1.1.1 WebKit" to "Chrome 45.1.1.2.0 WebKit" it shouldn't really care. To be more clear in the case of changing browsers it detects this chnage via cookies, not by UA string.
- jethro_tell 11y agoSure, if it was me logging into someone else's account (and there had to be some conscious effort based on his random password), I'd log in and delete the email immediately. Delete from inbox, delete from trash, refresh.it seems like you would notice that but no one spends 24 hours a day looking at their email. It probably wouldn't be that hard to slip by the best of us. That's what two factor authentication is for. And not emailing the same account for login notifications. I just don't find this to hard to believe.
- thevibesman 11y ago(EDIT): Left my slightly off-topic comment below as it may be useful to some people anyway; as the two child commenters pointed out, this doesn't necessarily relate. It seems as if this was an attack, the non-gmail email must have been compromised as well as I don't see a way to turn off these notifications. From what I have seen assisting others with compromised Google accounts (most likely due to a phishing attack, but unconfirmed), emails that would give away the compromise are usually deleted---either manually or via a filter[1]. Sometimes these deleted mails can be retrieved because they not purged completely, but deleted mail does not show up in GMail search. [1]: If you believe your account has been compromised, check your email filters, I've seen weird delete filters added to accounts.
- zippergz 11y agoBut the email address on his account is not Gmail, so an attacker would have had to separately compromise his non-Google mail server to do achieve any of this.
- thevibesman 11y agoOh, its been a long day; I guess I forgot about that when I came back to comment. (EDIT:) Thanks for the correction.
- zippergz 11y agoI should have said, despite the fact that it doesn't fit in this specific case, your overall advice is very good. This is quite common and definitely something people should be aware of.
- reboog711 11y agoFrom the article: "I currently do not have a Gmail account associated with my Google account" Given that; I'm not sure any Gmail search settings or filters apply in this situation.
- bitmapbrother 11y agoI can't figure it out so let's blame my Android phones running a hacked ROM cobbled together by script kiddies on XDA.
- rajeevk 11y agoI had one interesting incident.. I was not able to access my twitter and gamil account both. The twitter account was associated with that gmail account. I had same password for both of them. I was able to recover my gmail as the attacker did not change the recovery email in my gmail account. And hence I could recover the twitter account too. Then again I set the same password for both of them. Next day same thing happened again. Then recovered both and set different password and since then it is fine. I wondered how someone could hack so easily. The passwords were not easy and I can not believe that anyone could guess that. I also checked the last access time in gmail and there were no suspicious activity there.
- transitorykris 11y agoI'm curious to know what the author's gmail address is. I've experienced bad behavior with the ability to add or remove dots from the mailbox name. Apple (amongst some others) allows people to register iCloud accounts using unverified email addresses. It is obviously a big leap to think the YouTube app would respect the iCloud username.
- Taylor_OD 11y agoThis is a long shot... But if you use Linkedin that could account for some of the videos. They recently added an autoplay feature for their videos on the home page that is very tedious to shut off. If you're logged into youtube on the same device it will play the videos and show up on your played videos on Youtube.