7 ms·
The NYPD Was Ticketing Legally Parked Cars; Open Data Put an End to It
- guelo 11y agoI don't think that's what "systematically" means.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoI do? When you're collecting two million dollars a year from ticketing legally parked cars, at less than $200 per ticket, you're not making a minor one-time error. That's a systematic practice (or, depending on your point of view, a minor one-time error that happened to be repeated 10,000 times every year).
- guelo 11y agoThe rules of the system had changed and part of the system was unaware of the change. The system was not working as a whole to intentionally ticket legally parked vehicles. It was not systematic. And it's a clickbaity title. My comment is getting downvoted to oblivion because people don't know the definition of the word.
- dingo_bat 11y agoIf it becomes illegal to pick your nose from today and you unknowingly pick your nose, would the police let you go? Would they "forgive" you for not knowing the law? That's right, they wouldn't. You would be caught and sentenced.
- tamana 11y agoThe system did not stop ticketing parkers after the law changed. The system was broken, causing systematic problems
- danso 11y agoFor people who skip straight to the comments: I couldn't fit it into the title, but the other half of the OP's title is that the author confronted the NYPD with his data analysis and they thanked him and spoke positively about the effect of open data: > “Mr. Wellington’s analysis identified errors the department made in issuing parking summonses. It appears to be a misunderstanding by officers on patrol of a recent, abstruse change in the parking rules. We appreciate Mr. Wellington bringing this anomaly to our attention... > Thanks to this analysis and the availability of this open data, the department is also taking steps to digitally monitor these types of summonses to ensure that they are being issued correctly.”* Sure, it's easy to pay lip service to open data and transparency...but I've found for the most part that bureaucracies are generally OK with open data after it's been ingrained in their culture (which is why it is so amazingly easy to get data from Florida -- they have an IT system that is optimized to handle it -- the employees don't mind fulfilling the requests since it's no skin off their back). Bloomberg got the ball rolling, and hopefully the momentum continues...I'd be happy with NYC agencies tolerating open data as a status quo...Looking forward to the day when bureaucrats and citizens can get to the point where transparency isn't seen as a zero-sum game.
- parennoob 11y agoThe fact that they thanked him means exactly zero if they don't give back the money that they got from people who were lawfully parked, but still got erroneously fined by the department for reasons that directly contradict existing law. It is easy to give verbal apologies (especially using hedging words like “....recent, abstruse change in the parking rules.” If the police are so confused by abstruse changes in the parking rules, how are normal people supposed to understand and obey them?). Monetary ones are more difficult to come by. [EDIT: To make it clear, I'm not saying the work of 'iquantny hasn't resulted in positive change. It obviously has. Just that the department's response is, in my opinion, not positive enough.]
- danso 11y agoDefinitely...it's easy for a bureaucrat to say "Thanks for the help, we'll do better next time!" if no one's getting fired.
- jasonjei 11y agoDid NYPD refund fines from erroneously paid citations?
- darpa_escapee 11y agoNo, that would mean admitting wrongdoing by their officers and that will never happen. It's also a nice revenue stream and would expose the internal pressures to raise money through ticketing by management and administrators.
- iquantny 11y agoThey admit wrongdoing in the quote.
- DiabloD3 11y agoBut there is nothing in the story stating NYC is returning the effectively stolen, as per their admission to wrongdoing, money.
- morganvachon 11y agoIt's not stolen, that implies an intent to do wrong. Per the NYPD's response (and given their candor, I find no reason to believe otherwise) it's clear this was a training issue and the officers writing the tickets were doing their duty to the best of their knowledge at the time. And having said that, yes I believe the money should be returned, and probably will.
- darpa_escapee 11y agoThey sent an email saying they made a mistake to a blogger.
- jessriedel 11y agoNot by the officers.
- esbranson 11y ago
- fsaneq2 11y agoWe need this in SF. SFMTA ticketed my car for no reason before; I tried their "appeal" process, only to get a response that sounded like they didn't even read what I said.
- twinkletwinkle 11y agoI once received a parking ticket timestamped 2 in the afternoon. Funny thing is, that day I drove across the GG Bridge and went hiking - I had photographic evidence of crossing the bridge in the morning and the toll to prove I returned in the evening. Therefore I and my car were not in the city at 2 pm and could not have parked illegally. Appeal denied.
- dragonwriter 11y agoIts quite easy to leave SF via the GGB in the morning, reenter SF via any of a variety of different routes and get a ticket at 2pm, leave SF again, and reenter via the GGB in the evening. Now, if you had described evidence of the specific location your car was at the time of the ticket, and the appeal was still denied, that might be a different story.
