4 ms·
In my experience, disclosing my salary to recruiter has only ever had a negative effect.
by collyw 11y ago
In my experience, disclosing my salary to recruiter has only ever had a negative effect.
- peteretep 11y agoWhat's the negative effect it's had?
- evilduck 11y agoAnchoring effect. You're showing your hand in poker before placing bets. You'll never get a substantive increase in pay since the recruiter knows what you're currently willing to work for and that some small percent increase is still a win for you. Big jumps also usually means moving out of the range of jobs you're a "safe" fill for and that makes them view it as a higher risk of not getting paid for the effort trying to place you. If you're not well networked and you're not enough of a rockstar to have companies approaching you out of the blue, your best bet is to control where that salary anchor is placed. There's hardly any way to verify your claim and you're almost always better off placing it at a believably higher position. I mean, companies aren't going to tell your their actual upper bounds for what they'll pay in salary, why should you tell them your actual lower bounds?
- collyw 11y agoWhenever I have done that they have offered very little (or even the same) salary as I am on. One time I was contacted about a role in London offering between 65k and 90k (can't remember exactly, but a range along those lines). I said I would only consider moving for the 90K end. He asked what I was on. I refused to tell him then eventually got wore down and told him my relatively small Spanish salary. He refused to put me through for that saying that it was not usual to get more than 10% more than what I am on. The company was willing to pay more for "the right candidate", but my salary at the time meant I wasn't that candidate. Don't disclose your salary to recruiters.
- SinomaSo 11y agoThis is especially true for London recruiters. I had this happening to me too. Recruiter said "oh you should only ask for 15% top, I don't think we can consider you for the job". Stay away from those recruiters and never negotiate your salary with recruiters.
- rebelde 11y agoYou tell them your real salary? I always gave them a number that was closer to my target range.
- DanBC 11y agoThat's potentially fraud.
- antisthenes 11y agoNot being paid as much as you deserve is actual fraud, though.
- 15155 11y agoIn what way? Who is harmed? In which jurisdiction?
- jeff_tyrrill 11y agoYour salary involves two parties, and you are only one of them. The other party is your employer. By stating an untrue salary, you're fraudulently claiming that your current or previous employer (usually known to your negotiating counterparty) agreed to pay you the stated amount. It's somewhat like lying about a credential.
- artmageddon 11y agoWhy is the business of the new employer to know how much I was making at my previous position? If they would agree to pay me for my skillset alone, that'd be one thing, but otherwise they'll simply use the information from my previous position to give me a de facto raise. Two can play at that game. Also, I could be wrong but I don't think a new employer will contact a previous employer to specifically learn how much a particular individual was earning.
- DanBC 11y agoIf it's not their business you should just not tell them, but instead tell them what you're looking for. But don't lie to them, especially if they're going to pay you more because of that lie.
- chadgeidel 11y agoI would recommend never disclosing salary because the recruiter will always say "oh, you can't possibly expect to make x% more than your current salary" and negotiate from there. When asked, I always say "I am looking for between $Y and $Z" to set the tone. If they continue pushing for my current salary I end the conversation.
- vonmoltke 11y ago> I would recommend never disclosing salary because the recruiter will always say "oh, you can't possibly expect to make x% more than your current salary" and negotiate from there. To which you respond, "Then I guess we won't be working together". If he really cares about your business, he'll come around. If not, then it really doesn't matter either way because your likelihood of getting what you would ask for otherwise is slim.
- rdrey 11y agoI don't mind disclosing my current salary but wouldn't accept any job that's not a 15-20% increase. (Not worth the disruption.)