3 ms·
If you give out monopolies, then this is what happens. Here's a simple idea to fix this: capitalism. Mandate at least two providers at each prison and let them
by koolba 11y ago
If you give out monopolies, then this is what happens. Here's a simple idea to fix this: capitalism.
Mandate at least two providers at each prison and let them charge whatever they want. Let them race to the bottom so you get the same cheap voip rates the rest of the country has access to.
Oh and if they collude on pricing, throw the management in the same prison.
I bet they'd also start competing on the features the prison cares about too. Like tracking who's calling who, speech to text transcripts, and service levels.
Problem with this approach is that it doesn't allow for the cronyism that is ripe in this type of industry.
- deelowe 11y agoTwo wouldn't be enough: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duopoly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duopoly
- smnrchrds 11y agoNeither is three: https://i.imgur.com/NVsdNIE.png https://i.imgur.com/NVsdNIE.png https://www.reddit.com/r/canada/comments/4e9yjw/competition_in_canada_a_comparison_of_canadian/ https://www.reddit.com/r/canada/comments/4e9yjw/competition_...
- wrboyce 11y agoIt would seem that EU Regulators agree with this sentiment: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-36266924 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-36266924
- wrboyce 11y agoThe linked article describes with a Duopoly is, but not why one would be a problem.
- dragonwriter 11y agoOligopolies (of which duopoly is the minimal example) produce largely the same problems as monopolies, for largely the same reason, once (formal or indirect through signalling) collusion is factored in; competition works when there are enough market participants that a colluding group that can sweep up the whole set of suppliers is impractical to maintain.
- netcan 11y agoMaybe, but realistically not every problem needs a market constructed to fix it. They could just find providers that offers better prices.
- nothrabannosir 11y agoN providers will always be a problem for the consumer, if N is fixed. To get providers to compete, you need not only have many of them, but you need to open the market to new players. The lower the barrier to entry ("disruption"), the higher the incentive for incumbents to stay on top of their game.
- Spooky23 11y agoYou're making some flawed assumptions. The prison wants the cash -- these are revenue contracts that generate a lot of money. The video stuff nets money for the prison operator as and has other benefits. They pull the fiber to the prison in nowhere vile using erate funds for the "schools" in the prison.
- ndespres 11y agoNot to mention the municipalities that benefit. There's a perverse incentive to pick the vendor with the highest price, since the muni will net a higher dollar value on the kickbacks. I'm interested in seeing more about using erate funds to pull fiber and invest in other infrastructure, especially if it's then turned over to a private operator. Do you have any more info about who is doing this, and where?
- Spooky23 11y agoI was wrong about the ERate thing -- it wasn't a prison, but a juvenile detention center. Kiddie prison is considered a school. See: http://usac.org/sl/applicants/beforeyoubegin/non-traditional/eligibility-table.aspx http://usac.org/sl/applicants/beforeyoubegin/non-traditional...
- ndespres 11y agoThanks for the link and the correction. I'm going to look into pulling a list of contractors who have used erate funds for infrastructure upgrades which mainly benefited a private prison telco rather than the incarcerated juveniles.
- eevilspock 11y ago> If you give out monopolies, then this is what happens. Here's a simple idea to fix this: capitalism. I believe you meant "a free market". Please let's stop equating "capitalism" with "free markets"; They are not one-in-the-same, and there are serious problems with the former.
- baddox 11y agoAlso, the commenter's suggestion is not a great way to benefit from market forces: > Mandate at least two providers at each prison and let them charge whatever they want. Let them race to the bottom so you get the same cheap voip rates the rest of the country has access to. If you want market forces to work, just make the most profitable deals with phone providers. Let phone providers pay the prison to be able to sell their phones in the prison.
- ThomPete 11y agoCapitalism is running big parts of the prison system. Creates wrong incentives in that case. With regards to cellphones though of course capitalism is the answer there.
- gshulegaard 11y agoWhile I agree with the ideas you are expressing, I just want to amend your opening: > If you give out monopolies, then this is what happens. Here's a simple idea to fix this: COMPETITION. Monopolies aren't some market externality that only occur outside of capitalism (private ownership of the means of production). Don't mean to split semantic hairs, but I just don't want to perpetuate the mainstream editorializing of "capitalism" into a buzz word meaning something akin to "for private corporations" and that privatization is always better for the market and society.
- dredmorbius 11y agoOddly enough, your statements are directly contradicted by the story. It was under a monopoly -- a national monoply, regulated closely by the federal government -- that the system was, in this case, far better: "AT&T was the exclusive service provider in the industry, and costs for inmates were comparable for similar services outside. But in the 1980s, an antitrust agreement pulled the Bell System apart. Meanwhile, America’s incarceration rate was booming, driven by the war on drugs and more stringent sentencing guidelines. "With AT&T in pieces, upstart phone providers saw dollar signs in the bevy of new "customers" waiting to be served. First, other major telecommunications companies, such as MCI and Sprint, moved in. Then came the specialists — dedicated outfits, like Pay Tel Communications and Global TelLink, willing to appeal to the specific needs of the corrections industry. Providing communications to a literally captive audience was highly profitable, and as these companies grew, they popularized a new kind of contract with local governments. These agreements hinged on an idea formally known as the "site commission contract," though critics often describe them using another word: kickback." "Free market" doesn't by itself sprinkle Magickal Pixiy Duste over all problems and make them go away. A guy wrote a long book about this once, and how unregulated laissez-faire markets tended strongly to special interests and plutonomy. He was named Smith, title is An Inquiry Into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations*. Recommended reading.