- fsaneq2 11y agoHeh, please, don't defend these POS. They're cheating and they know it. I got a ticket for the car being "double parked"; I sent a picture of how it was parked (right next to the curb in a legal spot). It was a rainy day, so you could even see that the car must've been in that spot for a while -- it's not like I moved it there to take a picture. Later, I got a prewritten appeal denied notice -- it wasn't even specific to double parking, and mentioned none of the evidence I sent. I also have several friends with similar experiences. So, please, let's fire them, instead of making improbable excuses.
- breakingcups 11y agoHere in the Netherlands, if a response to your appeal contains evidence that the handling officer hasn't read your appeal properly or does not give an appropriate answer to each of your objections, it is grounds to get the ticket thrown out in court EVEN if it was a legitimate ticket. An example: If you object to the calibration of the SPECS camera (e.g camera's that track you over a longer piece of road to determine your average speed) and the officer responds saying that the radar equipment was properly calibrated, you can have the ticket thrown out as it was not radar equipment that ticketed you and thus proper care wasn't shown during the handling of your appeal.
- jrockway 11y agoWhy risk parking in a questionable area like a ramp cutout when some streets have an entire extra parking lane (indicated by a picture of a bicycle)?
- ghaff 11y agoAs the article explained, tickets had been voided when cases were disputed as widely happens in just about every city. Honestly, if I were a public official reading the comments here, I'd be inclined to just go "Why do I even bother? I explained how, even though the people who hand out most of the parking tickets were educated about the change, many police officers weren't. We'll fix it now." Sure, rerun the analysis a year or two down the road. If things don't change, that's a story. But this strikes me as a nice use of open data and a reasonable response from the NYPD. You can argue that they should do pro-active refunds but a lot of addresses will have changed and it would be otherwise difficult and expensive. I'm honestly not convinced that's a reasonable expectation.
- woodman 11y ago> I'm honestly not convinced that's a reasonable expectation. It seems reasonable to me - not being allowed to keep money that isn't yours and that you shouldn't have taken (even by mistake), consider the incentives - writing a huge number of false tickets and then returning the money only to those that are willing to go through the trouble of contesting the ticket.
- ghaff 11y agoEh. Cities issue parking violations all the time when they shouldn't (partially because the rules can be confusing). And, at the same time, many, many people get off with parking violations because they weren't caught. It's hard for me to get excited about a specific group of non-violations because they happened to occur in high incidence spots as uncovered by an examination of public data. I'm not opposed to the city making a modest effort to refund money to this subset of individuals. Though if it does so I expect it will be purely because they see it as a good PR play.
- woodman 11y ago> ...all the time when they shouldn't... Yup, so maybe some harm reduction (returning money) and negative reinforcement (hassle of returning) can help incentivize an improvement in the quality of parking enforcement service. Individual employees would likely have the same level of interest that you've expressed, but department heads would have a lot more incentive to act (especially if there is any departmental rivalry). > ...many people get off with parking violations... Is your point that these people would have deserved a ticket in the past or future - so whatever, or are you talking about some sort of municipal level karma balance where individuals are irrelevant?
- mynameisnoone 11y agoNYPD ticketed Casey Neistat for not riding in the bike lane, a viral video put an end to it. ;) http://youtu.be/bzE-IMaegzQ http://youtu.be/bzE-IMaegzQ
- wyldfire 11y agoWhile I think that's a good thing, this is different from that in an interesting way. In this case, the government opted-in to releasing data to the public. And beyond that they accepted the "government bug report" from a citizen data analyst and (1) issued a correction and (2) vowed to monitor this data item going forward. A viral video is IMO not very different from having the local news media shame the government into taking the right action. While these videos have helped us reign in the systematic racism and violence of the police here in the US, it's fantastic to see the government acting in such a responsible and effective manner.
- wheelchairuser 11y agoIt seems that there are multiple failures here. 1. Designated approved cutouts should be an easier process to obtain (just try getting a stop sign/crosswalk approved in the city and you'll understand the black hole that is the DOT approval process) 2. Over eager officers issuing tickets. Pedestrian cutouts are there for a real purpose, namely accessibility for people with disabilities and wheelchairs. While it sucks for cars to get ticketed, I for one share no compassion with those people blocking cutouts in general, because they are not offering courtesy for those people who require these cutouts to live. Edit: For those suggesting that the crosswalks in the middle of the block go "nowhere" consider the following. a wheelchair user parks his/her car and exits the car. he/she will have to cross all the way to the ends of the block in order to get out of the street into safety. even it may seem like it's going nowhere, there is a real functional purpose.
