4 ms·
It's not an autonomous vehicle. This mode does operate without a human in the driver's seat, but the human is still expected to observe and intervene if things
by mikeash 11y ago
It's not an autonomous vehicle. This mode does operate without a human in the driver's seat, but the human is still expected to observe and intervene if things go wrong. To accommodate the special nature of this, speeds are limited to 1MPH for this particular feature, and the car will move a maximum of 39ft before ending the maneuver.
The problem here is that it's too easy to activate the feature by accident and it's not sufficiently clear when you do so. IMO it needs another confirmation step on the touchscreen after double-clicking the Park button before it goes into the "auto-park after closing the door" mode. It's not a sensor problem; the sensors aren't intended to be foolproof here, they're just a backup.
- ColinDabritz 11y agoPerhaps if the feature requires continuous observation by the driver, it should require a continuous 'hold' of the button to operate?
- mikeash 11y agoBy default, it does. You have to explicitly change a setting (and I believe get a dire warning about what you're about to do) in order to enable it to move hands-off.
- chc 11y agoDoes this include the "double-park and get out" feature this guy went through? I know it works that way with the key fob, but I'd never heard about this way of activating Summon before, and I'm not sure how a dead man's switch would work in this case.
- mikeash 11y agoThe double-park feature isn't available unless you disable the dead man's switch operation.
- Mithaldu 11y agoThanks for that explanation. I was wondering why Tesla's response was so lackadaisy, but given that he: Accepted a beta feature, disabled the safety override, ignored a warning, and failed to observe the car as he was told to; It simply is operator fault. He can be lucky it wasn't one of these power drills with a "perma-on" button, which would've ended much worse for him.
- makomk 11y agoAccording to the release notes introducing the feature there's also no way of activating Summon from the key fob or anything other than the mobile app in that firmware version unless you disable dead man's switch operation, which enables the double-press Park feature. Hopefully they've changed it since but it's like Tesla designed it with only two modes - safe but impractical (get out your mobile, unlock it, launch Tesla app, hold down button) and convenient but unsafe (all activation methods enabled, no dead man's switch). See http://electrek.co/2016/02/17/tesla-new-update-autopark-summon-v7-1-2-12-22-release-notes/ http://electrek.co/2016/02/17/tesla-new-update-autopark-summ... and https://youtu.be/Cg7V0gnW1Us https://youtu.be/Cg7V0gnW1Us
- mikeash 11y agoI don't think using the phone app is particularly impractical. It's usually as convenient to access as the key fob is, and unlocking it and launching the app isn't that hard. I will admit that the first thing I did when I got the update that defaulted to dead-man's-switch operation was to put it back the way it was. But I was careful to understand the implications of what I was doing, at least.
- cynix 11y ago> I don't think using the phone app is particularly impractical. In Australia, we don't have the option of disabling the dead man's switch, so we're forced to use the phone app to control Summon. There are no words in the English language that can begin to describe how frustratingly unreliable it is. Most of the time it simply doesn't work (will say something like "failed to communicate with car"), and even when it does work it tends to lose connection half way and abort. I don't think I've ever managed to complete a Summon without it aborting. This is exacerbated by the fact that the places where I actually need to use Summon tend to be places with poor cell phone reception, e.g. underground car parks. I can't wait for the key fob-controlled Summon to be enabled in Australia. Summon in its current state is basically useless.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>the human is still expected to observe and intervene if things go wrong. To accommodate the special nature of this, speeds are limited to 1MPH for this particular feature, and the car will move a maximum of 39ft before ending the maneuver That's what it does? And it can crash into things? How was this hailed as ground-breaking technology? When it was announced it was on the front page of every technology site.
- eclipxe 11y agoAre you talking about AutoPilot or Summon?
- spullara 11y agoSummon isn't autopilot. It is a pretty lame feature IMHO that I don't think I will ever use as I don't have a garage too small for my car and I avoid parking in similarly tiny parking spots. I know a lot of Tesla S/X owners and none have ever used it.
- Domenic_S 11y agoDude doesn't deserve the downvotes, Tesla's video in TFA says at :06: "SUMMON: The next step in Auto Pilot"
- jonathankoren 11y agoUnless you have positive control over the car -- like a radio controlled toy car -- it's autonomous. It's not like the summon mode is simply disengaging the brake and letting the car roll around randomly.
- ryanmarsh 11y agoIf the car was rolling over my child how would I presumably stop it? Nevermind what it "should" do, how would I stop it?
- mikeash 11y agoYou could press any button on your key fob, press any door handle, or step in front of the car so it detects an obstacle.
- ryanmarsh 11y agoAssuming the driver did summon the car he must not have been paying much attention. Either that or he "butt" summoned it.
- discardorama 11y agoUm, if it detects an obstacle, how did it hit the trailer?
- cynix 11y agoIt doesn't guarantee to detect every obstacle every time.
- _pmf_ 11y ago> It doesn't guarantee to detect every obstacle every time. In Silicon Valley, they call this "eventually safe".
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y agoWhich is probably how it ended up rolling over your child in the (hypothetical) first place.
- mikeash 11y agoIt has ultrasonic sensors in the bumpers. They're too far down to detect a trailer at windshield level, but they'll detect the legs of a person standing in front of it.