5 ms·
In the case of the $0.98 cent drink, CLEARLY, the $1230.00 cost in working the case and holding the accused/guilty is NOT cost effective. Only Walmart and priv
by mjevans 11y ago
In the case of the $0.98 cent drink, CLEARLY, the $1230.00 cost in working the case and holding the accused/guilty is NOT cost effective.
Only Walmart and private prisons benefit from this; everyone else is worse off.
There must be a more effective solution.
Not just a 'better quality of "neighborhood"' at Walmart, but for our society as a whole.
- rlpb 11y ago> CLEARLY I disagree. It's the most cost effective method that we have that prevents stores becoming a free-for-all for shoplifters. This response serves to prevent other, similar crimes. Hidden from the cost of this is the saving society gets by crime not being worse. Higher shoplifting rates would mean higher prices for everyone because stores' security costs would be much higher.
- zardo 11y ago>It's the most cost effective method that we have that prevents stores becoming a free-for-all for shoplifters. We don't have the data to come to that conclusion. What if police responded to a lower percentage of these calls?
- dragonwriter 11y ago> In the case of the $0.98 cent drink, CLEARLY, the $1230.00 cost in working the case and holding the accused/guilty is NOT cost effective. It may not be, but the cost of the drink vs. the cost of enforcement alone is not sufficient to show that. What you'd need to know is the net effect of the enforcement costs -- what future thefts would have happened without them that they prevent by deterrence (general or specific), incapacitation, or rehabilitation (including the particular enforcement actions contribution to the broader deterrent effect of the collective enforcement of similar offenses throughout society.)
- mjevans 11y agoI'm going to go with the 'Rehabilitation' angle here. What if, when presented with video evidence of the crime, there was already a 'plea deal' that was always on the table. Lets say that for 10X the minimum wage cost of the affected items, you could provide community service doing some type of work the community needs and would have otherwise contracted out. In that case, the offender would literally work off the (retail) 'cost' of the drink (maybe also a fixed 'fine' in money or community service time) to the community, also providing some rehabilitation, while the company in question would be pressed in to only writing off whatever loss isn't covered by insurance as at cost shrinkage on their taxes. Note that in this case instead of all of that money spent on corrections and the /peace/ officer is not wasted making a mountain out of a pimple.
- zeveb 11y ago> Only Walmart and private prisons benefit from this; everyone else is worse off. So your proposal is that it be legal to steal items of less than $1,230 in value? Or is it to deprive those accused of stealing items with no more legal representation than the value of those items? Or … what?
- briHass 11y ago> Only Walmart and private prisons benefit from this; everyone else is worse off. That seems a little hyperbolic. Stealing less than $100 in FL is a 2nd degree misdemeanor, usually just punished by a fine and probation. No private prison is making money from a misdemeanor shoplifting arrest. It would be hard to argue that Walmart is profiting: their loss-prevention staff costs money, they have paperwork, and they do lose some merchandise when the shoplifter isn't caught. Walmart may have plenty of negative externalities to discuss, but theft is a crime, and I don't see why they should be expected to ignore it. http://www.criminaldefenselawyer.com/resources/criminal-defense/misdemeanor-offense/shoplifting-charges-florida http://www.criminaldefenselawyer.com/resources/criminal-defe...
- ceejayoz 11y ago> Stealing less than $100 in FL is a 2nd degree misdemeanor, usually just punished by a fine and probation. No private prison is making money from a misdemeanor shoplifting arrest. Fine collection and private probation is just as fucked up. http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2014/04/private-probation http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2014/04/pr... http://www.npr.org/about-npr/314011043/npr-news-investigation-guilty-and-charged http://www.npr.org/about-npr/314011043/npr-news-investigatio...
- rustyfe 11y agoI think the "cost" argument here misses the point slightly. Law and order has value, in and of itself. There's a reason why the punishment for stealing $100 is not a $100 fine. We all benefit from a society where no one steals things. Not to strawman, but for instance, I see no ethical argument that homicide is less serious if you murder a person with a net negative cost to society. Neither murder nor theft are wrong simply because they're expensive. They're wrong without the context of cost. In both cases, cost effectiveness isn't what I would consider the most important thing. However, I 100% agree with you that Walmart is certainly benefitting from the public police force enforcing private security. It's a sticky issue without a clear solution. Crimes are crimes, but there's also a reason we install locks and alarm systems in our homes. By maintaining secure systems, we reduce our vulnerability to crime and our cost to everyone else. I feel like Walmart should do the same.
- monochromatic 11y ago$1,230 is pretty cheap for the benefit to society of deterring crime.
- drcube 11y agoThen why doesn't society pay for it?