- esbranson 11y ago> the black hole that is the DOT approval process Once one reads a number of successful and unsuccessful applications and their interpretation and implementation (including the substantive laws/rules, procedural laws/rules, and administrative court precedents), I think the DOT approval process would be rather clear. These processes are usually extremely verbose and pedantic for this reason. Once again I think lack of access to the law (e.g., lack of access to court decisions ala PACER) is a fundamental contributing cause underlying your claim.
- wheelchairuser 11y agoYes absolutely. However, at the same time if I'm understanding you correctly, if we take it one step further, even assuming we have easy access to court decisions, is the DOT approval process an absolute necessity to reevaluate each X number of cutouts in NYC? Would this mean that a wheelchair user should plan weeks (months) ahead to google street view every cutout within a 10 block radius of his/her destination and make a request to have it become a DOT approved ramp?
- esbranson 11y ago
- yomly 11y agoAfter recently dealing with the various governments / nationalised businesses from a number of countries I can safely say that I am well and truly fed up with their inane bureaucracy. This article doesn't surprise me: where the recent swath of internet companies seem to extoll individual agency/ownership, nationalised companies seem to preach the exact opposite - a problem is never the individual's responsibility and people seem perfectly happy to ship a borken status quo. As such, ludicrous oversights like this are a regular occurrence rather than a gross intolerable negligence. This is not even yet mentioning how awful the UX is for the customer who has to interface with these institutions. While it may be very easy to discard my point as rife with cliches, it's worth noting that we have become very spoilt by ruthlessly frictionless (yet equally effective) customer-facing tech products. The opportunities to streamline processes and save time and money for state-owned interfaces (both online and offline). As an example, I recently had to queue in a hospital with my sick mother for an hour, to be told that that individual couldn't process our particular issue and that we would have to join the back of the adjacent queue (not there was zero signposting whatsoever). This is one example and not a criticism on healthcare, but what happened to service-driven processes? Instead we, the public, have to live with the dire reality of inefficient (and increasinly apparently indifferent) government services as the gap between private and state run services continues to expand as we grow increasingly disenfranchised.
- bpchaps 11y agoI've been working on something like this for over a year now for Chicago. Most of that time's been spent just simply doing data cleanups. My most recent update from Monday: https://plot.ly/~red-bin/6.embed https://plot.ly/~red-bin/6.embed Pretty fucking proud of that, not gonna lie.
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoThat's a shame. Parking in front of a handicapped-access ramp is a shitty thing to do even if it is legal.
- ghaff 11y agoIt's either legal to park in a spot or not legal to park in a spot. It doesn't work and certainly doesn't scale to have spots where "maybe I shouldn't park there because I might get in someone's way even though it's a legal spot."
- ricardobeat 11y agoThe article mentions that regulations recently changed to allow this, maybe the cops are just using common sense?
- djrogers 11y ago2009 is hardly 'recently'...
- ComteDeLaFere 11y agoYes, it scales like this -> "That's a handicappped-access point, I should park somewhere else." See? Easy.
- tamana 11y agoWhy are wheelchairs rolling into the middle of the street? That seems terribly unsafe.
- thevibesman 11y agoIn 2011, I was given two parking tickets when legally parked in Boston. The first ticket was issued for parking in resident street parking without a permit. I was actually parked just after the sign delimiting the resident parking area[1]. I photographed where I was parked and sent in an appeal which was accepted. A month later, I was parked in the same non-resident street parking and I was issued a ticket for failing to pay a parking meter; the number of the meter I supposedly failed to pay was a LONG block and a half away from where I was parked. Again, I submitted an appeal, but this time it was not accepted. The friend I was visiting when I received these tickets was a producer for a local television news station. She told the story of these two tickets to their investigative reporter who was interested in the story and was going to inquire about it with the Boston PD. Apparently she didn't get anywhere with the story, but Boston PD did stop sending me failure to pay notifications for the fine. [1]: This non-resident street parking was not metered. (EDIT: Foot-note formatting)
- sundvor 11y agoNice. I'm just hoping you won't find out one day that they didn't forget in the form of an arrest warrant or something like that for failure to pay. (Disclaimer: I live in Melbourne, Australia, so that could just be the stuff of fiction for what I know).
- nommm-nommm 11y agoI don't know about Massachusetts but in my state you can look up arrest warrants and criminal citations online. All public information.
