6 ms·
Did someone just patent the process of patent trolling? USPTO: 0080270152
- steveklabnik 17y agoJust? This was filed in 2007.
- zaphar 17y agoFrom a cursory examination it looks like it's pretty close. Although this patent seems to be broader than just patent trolling. It looks like it's a patent on asserting patent rights in any situation predatory or non-predatory.
- Dav3xor 17y agoThe US Patent System has just been owned by Kurt Godel. and Halliburton -- oh crap.
- billybob 17y agoOH NO THEY DIDN'T. I already patented 'a method of subverting the patent system by patenting the process of patent trolling." I'm totally going to sue.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- frederickcook 17y ago"[0012]The inventor and the assignee of this patent have no intention of applying the techniques described herein offensively but instead intend to use the patent defensively to discourage patent trolls and the like from extortionist practices." Whew, that could have been bad.
- lotharbot 17y agoThat's actually quite a brilliant hack. I wonder, has it ever been done? X launches a patent-trolling suit to try to get in on Y's patent. These guys launch a countersuit at X for using their patented technique, stalling the original suit. The best part is, the evidence for the countersuit is already known to the court...
- stcredzero 17y agoWorth doing just as a protest.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- CoryMathews 17y agolink gives an error. [Edit] Why the downvote?
- glyphobet 17y agoAnyone have a working URL?
- ramchip 17y agohttp://www.educause.edu/blog/sworona/TrollingforTrolls/168007 http://www.educause.edu/blog/sworona/TrollingforTrolls/16800... has some information. Methods for a first party to acquire and assert a patent property against a second party are disclosed. The methods include obtaining an equity interest in the patent property. The methods further include writing a claim within the scope of the patent property. The claim is written to cover a product of the second party where the product includes a secret aspect. The methods further include filing the claim with a patent office. The methods sometimes include offering a license of the patent property to the second party after the patent property issues as a patent with the claim. The methods sometimes include asserting infringement of the claim by the second party after the patent property issues as a patent with the claim. The methods sometimes include negotiating a cross-license with the second party based on the assertion of infringement of the claim, where under the cross-license the first party obtains a license to an intellectual property right from the second party. The methods sometime include attempting to obtain a monetary settlement from the second party based on the assertion of infringement of the claim.
- tkeller 17y agoChange appft1 to appft in the url
- GavinB 17y agoI think I'll patent "A method and process for mounting a legal defense against patent lawsuits." And next, "A method and process for preventing patent litigation through acquiring patents and threatening to counter sue." I'll be unstoppable!
- domfarr 17y agoperhaps someone should patent the process of patenting the process of patenting. no one will beat that, surely.
- stcredzero 17y agowhy not? It's not like they take prior art into a account.
- eru 17y agoShouldn't this apply to patenting trolling, too?
- stcredzero 17y agoHow about patenting a method of getting a patent despite prior art?
- GHFigs 17y agoThis is a patent application, not a granted patent.
- js3309 17y agoThis is sad. This case has 100 claims. The Examiner on the case is writing 50 page actions, the attorney is writing 20 page responses. Both their time and energy can be used on better things.
- sabat 17y agoSelf-reference has just waved the white flag and gone home.
- NathanKP 17y agoFinally an effective way to end the patent troll: You are using my patented method for patent trolling. I'm suing you!
- andyjdavis 17y agoOnly if a patent on patent trolling was set up up so that it could be used by everyone. I'm guessing its possible somehow to grant a license to use a patent to every person, living or dead, now or in the future for an unlimited period of time.
- harshpotatoes 17y agoAfter reading so many patents in the past week, I've learned a few things such as: "the title is meaningless", and "patents are densely worded and difficult to comprehend for somebody not versed in legalese" So, are there any patent lawyers in our midst who can attest to the meaning of this patent application? Is this actually what it appears to be?
- marcusbooster 17y agoI'm sure you can find prior art on this one.
- zargon 17y agoNon-final rejection was on 2009-10-09. Response submitted on 2010-01-20. I haven't read any of it but you can look up application number 11/741429 at http://portal.uspto.gov/external/portal/pair http://portal.uspto.gov/external/portal/pair.
- cduan 17y agoTwo bases for the rejections: one for lack of statutory subject matter (no machine or transformation under Bilski) and one for obviousness (combining an article about patent trolling with the PTO's prosecution manual makes the claimed method obvious). With regard to subject matter, the applicant makes two arguments: (1) patents are like personal property, so they satisfy the "transformation of matter" prong of Bilski; and (2) one of the steps involves computer research (basically, Google searching), which involves a machine. With regard to obviousness, the patent applicant argues that the prosecution manual does not contain all the steps of the claimed method. In my mind, the big issue is that the applicant most likely wrote the claims up based on what other patent trolls have done before. Besides the fact that this means that his claims are anticipated by prior use, it means that he is not the original inventor of the claims, making them unpatentable.
- dotBen 17y agoHalliburton already tried this in 2008. http://techdirt.com/articles/20081107/0118162765.shtml http://techdirt.com/articles/20081107/0118162765.shtml Yes, everyone's favorite "Halliburton".
- andyjdavis 17y agoThe one patent to rule them all!!
- roundsquare 17y agoI suppose it could only have happened with the first (few) patent(s), but someone should have patented "a method for filing a patent."
- kschua 17y agoThis patent shouldn't be allowed. There are lots of prior art. Just ask any patent troll
- dkersten 17y agoPrior art, surely.