6 ms·
I'd love to see Clojure break into the mainstream. Perhaps it will, but I'm skeptical that any s-expr syntax will ever be palatable to a majority of programmers
by cageface 17y ago
I'd love to see Clojure break into the mainstream. Perhaps it will, but I'm skeptical that any s-expr syntax will ever be palatable to a majority of programmers.
I think programmers tend to overestimate the importance of language choice in the success or failure of a development project. We can passionately debate the merits of static vs dynamic typing and various schools of syntax but I suspect that ultimately the skill and determination of the people involved make the crucial difference.
That said, I do think Clojure's prospects are better than any previous lisp, because even if it can't "win" it can tag along for the ride with the rest of the Java ecosystem and benefit from its much larger momentum.
- kiba 17y agoCaribus paribus, two equally skilled programmers will differ in programming productivity by language choices.
- ewjordan 17y agoClojure has a leg up over most Lisps for another reason: the people that know Clojure well and participate in its community are not complete douchewieners, and they're willing to accept that everyone has different needs and backgrounds. They actually want people to try Clojure out (even if they were - gasp! - Java programmers!), rather than making the assumption that anyone that doesn't already worship their language as The One True Holy Solution-To-Everything Language is a moron. To hear the more vocal Common Lispers tell it, even people that code Clojure are retarded code apes that need to be lectured on why they're stupid for not using a Real Lisp, more deserving of scorn than encouragement or support. Haskell's community is not nearly as bad (Common Lisp's userbase has become one of the most bitter, self-important cesspools of snobbery the programming world has ever seen, and Haskell is far too active and useful to foster such degeneracy), but there's always that pervasive scent of "If you're not already using Haskell, you're cheating, and it's clearly because you're dumber than I am." Then again, the Haskell folks piss me off for other reasons - after studying such things in the context of real math, it's infuriating to be talked down to by people that just "got" monads and think that their shallow grasp of the concept entitles them to wield Genius Points over everyone else's heads. I suspect this is just a small but vocal sub-population in Haskell-land, but it's a really annoying one that seriously turns me off from the language...
- sutro 17y ago+1 for douchewieners.
- cageface 17y agoI actually advocated something analogous to Clojure in 2001 on comp.lang.lisp: http://lib.store.yahoo.net/lib/paulgraham/miles.txt http://lib.store.yahoo.net/lib/paulgraham/miles.txt And was pretty roundly flamed for it. In any case, I totally agree that the community surrounding common lisp is utterly and irreparably toxic and that Rich is right to ignore it and to carefully cultivate a far more civil and friendly community around Clojure. I don't know exactly what it is about functional programming that attracts people that can't tolerate different philosophies. Maybe the more Aspberger-prone coders naturally gravitate towards tools that promise to impose simple, elegant order on the inherently messy world of real-life programming.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jrockway 17y agoCommon Lisp's userbase has become one of the most bitter, self-important cesspools of snobbery the programming world has ever seen You are absolutely right here. I am not sure what caused this to happen, but I have never seen a programming community that so actively discourages code reuse. Ask why two libraries don't work together, and the answer is usually, "you shouldn't be using libraries!" Yeah. SBCL is a nice VM, but the community needs to die. Then again, the Haskell folks piss me off for other reasons - after studying such things in the context of real math, it's infuriating to be talked down to by people that just "got" monads and think that their shallow grasp of the concept entitles them to wield Genius Points over everyone else's heads. You're sort of doing the same thing, right? And in reality, the people that actually use Haskell are not like this. Don't let someone that read about Haskell on Reddit yesterday, opened ghci, and typed "let fibs = 1 : 1 : (zipWith (+) fibs $ tail fibs)" put you off. People like to be excited about things, and people that read too many programming blogs get themselves unnecessarily excited about simple things. Then when they sort of understand that simple thing, they feel the need to tell everyone. The clojure community has the "omg monads!" problem too, but that structure isn't particularly useful in Clojure and that is obvious, so people aren't as excited about it. There is plenty of annoying Clojure fanboi-ing, though... but that is true of any language. (OK, there are no Cobol fanbois.)