- sokoloff 11y agoMA will enforce unpaid fines with non-renewal of MA driver's license or vehicle registration. I don't know with which states MA has a reciprocity agreement for that. (And eventually, I think at 3 overdue tickets, your car is eligible for the boot.) These are civil fines; no arrest warrant will be issued, but I also doubt that just because BPD stopped sending notices that they agree the ticket was bogus and have deleted it. Far more likely is they just stopped sending notices and the ticket is still active.
- kevin_thibedeau 11y agoThe T intersection at Virginia Avenue is not legal. The ramps serve an unmarked crosswalk as exists at all intersections in NY state.
- re 11y agoApparently it is legal to park there if it's not a marked crosswalk: http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/motorist/parking-regulations.shtml http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/motorist/parking-regulation...
- kevin_thibedeau 11y agoIt is state law. A municipality can't override it.
- tamana 11y agoDo you have a state law reference that covers T intersections?
- kevin_thibedeau 11y agoNY Vehicle and traffic Article 32 S 1202. Stopping, standing or parking prohibited in specified places. 1. Stop, stand or park a vehicle: d. On a cross walk; 2. Stand or park a vehicle, whether occupied or not, except momentarily to pick up or discharge a passenger or passengers: b. Within twenty feet of a cross walk at an intersection, unless a different distance is indicated by official signs, markings or parking meters; Formal definition of a crosswalk in Article 1: S 110. Crosswalk. (a) That part of a roadway at an intersection included within the connections of the lateral lines of the sidewalks on opposite sides of the highway between the curbs or, in the absence of curbs, between the edges of the traversable roadway. (b) Any portion of a roadway at an intersection or elsewhere distinctly indicated for pedestrian crossing by lines or other markings on the surface. In other words there are crosswalks at every intersection whether marked or not. Crosswalks elsewhere must be marked to be recognized as such. That is why the unmarked curb cuts in the middle of a block don't count for parking violations. T intersections are not special in any way and are subject to the same rules as all others.
- Rapzid 11y agoTo me this is an example of how transparency through information services is winning. Eventually this will pervade every aspect of government. We are going to be in a much better place when we can see what our government is doing in fine detail; spending, enforcement, funding(think campaigns), voting history, etc. The technology is there now but we haven't quite reached the point where it's all on the table and expected/demanded.
- caiob 11y agoDidn't ticket enough. I say, ticket all the cars just for being on the street. We need more public transit.
- holdenc 11y agoSad to see that a majority of these bad tickets are in poorer neighborhoods. It seems most of Manhattan (below the Bronx) is relatively ok.
- nowarninglabel 11y agoI thought that too, but we don't know how many of these types of spots exist in Manhattan vs. Brooklyn, it could just be that the poorer neighborhoods happen to have more sidewalk ramps. Would have to do more analysis on the data.
- tamana 11y agoPolice may know where civilians aren't savvy enough to fight illegal tickets.
- ommunist 11y agoIn Russian big cities commercial car evacuation for misparked often bribes policeman to cover their activity. But resistance is futile and there is helping app against that http://peapp.ru http://peapp.ru.
- xapata 11y agoThe best defense we have against bad actors in government (whether intentional or accidental) is ubiquitous public surveillance -- not the government spying on the people, but the people monitoring the government. A cameraphone in nearly every pocket is a good start.
- tn13 11y agoWhenever I visit NY I dont assume anything is legal. If someone tells me walking barefoot is illegal in NY I would believe it. After all they kill people for sharing smoke and all.
- Grishnakh 11y agoIt sure seems like I hear about a lot more authoritarian nonsense like this in the east-coast (namely northeast) cities, and not nearly as much in the west-coast cities.
- agjacobson 11y agoNice. Something like this happened to me in 1979 in Berkeley. You can infer how angry I got. I was too busy, at the end of grad school, to even contest it.
- colordrops 11y agoAn anecdot: when I lived in Manhattan in 2001, I parked near 61st and 1st, between two differing parking signs. I was clearly very close to one, and much further from another, by at least 50 yards. I got a ticket for illegal parking according to the further sign. Being a broke ex-dot-commer, I was furious, so I photographed and measured everything, and put together a seven page report. After a long while, I got a response back from the responsible agency, which agreed that I was in compliance with the parking rules, and thus they would reduce the fine from $100 to $40. What??
- aptwebapps 11y agoProcessing fee. Five bucks plus five per page they had to read.
