3 ms·
> Second you completely ignored millions of people who can't be significantly educated or handle significant responsibility, but can hold down low skill repetit
by Alupis 11y ago
> Second you completely ignored millions of people who can't be significantly educated or handle significant responsibility, but can hold down low skill repetitive jobs
You seem to, at the core of your argument, have little faith in people's capabilities.
> Put down your blinders and try looking at the real world
I've done just that. We have an evolving economy, and we need to put things in place to enable a successful transition. Handing people money for nothing is not part of a successful transition; it only postpones the proper solution. That's wrong.
- Retric 11y ago> have little faith in people's capabilities. 2.2% of the US population has an IQ below 70. 8.9% of the US population has an IQ below 80. Not all of these people are capable of being even minimally productive, but some are on the line where they are productive but only in a limited fashion. IQ is of course not the only limitation, intelligent people also often have issues.
- Alupis 11y ago> Not all of these people are capable of being even minimally productive IQ is a horrible indicator, and while influenced by genes, it is also biased by a number of factors, including upbringing environment. As the son of a teacher, I refuse to accept the notion that our "dumbest" folks aren't capable of learning great things. It's attitudes like the one you're presenting that keep these folks down in the dirt. "They just aren't capable of complicated things!"... what hogwash. Even a person with diagnosed learning disabilities can accomplish great tasks given the proper guidance and training. You would have us just give up on them! The devil in me questions the point of life if you just sit around and exist... nothing more. I think we need to agree to disagree here.
- Retric 11y agoEven the Army has long held minimum standards for mental capabilities. This is backed up by a lot of research. I am also a son of a teacher, but that's very different than an actual teacher. I can't picture using that to try and argue from authority. Especially when the lowest end of the scale is segregated from everyone else. Though, I guess wallowing in your ignorance is par for the course.
- Alupis 11y ago> I guess wallowing in your ignorance is par for the course I don't know why you choose to be so hostile? It's a bit condescending, and your position is not any more correct than I. > Even the Army has long held minimum standards for mental capabilities. This is backed up by a lot of research And the same was said about women serving in combat roles... until recently. I also happen to come from a military family, and can attest to the bar being very, very low regarding mental capabilities. I grew up around these folks. It's actually who the military seeks for low rank positions - not independent thinkers, they want compliance without question. You don't get that with highly educated individuals. I know this is anecdotal, but it does have value. Change your outlook, because it's awful. Having zero faith in people's abilities to rise to meet new challenges is odd, to say the least. You seem content to keep people poor, dumb, and useless. A new economy requires higher level of skills and thought. The time to start brewing that ecosystem is now, not later.
- Retric 11y agoSomeone who makes into the Army is a high achiever. A friend's child is sufficiently handicapped that at 20 he is incapable of speech more complex than grunting. He is still capable of relativly simple tasks. But to asume there is a binary choice where every person is either totally disabled or capable of becoming a fortune 500 CEO if they just worked harder is both idiotic and common. There are many people with hopes and dreams who are worthy of respect, but simply can't function at a high level. Increasingly we simply throw them to the wolves as even if they can hold down a simple job that's not enough for rent, which starts a cycle of homelessness and often prison. A living wage is about human decency even for those who have trouble with tasks more complex than mopping a floor.
- Alupis 11y ago> Someone who makes into the Army is a high achiever This is a laughably absurd statement. Majority of enlistees are there exactly because they are not high achievers... A major benefit of the military is the opportunities it provides. They hammer into you responsibility, education, and highly skilled training. Even the lowest performers learn very complex tasks, making the military a fantastic example of what I'm advocating. Perhaps we need programs like this for the general public. > A friend's child is sufficiently handicapped that at 20 he is incapable of speech more complex than grunting I feel for your friend, as this is truly an awful thing to have to deal with. However, this is a false dichotomous claim. This scenario does not apply to any majority of folks in this country (or the world), and you're transforming this into a black and white scenario. In addition, certain types of ailments will permanently necessitate assisted living, even in adulthood, which makes your anecdote even less relevant to this discussion. > is a binary choice where every person is either totally disabled or capable of becoming a fortune 500 CEO if they just worked harder is both idiotic and common Of course it's not a binary choice. I never asserted as such. What I have asserted is, the future of the economy will depend on highly skilled and/or highly educated workers. The idea of the "working class" must shift - otherwise there's no purpose for them... and an economy cannot function with 50-80% of it's workforce only consuming via funds not earned nor supported (via taxes, because taxing a BI is sort of a ridiculous idea) by them. > A living wage is about human decency No it's not. It's about making folks as yourself feel good temporarily. A living wage is never enough. Why not make minimum wage $30 per hour today? It surely would postpone other necessary measures for longer! Inevitably though, we'll have to re-address this issue in a few years time, as we have been doing for 78 years. We have got to figure out a better solution, because the one we have right now is simply not cutting it. Even you agree to this, surely. So no, I won't accept your defeatist attitude. Give up on the poor and stupid because they'll never amount to anything. Don't bother increasing education and training, because they'll never be capable of anything more than mopping floors. Just give them money and don't think about their problems for a couple of years. What absurdity. With this said, we really should end this. You will never agree with me, and I the same with you.