- kagamine 11y agoI once parked in a free spot and got a ticket with the attendant claiming it was a disabled space. There were no markings or signs so I complained. They told me to get lost and painted a picture of a man in a wheelchair on the spot the week after. This was not in the US, btw. Bloody bureaucrats.
- stonewhite 11y ago'There is no such thing as a plea of innocence in my court. A plea of innocence is guilty of wasting my time. Guilty.'
- glasz 11y agoi've had a similar situation in germany though not related to parking. i fought back while everybody suggested to just pay. after several letters quoting the law, they lowered the fine. i wanted to fight to the end because it was a sign for me that they half-admitted wrong-doing. but, as a sheep, i ended up paying. still hate myself for giving in.
- tantalor 11y agoWeighted average of the two signs?
- Qantourisc 11y ago"..., the department focused training on traffic agents, ..." -> The police got trained, but we are suppose to just know the law. How unjust.
- known 11y agoWhy not http://www.petition2congress.com/ http://www.petition2congress.com/
- DannyBee 11y agoSo, i would wait till they stop before i would declare victory :) Certainly a great step forward, but my cynical view, after dealing with tons and tons and tons of city governments (it used to be my job): It's very easy to issue statements saying they've solved the problem. Rarely do they actually solve the problem :)
- rotrux 11y agoHeadline -- "The NYPD Was Ticketing Legally Parked Cars; Open Data Put an End to It." Expanded & Explicit Translated Headline -- "Some NYPD Officers Were Cutting Corners in a Profession Where Cutting Corners is a Relatively Big Deal. Some People With Computers Did a Fancy Search and Now Those Cops Are Rightfully Getting in Trouble and the Shit Is Stopping" You're welcome.
- taejo 11y agoNobody's getting in trouble.
- tedmiston 11y agoHow do you know that these tickets, given at locations of pedestrian ramps, were not actually due to other things... like uncommon street sweeping hours or those pesky snow parking restrictions that are so hard to keep track of. Is the reason for citation available in the data?
- taejo 11y ago> But thanks to NYC’s Open Data portal, I was able to look at the most common parking spots in the City where cars were ticketed for blocking pedestrian ramps.
- tedmiston 11y agoTo clarify, I was hoping to see validation with reference to the specific citation code(s), etc. For example, open the 2014 data link [0] included at the bottom of the post. When I run: Filter > Violation Description > Contains > ramp There are no results. It's possible there's a bug in the tool or that the violations are encoded using different language, but it's not something that's obvious to me. 0: https://data.cityofnewyork.us/City-Government/Parking-Violations-Issued-Fiscal-Year-2014-August-/jt7v-77mi https://data.cityofnewyork.us/City-Government/Parking-Violat...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bradgessler 11y agoThis is a good reminder that San Francisco went the other direction and blocked Fixed: http://techcrunch.com/2015/10/12/fixed-the-app-that-fixes-your-parking-tickets-gets-blocked-in-san-francisco-oakland-l-a/ http://techcrunch.com/2015/10/12/fixed-the-app-that-fixes-yo...
- tomohawk 11y agoIt's not surprising that a small change like this could be enabled with open data, but big changes? There's been plenty of data related to medicare fraud, veteran's admin fraud, etc, but changing big things like that appears to be a no go even though the cost is tremendous in terms of affected lives and money.
- sleepychu 11y agoSmall steps. I think there's a knee-jerk reaction (and anecdotally I've found government organisations to be particularly guilty of this) of taking analysis like this as embarrassing criticism that needs to be rejected, not embraced. EDIT: Sorry, my point there was - as more things like this happen we should see increased engagement from orgs.
- m0llusk 11y agoIt might make sense to focus on the core issue of pedestrian safety and curb cuts. As someone who rolls to most of my destinations on wheels blocked ramps can be a major inconvenience that might conceivably compete with parking convenience as an issue.
- tibbon 11y agoDozens of motorcyclists in downtown Boston recently had a problem like this. There are 12-hour motorcycle meters (25 cents an hour, woo!), but a parking cop kept issuing tickets for "Over 2 hour parking" at those meters. They assumed they were like the car meters. I challenged my stack of them, and they relented, but refused to actually write me back with how/why this was happening, and how they were upgrading their training. What gets me, is that I doubt they did a search through their system for all such tickets, and then immediately issued refunds- or put through a software patch on their ticketing system to disallow those tickets at motorcycle meters. Refunding can't be that hard.
- c64sys64738 11y agoYou can't park in peace in NY. They hired h1b traffic officers too, I've heard the Americans traffic officers weren't aggressive enough.